Communication: Exciton–phonon information flow in the energy transfer process of photosynthetic complexes

Patrick Rebentrost, Alán Aspuru‐GuzikThe Journal of Chemical Physics 2011 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new way to quantify "non-Markovianity" – the tendency for information to flow back and forth between electronic and vibrational parts of molecules – in photosynthetic systems. They found that this information backflow is significant even at physiological temperatures, suggesting it plays a crucial role in the highly efficient energy transfer observed in nature.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Photosynthesis relies on incredibly efficient energy transfer, moving captured light energy from antenna molecules to a reaction center. This process is thought to be aided by quantum effects, specifically "excitonic coherence," where energy exists in multiple locations simultaneously. A key challenge in understanding this is the complex interplay between the electronic states (where the energy is) and the vibrational states (the molecule's internal jiggling). Traditional models often assume a simple, one-way flow of information from electronic to vibrational degrees of freedom (Markovian assumption). However, recent experiments suggest that this might not be the whole story, especially in systems with "intermediate exciton-phonon coupling." This paper tackles the question of how much information actually flows back from the vibrational modes to the electronic ones, a phenomenon known as non-Markovianity, and whether this backflow is important for photosynthetic energy transfer.

Methods

The authors employ two main tools:

  1. Hierarchical Equation of Motion (HEOM): This is a sophisticated theoretical framework designed to accurately model systems where electronic and vibrational degrees of freedom are strongly coupled and can be out of equilibrium. It goes beyond simpler models by explicitly accounting for the "memory" effects of the vibrational environment.
  2. Non-Markovianity Measure: They adapt a recently developed measure based on the trace distance between quantum states. The trace distance quantifies how distinguishable two quantum states are. If this distance increases over time, it signifies that information is returning to the system, indicating non-Markovian behavior. They specifically look for periods where the trace distance grows, and then integrate this growth over time to get a quantitative measure of non-Markovianity (NM-ity). They also propose an ADO distance measure, which quantifies information flow into the auxiliary degrees of freedom used in the HEOM.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study uses theoretical models of molecular systems (a dimer and the FMO complex) with parameters derived from quantum chemistry studies or experimental data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Information Backflow is Real and Significant: The core finding is that information doesn't just dissipate into the vibrational environment; it can flow back to the electronic system. This "non-Markovian" behavior is not just a theoretical curiosity but appears to be a significant factor in how photosynthetic complexes operate.
  • Physiological Conditions Matter: The paper emphasizes that these non-Markovian effects are observed under conditions relevant to biological systems (e.g., physiological temperatures), making them biologically relevant.
  • New Measure for Information Flow: The proposed trace distance-based measure for non-Markovianity provides a concrete way to quantify this complex information exchange, potentially applicable to other quantum systems.
  • Model Systems Reveal Key Dependencies: Studying simplified models (dimer) and a more complex, biologically relevant system (FMO complex) allows the authors to pinpoint which parameters most influence non-Markovianity.

Key Results

  • Dimer System:
    • The trace distance shows clear "revivals" at intermediate times, indicating information returning to the electronic system.
  • Longer bath correlation times (sluggish environments) lead to more pronounced non-Markovianity.
  • The non-Markovianity measure (NM-ity) is strongly dependent on the coupling between the molecules and is maximized at intermediate reorganization energies.
  • Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) Complex:
    • Similar to the dimer, the FMO complex exhibits significant non-Markovian information flow under physiological conditions.
  • The NM-ity shows a maximum at a specific reorganization energy (around 55/cm), suggesting an optimal balance for this effect.
  • Parameter Sensitivity: The authors systematically scanned parameters like coupling strength, site energy difference, bath dissipation rate, and reorganization energy, revealing their impact on the degree of non-Markovianity.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Truncation Criterion: The HEOM approach requires truncating the hierarchy of auxiliary density operators. While the authors use a criterion that is generally considered robust, it's an approximation. The paper notes that for the FMO complex, using fewer tiers might slightly overestimate NM-ity.
  • Experimental Verification: While the paper uses realistic models, direct experimental measurement of this specific information flow is challenging.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest extending their analysis to other master equations and exploring how to efficiently extract non-Markovianity from experimental techniques like four-wave mixing. They also highlight the potential of ultrafast quantum process tomography for characterizing quantum maps.

Summary updated

Abstract

Non-Markovian and nonequilibrium phonon effects are believed to be key ingredients in the energy transfer in photosynthetic complexes, especially in complexes which exhibit a regime of intermediate exciton-phonon coupling. In this work, we utilize a recently developed measure for non-Markovianity to elucidate the exciton-phonon dynamics in terms of the information flow between electronic and vibrational degrees of freedom. We study the measure in the hierarchical equation of motion approach which captures strong coupling effects and nonequilibrium molecular reorganization. We propose an additional trace distance measure for the information flow that could be extended to other master equations. We find that for a model dimer system and for the Fenna-Matthews-Olson complex the non-Markovianity is significant under physiological conditions.
BibTeX
@article{rebentrost2011communication,
  author = {Patrick Rebentrost and Alán Aspuru‐Guzik},
  title = {{Communication: Exciton–phonon information flow in the energy transfer process of photosynthetic complexes}},
  journal = {The Journal of Chemical Physics},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1063/1.3563617},
}
Figure