Common species link global ecosystems to climate change: dynamical evidence in the planktonic fossil record

Bjarte Hannisdal, Kristian Agasøster Haaga, Trond Reitan, David Diego, Lee Hsiang Liow

Abstract

Common species are the primary drivers of ecosystem structure and function, yet paleobiological research often focuses on species richness, a metric prone to sampling bias. This study utilizes the global occupancy of planktonic foraminifera over the last 65 million years to track ecosystem responses to climate forcing. By introducing the Summed Common species Occurrence Rate (SCOR), we demonstrate a robust, dynamical coupling between deep-ocean temperatures and the commonness of planktonic species. Our findings suggest a time-delayed causal link, potentially mediated by ecological factors such as mixotrophy, which connects global abundance to long-term climatic shifts.

The Limitations of Species Richness

In ecology and paleobiology, biodiversity is frequently measured through species richness—the total count of different species. However, richness can be a misleading indicator of ecosystem health. In most biological communities, a small number of common species account for the vast majority of biomass and nutrient cycling. If these dominant species decline, the ecosystem's functional integrity may be compromised even if the total species count remains stable.

Furthermore, estimating richness from the fossil record is challenging due to sampling biases. Rare species are often missed in sediment cores, creating "noisy" data that can obscure true ecological trends. To address this, we focus on "commonness" as a more stable and functionally relevant metric for tracking long-term ecosystem response to environmental change.

Methods: The SCOR Metric

We developed the Summed Common species Occurrence Rate (SCOR) to measure global occupancy—the proportion of sampled sites where a species is observed. Unlike richness metrics, SCOR focuses on the most widespread taxa, making it less sensitive to the disappearance of rare species or fluctuations in sampling intensity.

The SCOR formula defines the metric as the sum of occurrences for a set of common species across sampled sites.

To validate this approach, we utilized the Poseidon numerical simulation model. These simulations allowed us to compare SCOR against traditional richness estimators (such as Shannon entropy) under varying conditions of sampling completeness and changes in species abundance distributions.

Simulation data from the Poseidon model illustrating the relationship between sampled sites, occurrences, evenness (J), and Rank Abundance Distribution (RAD) shape (σ) over time.

Detecting Dynamical Coupling

To move beyond simple correlation, we applied three independent mathematical frameworks to detect causality between climate (Deep-Ocean Temperature, or DOT) and biology (SCOR):

  1. Convergent Cross Mapping (CCM): Detects causality in non-linear, deterministic systems.
  2. Information Transfer (IT): Measures the directional flow of information between time series.
  3. Stochastic Differential Equations (SDEs): Uses Bayesian inference to model probabilistic connections.

All three methods converged, confirming that changes in deep-ocean temperatures causally drive changes in the commonness of planktonic foraminifera. Notably, the SDE models identified a significant time lag of approximately 0.33 to 1.1 million years between the climate signal and the biological response.

Ecological Implications: The Mixotrophy Hypothesis

Our analysis revealed that symbiont-hosting (mixotrophic) foraminifera tend to thrive during warmer periods. We hypothesize that climate-driven changes in ocean stratification expand nutrient-poor (oligotrophic) regions, giving mixotrophs a competitive advantage. This shift in global occupancy suggests that common species act as a bridge, linking large-scale climate forcing to the global carbon pump and other essential ecosystem services.

Conclusion

By focusing on common species rather than total richness, we have identified a clear, dynamical link between the Earth's climate and its marine ecosystems over geological timescales. While the causal link is likely indirect—mediated through complex oceanographic changes—the robustness of the SCOR metric provides a new tool for understanding how today's common species might respond to future anthropogenic climate change. Future research using spatially resolved data will be essential to further test the regional mechanisms behind these global trends.

Summary updated

Abstract

Common species shape the world around us, and changes in their commonness signify large-scale shifts in ecosystem structure and function. However, our understanding of long-term ecosystem response to environmental forcing in the deep past is centred on species richness, neglecting the disproportional impact of common species. Here, we use common and widespread species of planktonic foraminifera in deep-sea sediments to track changes in observed global occupancy (proportion of sampled sites at which a species is present and observed) through the turbulent climatic history of the last 65 Myr. Our approach is sensitive to relative changes in global abundance of the species set and robust to factors that bias richness estimators. Using three independent methods for detecting causality, we show that the observed global occupancy of planktonic foraminifera has been dynamically coupled to past oceanographic changes captured in deep-ocean temperature reconstructions. The causal inference does not imply a direct mechanism, but is consistent with an indirect, time-delayed causal linkage. Given the strong quantitative evidence that a dynamical coupling exists, we hypothesize that mixotrophy (symbiont hosting) may be an ecological factor linking the global abundance of planktonic foraminifera to long-term climate changes via the relative extent of oligotrophic oceans.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hannisdal2017common,
  author = {Bjarte Hannisdal and Kristian Agasøster Haaga and Trond Reitan and David Diego and Lee Hsiang Liow},
  title = {{Common species link global ecosystems to climate change: dynamical evidence in the planktonic fossil record}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1098/rspb.2017.0722},
}
Figure