Co-evolution analysis of novel power system based on Brusselator model

Yunling Wang, Yunche Su, Fang Liu, Yang Liu, Tianxiang Xie, Ao Li, Ke XuFrontiers in Energy Research 2023 · DOI

Abstract

The evolution of the power system is a dynamic and complex process. This study constructs an evolutionary synergy model based on dissipation theory and the Brusselator model to quantitatively analyze the relationship between evolving subjects and the overall system development. By examining macro-environmental, meso-institutional, and micro-beneficial levels in China’s system transformation, the paper reveals evolutionary synergistic laws and provides suggestions for developing new power systems.

Introduction

Transitioning a national power grid from fossil fuels to renewable energy is a massive socio-technical evolution involving policymakers, financial institutions, grid operators, and emerging technology providers. Traditional models often focus on narrow technical optimizations or economic costs, frequently ignoring the synergistic relationships between different actors. For a "new power system" to succeed, its various subsystems must evolve in harmony. This study applies the Brusselator model—a thermodynamic framework typically used to study self-organizing chemical reactions—to quantify this harmony and understand the "evolutionary laws" governing the transition to a carbon-neutral grid.

Methodology: The Brusselator Model and Dissipation Theory

The researchers treat the power system as a complex, open system that exchanges energy and information with its environment. The methodology involves several key steps:

  1. Entity Mapping: Identification of 14 distinct entities (A1–A14), ranging from policymakers and international organizations to "load-side entities" and clean energy technology providers.
  2. Graph Theory: Mapping the relationships between these entities across four historical phases of China's power development (1950 to the present).
  3. Co-entropy Calculation: Using the Brusselator’s kinetic equations, qualitative relationships are translated into quantitative "positive" and "negative" entropy. Positive entropy represents disorder and friction, while negative entropy represents coordination and synergy.
  4. Stability Analysis: Calculation of the "Total Entropy" ($W$) of the system. If $W < 0$, the system forms a stable "dissipative structure," indicating successful self-organization into an ordered state.
Interaction model between evolutionary subjects

Datasets

The study utilizes historical policy and industrial data from 1950–2022 regarding China’s power reforms. Additionally, expert-coded correlation matrices were constructed to quantify the interactions between the 14 entities during different evolutionary stages.

Evolutionary Dynamics and Key Insights

The total entropy of China’s power system has generally followed a downward trend, moving from 0.818 in the initial construction phase to 0.726 in the current "dual carbon" phase. This indicates that the system is successfully moving toward a stable dissipative structure, where the inflow of "negative entropy" (coordination and innovation) offsets the "positive entropy" (disorder) generated by renewable integration.

The evolutionary process of the power system dissipative structure over time

Key Findings

  • The "Running-In" Penalty: Total system entropy actually increased during the second phase (2002–2015). This suggests that when new subjects, such as energy storage and power markets, first enter the system, they initially create disorder and friction before the system learns to integrate them.
  • Policymakers as the "Entropy Sink": Policymakers (A1) consistently show the highest negative entropy, confirming that government guidance is the primary force driving order, though its relative influence is gradually decreasing as market mechanisms mature.
  • The Grid as the Meso-Hub: The "grid-side body" (A7) has the highest synergistic value among institutional players, acting as the essential bridge coordinating the "source-grid-load-storage" cycle.
  • Technological Lag: Clean energy technology (A13) and power forecasting (A14) initially contributed positive entropy (disorder) but are now rapidly shifting toward negative entropy as they become "locked-in" to the system.

Conclusion and Future Work

While the model reveals significant synergistic laws, it faces limitations such as the subjectivity in initial relationship weighting and the broad temporal granularity of the historical phases. Future research could benefit from higher-frequency data to capture more nuanced shifts. Furthermore, while tailored to China’s centralized policy environment, the model provides a foundation for analyzing decentralized or deregulated markets by redefining entity relationships and weights. Ultimately, the study underscores that the transition to a new power system is as much about organizational synergy as it is about technological advancement.

Summary updated

Abstract

The evolution of power system is a dynamic and complex process. Whether the evolution of power system can adapt to the macro environment and develop with all subsystems within the system depends on the matching and integration development among different evolutionary subjects. Based on the dissipation theory and Brusselator model, this paper constructs an evolutionary synergy model of the power system, and quantitatively analyzes the evolutionary synergy relationship between the evolving subjects of the power system and the overall evolutionary process of the power system. Then, from the socio-technical system transformation theory, we analyze the evolutionary elements of macro-environmental level, meso-institutional level and micro-beneficial level in the process of system transformation in China and the interaction among them. Finally, by comparing the entropy changes of the evolutionary participant subjects and the overall power system at each stage, the endogenous mechanism of the power system, the external elements and their interactions on the system development are studied in order to reveal the evolutionary synergistic law of China’s power system and make suggestions for the development of the new power system.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2023co,
  author = {Yunling Wang and Yunche Su and Fang Liu and Yang Liu and Tianxiang Xie and Ao Li and Ke Xu},
  title = {{Co-evolution analysis of novel power system based on Brusselator model}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Energy Research},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fenrg.2023.1232094},
}
Figure