Companion Animal Ownership and Human Well-Being in a Metropolis—The Case of Hong Kong

Paul Wong, Rose Yu, Joe NgaiInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the impact of companion animal ownership on human well-being in Hong Kong, a hyper-urbanized city. Contrary to some expectations, socio-demographic factors like age, gender, housing, and education were found to be stronger predictors of well-being than pet ownership itself, though pets did appear to enhance social connectedness.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As global urbanization accelerates, leading to increased loneliness and alienation in densely populated cities, understanding the role of companion animals in human well-being becomes crucial. While previous research often highlights the positive effects of pet ownership on physical, psychological, and social well-being, the unique environmental and social context of a highly urbanized metropolis like Hong Kong might present different dynamics. This paper aims to explore these dynamics, specifically examining whether companion animal ownership contributes to well-being in such an environment and identifying which factors, including socio-demographics, influence this relationship.

Methods

The researchers employed a web-based survey to collect data from 986 participants in Hong Kong. The survey captured socio-demographic information, companion animal ownership status, and measures of physical, psychological, and social well-being. Statistical analyses included descriptive statistics, Poisson regression to analyze physical well-being (number of unhealthy days), and two-way ANOVA to examine psychosocial well-being (depression, anxiety, stress, and social needs satisfaction) in relation to ownership and socio-demographic variables. A sub-group analysis was also conducted to compare dog owners with other animal owners.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from a web-based survey of 986 participants in Hong Kong. This survey included 674 companion animal owners and 312 non-owners. No external datasets were used for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Socio-demographics Trump Pet Ownership: In the context of Hong Kong, factors like age, gender, housing type, and education level appear to have a more significant influence on an individual's well-being than simply owning a pet. This suggests that the complex interplay of urban living and individual circumstances plays a dominant role.
  • Social Lubricant Effect: While direct impacts on physical and psychological health might be limited or nuanced in this urban setting, companion animals seem to act as a "social lubricant," fostering connections with others and enhancing overall social connectedness.
  • Urban Constraints on Physical Well-being: The cramped living spaces and public policy restrictions in Hong Kong (e.g., dog prohibition in public housing) may limit the potential for companion animals to promote physical activity, thus moderating their positive impact on owners' physical health.
  • Age and Social Well-being: Older individuals, in general, reported higher levels of social well-being (satisfaction in relationships). Companion animal ownership appeared to moderate this effect, though this was less pronounced in the oldest age group.
  • Education and Social Well-being Interaction: Companion animal ownership had a more significant positive impact on social well-being for individuals with lower levels of education, suggesting pets might be particularly beneficial for social support in this demographic.

Key Results

  • Physical Well-being: Contrary to expectations, companion animal owners reported a higher number of unhealthy days (2.99) compared to non-owners (1.97). However, owners were more likely to engage in walking for 10 minutes or more.
  • Psychological Well-being: Owners reported marginally lower anxiety levels, but no statistically significant differences were found in depression or stress levels between owners and non-owners.
  • Social Well-being: Owners reported higher satisfaction in terms of autonomy, competence, and relatedness in their relationships with significant others.
  • Socio-demographic Differences: Statistically significant differences were found between owners and non-owners in gender, age, income, education, housing type, and number of occupants. Owners were more likely to be female, older (40-59), have higher incomes, and live in private housing with fewer occupants.
  • Dog Ownership vs. Other Animals: No statistically significant differences were found in physical, psychological, or social well-being between dog owners and owners of other types of companion animals.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Sampling Bias: The web-based survey likely led to an oversampling of companion animal owners, potentially affecting the generalizability of findings.
  • Subjective Health Measure: The reliance on a single-item, subjective measure for physical health is noted as a potential issue for validity.
  • Limited Sample Size in Subgroups: The small number of participants in certain age groups (e.g., under 19, ≥60) limits the robustness of findings for those demographics.
  • Focus on "Significant Others": The study primarily examined social well-being in relation to "significant others" (spouse/best friend), and future research could explore broader social networks (e.g., neighbors).

Future work is recommended to include:

  • More rigorous studies with larger, more representative samples and improved sampling methods.
  • Further exploration of the unique ecological factors in Hong Kong that might influence the human-animal bond.
  • Investigating the impact of companion animal ownership on broader social relationships beyond immediate significant others.
  • Developing policies and facilities that support the human-animal bond and the well-being of both humans and their companion animals in urban environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

Global urbanization has given cause for a re-assessment of the nature and importance of the relationship between humans and domesticated animals. In densely-populated urban societies, where loneliness and alienation can be prevalent, the use of animals as human companions has taken on heightened importance. Hong Kong is the world's most urbanised political entity, and thus provides an ideal context for the exploration of the role of animals in the provision of companionship for human beings in cities. A web-based survey with descriptive analyses, regression, and ANOVA was conducted. Six-hundred-and-forty-seven companion animal owners and 312 non-owners completed the survey that examined their socio-demographic information, companion animal ownership status, and physical-psychosocial well-being. The statistically significant findings appear to suggest that socio-demographic variables (i.e., age, gender, housing, and education level) have stronger predictive values than companion animal ownership status with respect to the well-being of people in Hong Kong. Due the unique environmental features in Hong Kong, the positive impacts of companion animal ownership on the physical well-being of owners may be limited by the city's cramped living space and the limited number of people who own companion animals. However, results suggested that companion animals may still serve as a social lubricant between the owners and their significant others, thereby playing a heightened role significant role in enhancing general social connectedness in a metropolis. Given the importance of animals as human companions, it is suggested that relevant administrative agencies need to consider the development of policies and facilities which are conducive to both the maintenance and development of the bonds between humans and their companion animals and the physical and psychosocial health of both.
BibTeX
@article{wong2019companion,
  author = {Paul Wong and Rose Yu and Joe Ngai},
  title = {{Companion Animal Ownership and Human Well-Being in a Metropolis—The Case of Hong Kong}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph16101729},
}
Figure