Compensation to visual impairments and behavioral plasticity in navigating ants

Sebastian Schwarz, Léo Clément, Lars Haalck, Benjamin Risse, Antoine Wystrach

Abstract

Desert ants are known to rely heavily on vision while venturing for food and returning to the nest. During these foraging trips, ants memorize and recognize their visual surroundings, which enables them to recapitulate individually learnt routes in a fast and effective manner. The compound eyes are crucial for such visual navigation; however, it remains unclear how information from both eyes are integrated and how ants cope with visual impairment. Here we manipulated the ants’ visual system by covering one of the two compound eyes and analyzed their ability to recognize familiar views in various situations. Monocular ants showed an immediate disruption of their ability to recapitulate their familiar route. However, they were able to compensate for the visual impairment in a few hours by restarting a route-learning ontogeny, as naïve ants do. This re-learning process with one eye forms novel memories, without erasing the previous memories acquired with two eyes. Additionally, ants having learnt a route with one eye only are unable to recognize it with two eyes, even though more information is available. Together, this shows that visual memories are encoded and recalled in an egocentric and fundamentally binocular way, where the visual input as a whole must be matched to enable recognition. We show how this kind of visual processing fits with their neural circuitry.

Introduction: The Challenge of Visual Impairment in Navigation

In biological systems, robustness often implies the ability to function despite partial damage. For humans, losing sight in one eye does not prevent the recognition of familiar environments. This study investigates whether desert ants (Cataglyphis velox) possess similar "inter-ocular transfer" or if their navigation is tied to a more rigid binocular framework. By experimentally capping one compound eye with opaque enamel paint, researchers tested how these foragers integrate visual information and whether they can adapt to a sudden reduction in their visual field. High-resolution trajectories were recorded in natural environments in Seville, Spain, using a custom video tracking system developed by the Risse group to digitize paths in cluttered terrain.

Immediate Navigational Failure and Motor Bias

Initial tests on "just-capped" ants revealed a complete failure to navigate familiar routes. Without the full binocular input they were trained on, 100% of these ants failed their initial homing attempts, veering off-course significantly. Beyond memory failure, monocularity induced a persistent motor bias, causing ants to turn repeatedly toward their uncapped side. This suggests that the ant's navigational system requires a precise match of the entire visual field to trigger memory retrieval; any deviation, such as the loss of half the visual field, acts as a "password change" that locks the ant out of its own memories.

Immediate behavioral disruption and subsequent compensation following monocular eye-capping.

Behavioral Plasticity: Re-learning the World

Remarkably, the ants demonstrated significant behavioral flexibility. When their familiar world became unrecognizable due to the eye-cap, they spontaneously reverted to a "learning ontogeny"—the same sequence of pirouetting learning walks performed by naive ants first leaving the nest. Through this process, they acquired new monocular memories. As shown in Figure 1, navigational efficiency improved rapidly over successive trials. Path straightness and directionality increased significantly from Trial 1 to Trial 4, reaching near-normal performance levels as the ants successfully "re-learned" the route with one eye.

Trajectories and navigational metrics showing the progression of learning in monocular ants over successive trials.

Parallel Memories and the Binocular Constraint

The study found that these new monocular memories exist in parallel with, rather than replacing, the original binocular ones. When the eye-cap was removed, ants could immediately navigate using their original memories. Conversely, ants that learned a route only while monocular were unable to navigate it once both eyes were open; the additional visual information acted as a mismatch, preventing memory recall. This supports a "coincidence detector" model where Kenyon Cells in the mushroom bodies likely require simultaneous, specific input from both eyes to fire. If the pattern is broken by adding or removing an eye's input, the environment is perceived as entirely novel.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While the ant's neural architecture for visual memory appears fundamentally binocular and rigid, its behavioral repertoire is highly plastic. This allows the organism to recover from severe sensory impairment by essentially starting over. Future work will aim to confirm the proposed neural mechanisms through direct recordings and explore the long-term resolution of sensory-motor defects. This research provides a striking example of how simple neural rules can underlie complex, adaptive behaviors in natural environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Desert ants are known to rely heavily on vision while venturing for food and returning to the nest. During these foraging trips, ants memorize and recognize their visual surroundings, which enables them to recapitulate individually learnt routes in a fast and effective manner. The compound eyes are crucial for such visual navigation; however, it remains unclear how information from both eyes are integrated and how ants cope with visual impairment. Here we manipulated the ants’ visual system by covering one of the two compound eyes and analyzed their ability to recognize familiar views in various situations. Monocular ants showed an immediate disruption of their ability to recapitulate their familiar route. However, they were able to compensate for the visual impairment in a few hours by restarting a route-learning ontogeny, as naïve ants do. This re-learning process with one eye forms novel memories, without erasing the previous memories acquired with two eyes. Additionally, ants having learnt a route with one eye only are unable to recognize it with two eyes, even though more information is available. Together, this shows that visual memories are encoded and recalled in an egocentric and fundamentally binocular way, where the visual input as a whole must be matched to enable recognition. We show how this kind of visual processing fits with their neural circuitry. Significance Statement If humans look at the world with both eyes, they have no problem to then recognize it with one eye only, and vice-versa. Thus, our way of encoding the world is robust to changes of the visual field. Yet ants do so very differently. Views learnt with two eyes can only be recognized with two eyes, and views learnt with one eye can only be recognized with one eyes (the same eye). However, this rigidity is compensated by a remarkable behavioral flexibility. Upon covering one eye, ants – which can no longer recognize their familiar surroundings – will restart a learning process to store these novel visual inputs in a parallel memory and resume their normal foraging activity.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{schwarz2024compensation,
  author = {Sebastian Schwarz and Léo Clément and Lars Haalck and Benjamin Risse and Antoine Wystrach},
  title = {{Compensation to visual impairments and behavioral plasticity in navigating ants}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.2410908121},
}
Figure