Comparison of capillary and venous blood for malaria detection using two PCR based assays in febrile patients in Sierra Leone.

Tomasz A. Łęski, Chris R. Taitt, Umaru Bangura, Joseph Lahai, Joseph M. Lamin, Victoria Baio, Mohamed S Koroma, Abdulai G. Swaray, Kathryn H. Jacobsen, Olivia Jackson, Brian W. Jones, Cynthia L. Phillips, Rashid Ansumana, David A. Stenger

Introduction

In the global effort to control and eliminate malaria, the sensitivity of diagnostic tools is paramount. While rapid diagnostic tests (RDTs) and microscopy remain the primary methods for clinical diagnosis, Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) is considered the "gold standard" for detecting low-density infections and for use in surveillance. A practical challenge in clinical and field settings is the choice of blood source: capillary blood (obtained via finger prick) or venous blood (obtained via venipuncture).

Capillary blood is significantly easier and less invasive to collect, making it ideal for pediatric populations and resource-limited settings. However, biological differences between the two blood types—including the potential for Plasmodium-infected erythrocytes to sequester in small capillaries—have raised questions about whether they are diagnostically equivalent. This study sought to resolve this ambiguity by comparing the performance of two different PCR platforms using paired capillary and venous samples from febrile patients in Sierra Leone.

Methods

The researchers conducted a prospective study in Bo, Sierra Leone, enrolling 141 febrile individuals between January and May 2019. Paired capillary and venous samples were collected from each participant and analyzed using two distinct multiplexed PCR assays:

  1. FilmArray Global Fever Panel (GFP): A fully automated, nested PCR system designed for rapid "sample-to-answer" results, detecting 19 pathogens including three malaria markers.
  2. Malaria Multiplex Sample Ready (MMSR): A traditional TaqMan-based real-time PCR assay requiring manual DNA extraction.

By employing both a nested PCR and a one-step PCR approach, the study aimed to determine if the blood source's impact was dependent on the specific molecular platform used.

Results and Discussion

The study found no statistically significant differences in parasite detection or Cycle threshold (Ct) values between capillary and venous blood for either assay. For the GFP assay, the proportion of positive samples was nearly identical (61% venous vs. 56% capillary). Similarly, the MMSR assay showed parity (32% venous vs. 26% capillary).

Venn diagrams illustrating the overlap in malaria detection between venous and capillary blood samples for the GFP and MMSR assays.

While the blood source did not significantly affect results, the choice of assay did. The GFP (nested PCR) was notably more sensitive than the MMSR (one-step PCR), detecting Plasmodium in over half the samples, whereas MMSR missed approximately 22% of those positives. This suggests that the diagnostic platform's sensitivity is a more critical factor than the blood collection method.

Furthermore, the data did not support the theory of parasite sequestration in capillary blood. Ct values, which serve as a proxy for parasite density, were highly correlated between the two blood sources across both platforms. This indicates that for febrile patients, the systemic distribution of parasites is sufficiently uniform for either blood source to be used reliably.

Conclusion

The findings provide strong evidence that capillary and venous blood are equivalent for PCR-based malaria diagnostics. This validation supports the use of less invasive capillary sampling for high-sensitivity molecular diagnostics and surveillance. While future studies with larger cohorts—particularly among children where sequestration may be more pronounced—are warranted, these results simplify the logistics of malaria research and clinical management in endemic regions.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> <bold>Background.</bold> Rapid and sensitive diagnostics are critical tools for clinical case management and public health control efforts. Both capillary and venous blood are currently used for malaria detection and while diagnostic technologies may not be equally sensitive with both materials, the published data on this subject are scarce and not conclusive.<bold>Methods.</bold> Paired clinical samples of venous and capillary blood from 141 febrile individuals in Bo, Sierra Leone, were obtained between January and May 2019 and tested for the presence of <italic>Plasmodium</italic> parasites using two multiplexed PCR assays: the FilmArray-based Global Fever Panel (GFP) and the TaqMan-based Malaria Multiplex Sample Ready (MMSR) assay.<bold>Results.</bold> We observed no significant differences in <italic>Plasmodium</italic> parasite detection between capillary and venous blood for both assays. The GFP assay was more sensitive than MMSR for all markers that could be compared (<italic>Plasmodium</italic> spp. and <italic>P. falciparum</italic>) in both venous and capillary blood.<bold>Conclusions</bold>. No difference was found in malaria detection between venous and capillary blood using two different PCR-based detection assays. This data gives support for use of capillary blood, a material which can be obtained easier by less invasive methods, for PCR-based malaria diagnostics, independent of the platform.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{eski2021comparison,
  author = {Tomasz A. Łęski and Chris R. Taitt and Umaru Bangura and Joseph Lahai and Joseph M. Lamin and Victoria Baio and Mohamed S Koroma and Abdulai G. Swaray and Kathryn H. Jacobsen and Olivia Jackson and Brian W. Jones and Cynthia L. Phillips and Rashid Ansumana and David A. Stenger},
  title = {{Comparison of capillary and venous blood for malaria detection using two PCR based assays in febrile patients in Sierra Leone.}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.2.22092/v3},
}
Figure