China’s way from conventional power grids towards smart grids

Gert Brunekreeft, Marius Buchmann, Christian Dänekas, Xin Guo, Christoph Mayer, Marcus Merkel, Christian Rehtanz, André Göring, Andre Herrmann, Ray Kodali, Michael Städler, Mathias Uslar, Nils Vogel, Till Luhmann, Tobias Menz, Sven-Uwe Müller, Paul RecknagelOpenalex Unknown 2015 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

China is currently undertaking the world’s largest power grid transformation, attempting to balance a massive surge in renewable energy with a rigid, coal-heavy regulatory legacy. This paper provides a comprehensive analysis of the evolution of China’s power sector, detailing its transition from a centralized, coal-dependent infrastructure toward a modern, flexible "smart grid." It identifies that while China leads in hardware, such as Ultra-High Voltage (UHV) transmission, the true "smartness" of its grid is stifled by fragmented governance and a lack of market-based pricing.

Introduction: The Scale of Transformation

China faces the monumental task of modernizing its power infrastructure to support rapid economic growth while transitioning to cleaner energy sources. The historical growth of the sector has been unprecedented, with total installed capacity nearly doubling between 2006 and 2012 to reach 1,147 GW. This expansion was necessary to keep pace with industrial demand but has created a system that is now struggling to modernize.

Total Installed Capacity (GW) and Growth Rate from 1980 to 2012

Geographic and Regulatory Mismatch

A primary challenge is the geographic mismatch between resources and demand: energy resources (wind and solar in the "Three Norths," hydro in the Southwest) are located thousands of kilometers from industrial load centers on the Eastern coast. Furthermore, the grid is physically and regulatorily unprepared for intermittent renewables. This leads to a "curtailment crisis"; in 2012 alone, 20 TWh of wind power was wasted due to grid congestion and rigid dispatch quotas that favor coal plants.

Growth of Renewable Energy Installed Capacity by Source (2005-2012)

Technological Evolution: "Strong" vs. "Smart"

There is a fundamental strategic disagreement between China’s two main grid operators. The State Grid Corporation of China (SGCC) favors a "Strong and Smart" grid centered on UHV AC backbones to centralize power. In contrast, China Southern Power Grid (CSG) envisages a more decentralized approach using HVDC links. Currently, over 50% of China’s smart grid revenue is tied to transmission upgrades rather than "edge" technologies like smart meters or demand response, reflecting a hardware-centric approach that may overlook distribution-level efficiency.

Regulatory Fragmentation and Market Barriers

Power is split between powerful state-owned enterprises (SOEs) and government bodies with overlapping jurisdictions, creating a "vision gap." While the National Energy Administration (NEA) is the nominal regulator, it lacks the independent authority of the NDRC, which still controls the "holy grail" of the sector: pricing. Historically, China allocated operating hours equally among coal plants to ensure capital recovery—an "equal shares" mechanism that prevents cleaner, more efficient plants from running more often and hinders the integration of renewables.

Key Results and Efficiency Gains

Despite these hurdles, significant progress has been made. The "Small Plant Closure Program" successfully shut down over 70 GW of inefficient coal capacity between 2006 and 2010. However, a reliability gap remains; average annual outage times for Chinese urban users exceeded seven hours during the study period, compared to just 15 minutes in Germany, highlighting the urgent need for distribution-level "smartness."

Conclusion

For China to move beyond "conventional" grids, it must transition from a hardware-focused expansion to a software-and-market-focused integration. This requires addressing data transparency, maturing market-based pricing, and better utilizing ICT expertise from non-traditional energy firms to create a truly flexible and intelligent energy system.

Summary updated

Abstract

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
BibTeX
@inproceedings{brunekreeft2015chinas,
  author = {Gert Brunekreeft and Marius Buchmann and Christian Dänekas and Xin Guo and Christoph Mayer and Marcus Merkel and Christian Rehtanz and André Göring and Andre Herrmann and Ray Kodali and Michael Städler and Mathias Uslar and Nils Vogel and Till Luhmann and Tobias Menz and Sven-Uwe Müller and Paul Recknagel},
  title = {{China’s way from conventional power grids towards smart grids}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-658-08463-9\_3},
}
Figure