Comment on "Fluctuation theorem for hidden entropy production"

Yongjoo Baek, Meesoon Ha, Hawoong Jeong, Hyunggyu ParkarXiv 2014 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The transition from time-reversible microscopic dynamics to irreversible macroscopic behavior remains a central puzzle in statistical mechanics. Recently, Kawaguchi and Nakayama (KN) proposed that "hidden entropy production"—the entropy lost during a coarse-graining procedure—satisfies the Integral Fluctuation Theorem (IFT) only if the system lacks odd-parity variables (variables like velocity that change sign under time reversal). They interpreted this as evidence that odd-parity variables are fundamental to the emergence of irreversibility. In this Comment, Baek et al. challenge this interpretation, arguing that the KN framework is mathematically inconsistent and fails to capture the physical transition from deterministic to stochastic dynamics.

Introduction

One of the deepest questions in physics is the "Arrow of Time": How do we derive messy, irreversible macroscopic behavior from the clean, time-reversible laws of microscopic physics? In 2013, Kawaguchi and Nakayama (KN) suggested that the bridge between these two worlds lies in how we simplify systems through coarse-graining. They argued that the hidden entropy production ($\Xi$) resulting from this simplification obeys the IFT ($\langle e^{-\Xi} \rangle = 1$) specifically when odd-parity variables are absent. This led to the conclusion that such variables play a unique role in the emergence of macroscopic irreversibility.

Baek et al. provide a formal critique of this claim, demonstrating that the KN approach is built on a problematic mathematical foundation. They argue that the framework fails to describe the origin of irreversible stochastic dynamics, calling into question the supposed importance of odd-parity variables.

Theoretical Critique

The Initialization Flaw

A core issue identified by Baek et al. is the definition of the time-reversed process. For entropy production to be a meaningful indicator of irreversibility, the time-reversed path must be properly initialized. The authors demonstrate that KN’s choice of initial conditions for the reverse process leads to mathematical inconsistencies. Specifically, if the reverse process is not started correctly, the probabilities of certain trajectories effectively drop to zero, rendering the resulting entropy values ill-defined. Baek et al. show that the IFT for hidden entropy production is only satisfied under specific, somewhat arbitrary choices for the time-reversed process, which undermines the physical generality of the original claim.

Determinism vs. Stochasticity

A significant insight from the critique is that coarse-graining a deterministic system does not inherently produce stochastic (random) behavior. If one simply "hides" variables in a deterministic Hamiltonian system, the underlying dynamics remain deterministic; the only source of randomness is the initial uncertainty.

To derive true stochastic equations—such as the Langevin equation or a random walk—a system must exhibit a "memory cutoff." This is the mechanism by which a system "forgets" its initial conditions over time. Baek et al. prove mathematically that the KN model lacks this memory cutoff. Consequently, the KN framework cannot explain the transition from deterministic microscopic laws to the noisy, stochastic dynamics observed in the real world.

Implications for Macroscopic Irreversibility

By highlighting these flaws, the authors call into question whether odd-parity variables are actually required for macroscopic irreversibility. They point out that other established results in statistical mechanics, such as the Evans-Searles theorem, explain irreversibility without needing to invoke the parity of variables.

The critique suggests that the "secret sauce" for irreversibility is likely the loss of information over time (the memory cutoff) rather than the specific nature of the variables being coarse-grained. While the authors do not strictly disprove that odd-parity variables might play some role in certain contexts, they demonstrate that the KN proof for their necessity is inadequate.

Conclusion

Baek et al. conclude that the KN framework is insufficient for describing the emergence of irreversible stochastic dynamics from reversible deterministic ones. By clearing away this misleading explanation, the authors refocus the discussion on the importance of memory loss and the proper definition of time-reversal in stochastic thermodynamics. Future research into the Arrow of Time should focus on how systems lose the memory of their initial states, as this appears to be the more likely driver of macroscopic irreversibility.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recently, Kawaguchi and Nakayama (KN) [Phys. Rev. E {\bf 88}, 022147 (2013)] showed that the hidden entropy production associated with a coarse-graining procedure obeys the integral fluctuation theorem (IFT) if the original process does not involve any odd-parity variable that changes its sign under time reversal. This was interpreted as the evidence that odd-parity variables play an important role in the derivation of irreversible stochastic dynamics from time-reversible deterministic dynamics. In this Comment, we show that KN's approach is inadequate for describing the origin of irreversible stochastic dynamics, which calls into question whether odd-parity variables are required for the emergence of macroscopic irreversibility.
BibTeX
@misc{baek2014comment,
  author = {Yongjoo Baek and Meesoon Ha and Hawoong Jeong and Hyunggyu Park},
  title = {{Comment on "Fluctuation theorem for hidden entropy production"}},
  year = {2014},
  eprint = {1402.1235},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1402.1235},
}
Figure