Comparing downwind shielding of noise walls and berms

Timothy Van Renterghem, Dick BotteldoorenGhent 2012

Introduction

Vertical noise walls are a standard solution in highway engineering for mitigating traffic noise. However, their effectiveness is significantly compromised when wind blows from the source toward the receiver. This degradation is primarily due to Screen-Induced Refraction of Sound (SIROS). When wind encounters a vertical barrier, it creates sharp vertical gradients in wind speed just above the structure. These gradients act as an acoustic lens, refracting sound waves downward into the "shadow zone" intended for protection. This study investigates whether earth berms, characterized by smoother aerodynamic profiles, can mitigate these wind-induced effects.

Methodology

The research utilizes a hybrid numerical modeling framework to evaluate various barrier geometries. The approach integrates three distinct computational methods:

  1. Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD): A $k-\epsilon$ turbulence model was employed to simulate wind flow fields over the barriers.
  2. Acoustic Modeling: Near-field interactions between sound and turbulent flow were captured using the Finite-Difference Time-Domain (FDTD) method.
  3. Long-range Propagation: For distances up to 250 meters, the Green’s Function Parabolic Equation (GFPE) method was used to maintain computational efficiency.

The study compared four primary configurations, all maintaining a height of 4 meters: a standard vertical wall, a shifted vertical wall, a steep (1:1) earth berm, and a shallow (3:1) earth berm.

Geometries of the noise barriers compared in the study, including a 4m wall and two berm configurations with 1:1 and 3:1 slopes.

Aerodynamic and Acoustic Performance

The core hypothesis is that the effectiveness of a noise barrier depends on its aerodynamic interaction with the wind. A vertical wall "trips" the airflow, generating the very gradients that undermine its performance. In contrast, a shallow berm allows wind to flow over it with minimal disruption.

Performance in Still Air

In the absence of wind, vertical walls maintain a slight performance advantage. When a wall is positioned at the leading edge of where a berm would begin, it can outperform the berm by approximately 1.3 to 4.1 dBA, depending on the vehicle type and speed.

Performance in Downwind Conditions

The advantage of the vertical wall evaporates under downwind conditions. Wind-induced refraction can reduce a wall's shielding efficiency by 3.5 to 7.8 dBA. While the steep (1:1) berm shows some improvement over the wall, it remains susceptible to wind effects.

The shallow (3:1) berm, however, demonstrates remarkable resilience. Its noise-shielding field remains nearly identical to the no-wind scenario, with wind-induced performance loss typically restricted to less than 1-2 dBA.

Comparison of noise reduction contours for a vertical wall versus a 3:1 berm under no wind, moderate wind, and strong wind conditions.

Discussion and Conclusion

The results indicate that for long-term noise mitigation where downwind conditions are frequent, shallow vegetated berms are superior to traditional vertical walls. Beyond their acoustic stability, berms offer several non-acoustic benefits: they are resistant to graffiti, do not require safety fencing, and can utilize excess construction soil.

The primary constraint for implementing shallow berms is their physical footprint. A 4-meter high berm with a 3:1 slope requires a base width of 24 meters, significantly exceeding the space requirements of a thin vertical wall. Nevertheless, in open landscapes where land is available, the aerodynamic advantages of the 3:1 berm make it the most effective long-term solution for traffic noise reduction.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{renterghem2012comparing,
  author = {Timothy Van Renterghem and Dick Botteldooren},
  title = {{Comparing downwind shielding of noise walls and berms}},
  booktitle = {Ghent},
  year = {2012},
}
Figure