Communication dynamics in twitter during political campaigns: The case of the 2011 Spanish national election

Pablo Aragón, Karolin Eva Kappler, Andreas Kaltenbrunner, David Laniado, Yana VolkovichPolicy 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper analyzes Twitter communication during the 2011 Spanish national election, revealing that political parties primarily use the platform for one-way broadcasting rather than genuine conversation. Despite some cross-party interaction, the study highlights a significant trend of "balkanization," where users primarily engage with those of similar political ideologies, potentially impacting democratic discourse.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing prevalence of social media in politics presents a challenge: how do political actors adapt to this new communication paradigm, and what are the resulting dynamics of online political discourse? Specifically, this paper investigates how Spanish political parties utilized Twitter during their 2011 national election campaign. It aims to understand their communication strategies, the nature of their interactions (both within and between parties), and whether Twitter serves as a tool for genuine dialogue or merely a broadcast channel, all within the context of Spain's unique electoral laws and media landscape.

Methods

The researchers employed a mixed-methods approach, combining quantitative analysis of Twitter data with network analysis techniques.

  • Data Collection: A large dataset of over 3 million tweets related to the 2011 Spanish national election was collected, focusing on tweets containing campaign hashtags, from official party accounts, or from users identified as activists, journalists, or media channels.
  • Activity and Emotional Load Analysis: The daily volume of tweets was analyzed to identify peaks corresponding to key campaign events like debates and election day. Sentiment analysis was performed on tweets from the two major parties (PSOE and PP) to gauge the emotional tone of their communication.
  • Network Analysis:
    • Retweet Networks: To study information diffusion, retweet networks were constructed. The Louvain method was used for community detection to identify clusters of users. Macroscopic metrics like clustering coefficient, giant component size, and average distance were calculated to assess network structure.
  • Reply Networks: To analyze conversation patterns, reply networks were built. Similar network analysis techniques were applied to understand inter-party communication and identify central users.
  • Betweenness Centrality: This metric was used to identify influential users within the networks who act as bridges for information propagation.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 3,074,312 political tweets collected from Twitter between November 4-24, 2011, from 380,164 distinct users. The tweets were selected based on campaign-related hashtags, official party profiles, or identified political actors. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the focus was on analyzing existing Twitter data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Twitter as a Broadcast Channel: Major traditional parties, especially, treat Twitter more as a one-way broadcast medium than a platform for genuine two-way conversation.
  • Balkanization is Real: The online political sphere in Spain, as in other countries, exhibits a strong tendency towards "balkanization," where users primarily interact with and consume content from those who share their political ideology.
  • Offline Events Drive Online Activity: Key offline events like televised debates and election day significantly boosted Twitter activity, demonstrating a strong interplay between traditional and social media.
  • Emotional Resonance of Winning: The winning party (PP) exhibited more positive sentiment in their tweets leading up to and on election day, potentially reflecting confidence in victory.
  • Minor Parties' Digital Advantage: Parties with less traditional media coverage (like UPyD and EQUO) showed a greater propensity to leverage Twitter for message promotion, resulting in more cohesive and clustered network structures.
  • Candidates as Central Hubs: For most parties, candidates acted as central figures in their online networks, particularly in conversation patterns.

Key Results

  • Tweet Volume Peaks: The highest tweet volumes occurred on the day of the debate between the leading candidates (over 500,000 tweets) and on election day (over 400,000 tweets).
  • Retweet Balkanization: Over 97% of retweets between political parties occurred within the same party, strongly supporting the balkanization hypothesis.
  • Reply Diversity (Slight): While retweets were highly insular, reply networks showed slightly more diversity, with some inter-party communication, particularly between parties of similar ideological leanings (e.g., PSOE-PP, IU-EQUO, ERC-CiU). However, intra-party replies still dominated (79-93%).
  • Minor Party Network Structure: Parties with limited mass-media coverage (EQUO, UPyD) exhibited higher clustering coefficients and more cohesive networks compared to major parties.
  • Candidate Centrality: In reply networks, candidates were often the most central users, suggesting a preference for dialogue with other politicians rather than directly with the general public.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on Major Parties: While the study analyzed seven parties, the in-depth analysis of emotional load was limited to the two major parties (PSOE and PP) due to data volume.
  • Causality: While correlations between offline events and online activity were observed, establishing direct causality remains challenging.
  • Future Research: The authors propose extending this analysis to future elections with greater uncertainty in outcomes to better understand the role of social media in predictions. They also aim to explore topological patterns of party networks in more detail and contrast them with networks formed by grassroots movements, as well as investigate the effect of emotions on information diffusion dynamics.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The irruption of social media in the political sphere is generating repositories of “Big Data,” which can be mined to gain insights into communication dynamics. The research reported here relies on a large data set from Twitter to examine the activity, emotional content, and interactions of political parties and politicians during the campaign for the Spanish national elections in November 2011. The aim of this study is to investigate the adaptation of political parties to this new communication and organizational paradigm originating in the evolution of the Internet and online social networks. We analyze the reply and retweet networks of seven political parties with significant offline differences to assess their conversation and information diffusion patterns. We observe that political parties, and especially the major traditional parties, still tend to use Twitter just as a one‐way flow communication tool. Moreover, we find evidence of a balkanization trend in the Spanish online political sphere, as observed in previous research for other countries .
BibTeX
@inproceedings{aragon2013communication,
  author = {Pablo Aragón and Karolin Eva Kappler and Andreas Kaltenbrunner and David Laniado and Yana Volkovich},
  title = {{Communication dynamics in twitter during political campaigns: The case of the 2011 Spanish national election}},
  booktitle = {Policy},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1002/1944-2866.poi327},
}
Figure