Collaborative Communication: A Qualitative Study of Roles and Emphases of Health Care Providers in Obstetrics and Gynecology

Wanqi Gong, Jiamei Tang, Yang Chen, Jing MaJournal of Multidisciplinary Healthcare 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Communication in obstetrics and gynecology (OB/GYN) is a team sport, not a solo performance by the physician. This study reveals how doctors, nurses, and midwives divide the labor of the "SEGUE" communication framework, with nurses and midwives acting as critical emotional anchors and information bridges that alleviate physician workload and reduce clinical disputes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the high-stakes environment of OB/GYN, communication failures are the primary driver of clinical disputes, accounting for over 80% of cases. In many healthcare systems, particularly in China, communication models are often doctor-led and technology-focused, creating a power imbalance and leaving patients feeling unheard.

While the SEGUE framework (Set the stage, Elicit information, Give information, Understand the patient’s perspective, End the encounter) is a gold standard for assessing communication, most research focuses solely on physicians. This paper addresses the "missing pieces" of the puzzle: the specific roles and communication emphases of nurses and midwives, and how these roles shift in the transition to online/offline hybrid care models.

Methods

The researchers conducted a qualitative study using in-depth interviews with 24 healthcare providers (8 doctors, 5 midwives, and 11 nurses) from 3A hospitals in a major Chinese city.

The study utilized an inductive thematic approach to analyze interview transcripts. Researchers coded the data through the lens of the SEGUE framework to identify which professional roles dominated specific stages of the patient encounter. This qualitative approach allowed the team to capture the nuances of "emotional labor" and "authority status" that quantitative surveys often miss.

Datasets

As a qualitative study, there is no large-scale numerical dataset. The "data" consists of the transcribed interviews and field notes from the 24 participants. The participants were selected via purposive sampling to ensure a diverse range of ages, professional titles (from head nurses to chief physicians), and years of employment (ranging from 4 to 37 years).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Communication Pipeline: Communication is a specialized division of labor. Nurses primarily "set the stage" and "elicit information," acting as emotional gatekeepers who soothe anxieties before the doctor arrives. Doctors dominate the "giving information" stage, leveraging their authority to explain diagnoses and treatment plans.
  • Midwives as Holistic Bridges: Midwives occupy a unique middle ground. They are often the primary providers for stable patients (e.g., in nutrition clinics) and are the most likely to focus on "understanding the patient's perspective" and "ending the encounter" with long-term guidance.
  • The Experience Factor: Empathy isn't just a trait; it’s a skill honed over time. The study found that senior providers with higher professional titles demonstrated significantly more patience and a more refined ability to navigate delicate medical discussions than their younger counterparts.
  • Hybrid Consultation Dynamics: The post-pandemic shift to online consultation (via platforms like WeChat) has created a "follow-up complement." While online tools are excellent for routine inquiries and "popularizing science," they are intentionally limited to avoid diagnostic errors due to the lack of physical examination.

Key Results

  • Role Specialization:
    • Doctors: Focus on rational communication and high-risk decision-making.
  • Nurses: Focus on psychological needs, family dynamics, and preliminary data gathering.
  • Midwives: Provide specialized, time-intensive care (often 20+ minutes per patient) that focuses on nutrition and recovery.
  • Conflict Mitigation: The study suggests that "collaborative communication"—where nurses and midwives handle the bulk of routine and emotional interaction—is essential to lowering the "online misdiagnosis rate" and alleviating the heavy workload of obstetricians.
  • Trust as a Cornerstone: All participants identified the cultivation of mutual trust as the single greatest challenge and the most important factor in patient compliance.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Geographic Bias: The sample was limited to major Chinese cities and top-tier (3A) hospitals, which may not represent rural or lower-tier medical environments.
  • One-Sided Perspective: The study only interviewed healthcare providers. Future research needs to incorporate patient feedback to see if their perception of these communication roles aligns with the providers' views.
  • Methodological Scope: The authors suggest that future studies should move beyond interviews to include ethnographic observations and field work to see these communication dynamics in real-time action.

Summary updated

Abstract

The health care providers of different types in obstetrics and gynecology communicate collaboratively with patients, highlighting the equally important role of midwives and nurses when communicating with patients. Nurses focus on "set the stage" and "elicit information" stage. Midwife is another important information source and medical care provider, especially for pregnant women in stable conditions. Nutrition clinic of midwife could be recommended for hospitals in second- and third-tier cities, which could help to alleviate obstetricians' workload. The provision of an online collaborative consultation could be beneficial supplement after face-to-face doctor-patient communication.
BibTeX
@article{gong2024collaborative,
  author = {Wanqi Gong and Jiamei Tang and Yang Chen and Jing Ma},
  title = {{Collaborative Communication: A Qualitative Study of Roles and Emphases of Health Care Providers in Obstetrics and Gynecology}},
  journal = {Journal of Multidisciplinary Healthcare},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.2147/jmdh.s457056},
}
Figure