Comparison of 0-D, 1-D and 2-D model capabilities for tidal range energy resource assessments

Athanasios Angeloudis, Matthew D. Piggott, Stephan C. Kramer, Alexandros Avdis, Daniel Coles, Marios Christou2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper compares three modeling approaches (0-D, 1-D, and 2-D) for assessing tidal range energy resources and their environmental impacts. It highlights that while simpler models are computationally efficient, more complex 2-D models are crucial for accurately capturing the hydrodynamic effects of larger tidal energy projects and their environmental consequences.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Tidal range energy projects, such as tidal barrages and lagoons, offer a predictable and large-scale source of renewable electricity. However, their feasibility and potential environmental impacts are challenging to quantify due to a lack of standardized methodologies and inconsistencies in how tidal power plants are modeled. Different studies use varying representations of operational algorithms, turbine technology, and spatial dimensions, making direct comparisons of proposed designs difficult. This paper aims to address this by systematically comparing the capabilities and limitations of 0-D, 1-D, and 2-D modeling approaches for resource assessment and hydrodynamic impact evaluation.

Methods

The authors present a hierarchy of models, progressively introducing spatial dimensions:

  • 0-D (Zero-Dimensional) Model: This simplified model treats the tidal range structure as a single point. It uses water level time series and operational algorithms to simulate energy generation, accounting for spring-neap conditions and realistic turbine/sluice gate characteristics. It's computationally very efficient.
  • 1-D (One-Dimensional) Model: This model utilizes the Saint-Venant equations to simulate flow along a channel or estuary. It represents tidal range structures as coupled 1-D models of upstream and downstream sections, allowing for the investigation of interactions with regional hydrodynamics. This approach offers a step up in spatial representation from 0-D.
  • 2-D (Two-Dimensional) Model: This is the most sophisticated approach, employing the shallow water equations within the Thetis coastal modeling framework. It captures depth-averaged horizontal velocity and allows for the representation of complex flow patterns, including turbine wakes and intertidal area wetting/drying effects. This model requires significant computational resources.

The study uses a consistent set of operational algorithms and turbine parametrisations (based on a double-regulated bulb turbine) across all three models to ensure fair comparison.

Datasets

The study uses:

  • Tide gauge data: Observed water level time series from the UK's Tide Gauge Network (specifically for the Severn Estuary and Bristol Channel) are used to validate the 1-D and 2-D model predictions.
  • TPXO database: This database is used to provide tidal forcing (eight constituents) at the seaward boundaries for the 1-D and 2-D models.
  • Case Study Specifications: Data for two specific UK tidal range proposals are used: the Swansea Bay tidal lagoon and the Severn Barrage. These include surface area, capacity, turbine diameter, generator poles, number of turbines, and sluice gate area.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing data was used for validation and case studies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Spatial Resolution Matters: The choice of model dimensionality significantly impacts energy output predictions and the assessment of hydrodynamic impacts.
  • 0-D Overestimation: The 0-D model tends to overestimate energy output, especially for larger schemes, as it neglects the influence of the structure on local tidal levels and flow dynamics.
  • 1-D as a Compromise: The 1-D model offers a better representation of regional hydrodynamics than 0-D and can be useful for optimizing smaller projects or for initial assessments due to its computational efficiency compared to 2-D.
  • 2-D for Environmental Impacts: For accurate assessment of environmental impacts (e.g., wake effects, sediment transport, water quality), 2-D (and potentially 3-D) modeling is essential. These effects cannot be captured by simpler models.
  • Turbine Parametrization is Crucial: The accuracy of turbine performance models (hill charts) and their integration into the simulations are critical for reliable energy predictions.
  • Pumping Benefits are Complex: While pumping can increase energy gains, its effectiveness is highly dependent on turbine efficiency and the scale of the project, with potential for increased losses in larger schemes.

Key Results

  • Computational Time: The 0-D model required 0.01 hours, the 1-D model 0.15 hours, and the 2-D model 48.0 hours for a one-month simulation, highlighting the significant computational cost of higher-dimensional models.
  • Energy Predictions: The 0-D model generally overestimated energy output compared to 1-D and 2-D models. For the Severn Barrage, the 0-D and 1-D models showed significant deviations in upstream water level predictions compared to the 2-D model.
  • Model Agreement: Qualitative agreement was observed between the three models for the Swansea Bay lagoon, but more significant differences emerged for the larger Severn Barrage scheme.
  • Validation: The 1-D and 2-D models showed good agreement with tide gauge data for established hydrodynamics in the Severn Estuary and Bristol Channel, with the 1-D model's accuracy slightly decreasing in the more complex estuary regions. The 2-D model achieved high correlation coefficients (R²) for water level predictions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Domain Limitations: The 2-D model's computational domain for the Severn Barrage was noted as potentially insufficient to fully capture far-field hydrodynamic impacts.
  • Environmental Impact Complexity: The paper acknowledges that even 2-D models have limitations in fully capturing environmental impacts like stratification and water quality alterations, suggesting the need for 3-D modeling.
  • Pumping Benefits Understudied: The detailed examination of pumping benefits, especially for larger projects, requires further investigation.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest extending the models to 3-D for more comprehensive environmental impact assessments, improving model scalability for increased resolution in areas of interest, and integrating these models into iterative design optimization frameworks. They also emphasize the need for standardized technical specifications and boundary conditions for reproducible and comparable studies in the tidal energy industry.

Summary updated

Abstract

Tidal range energy projects present an attractive means for the predictable and large-scale generation of electricity from the marine environment. In particular, proposals are under consideration in UK waters, with their feasibility currently being under high levels of scrutiny. This is due to a combination of potential environmental and socio-economic impacts that are challenging to quantify in the absence of a standardised methodology. At present, numerical models are being developed to provide robust resource/impact assessments and inform future designs. However, modelling inconsistencies in the representation of tidal power plants, operational algorithms, and turbine technology parameters can be observed in the studies to-date. This has made comparisons between proposed designs difficult to accomplish and rely upon. We present a series of models that progressively and consistently introduce spatial dimensions in resource prediction applications. The capabilities and limitations of each of these models are discussed with regard to the evaluation of energy resource and potential hydrodynamic impacts of tidal power plant proposals. Results highlight that a range of hydrodynamic scales should be considered, employing updated parametric models relating to the turbine technology capabilities. These steps will inform optimisation analyses and the robustness of tidal power plant proposals.
BibTeX
@misc{angeloudis2017comparison,
  author = {Athanasios Angeloudis and Matthew D. Piggott and Stephan C. Kramer and Alexandros Avdis and Daniel Coles and Marios Christou},
  title = {{Comparison of 0-D, 1-D and 2-D model capabilities for tidal range energy resource assessments}},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.31223/osf.io/sjxf4},
}

Loading related content...

Figure