Cluster Cooperation in Wireless-Powered Sensor Networks: Modeling and Performance Analysis

Chao Zhang, Pengcheng Zhang, Weizhan Zhang

TL;DR

This paper proposes a cooperative communication strategy for wireless-powered sensor networks (WPSNs) where nearby sensors act as relays for distant sensors to improve data transmission reliability. By modeling sensor battery dynamics with Markov chains, they derive analytical expressions for outage probability, demonstrating significant performance gains for distant sensors without compromising nearby ones, especially at higher HAP transmit powers.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Wireless sensor networks (WSNs) are increasingly powered by harvested radio-frequency (RF) energy, creating wireless-powered sensor networks (WPSNs). A key challenge in WPSNs is ensuring reliable data transmission, especially for sensors located farther from the energy source (Hybrid Access Point - HAP), as they receive less energy and face greater path loss. This leads to higher outage probabilities, meaning data transmission fails more often. Existing approaches often assume sensors transmit using only their harvested energy, which can be insufficient. This paper addresses the problem of improving the reliability of data transmission for distant sensors in a WPSN by leveraging the energy and proximity advantages of nearby sensors.

Methods

The core of this paper's contribution lies in its proposed cluster cooperation protocol. The network is divided into a "near cluster" and a "far cluster." When sensors in the near cluster have no data to transmit, they can act as Amplify-and-Forward (AF) relays for sensors in the far cluster. This relaying is activated only when both the far sensor has data and the near sensor has sufficient energy to act as a relay, and importantly, when the far sensor requests assistance.

To analyze the system's performance, the authors employ a finite Markov chain to model the dynamic energy storage and depletion process of individual sensor batteries. This allows them to capture the probabilistic nature of energy harvesting and consumption over time. Based on this model, they derive closed-form expressions for the outage probability, which serves as the primary performance metric. The analysis considers various working modes for sensors in both the far and near clusters, accounting for their energy levels and data transmission needs.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper relies on theoretical analysis and simulation results based on defined parameters.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cooperative Relaying for Distant Sensors: The fundamental idea of using energy-rich, nearby sensors as relays for energy-deprived, distant sensors is a practical approach to overcome distance-related energy and signal strength limitations in WPSNs.
  • Energy Thresholds are Crucial: The paper highlights the importance of energy thresholds (Ba for transmission, Br for relaying) in determining sensor behavior. This suggests that intelligent energy management and threshold setting are key to optimizing cooperative strategies.
  • Markov Chains for Battery Dynamics: Using Markov chains to model battery states provides a robust framework for analyzing the probabilistic performance of energy-harvesting systems, capturing the inherent randomness of energy availability.
  • Trade-off Between Energy and Information Outage: The simulations reveal a critical trade-off. At low HAP transmit power, energy outage dominates, and cooperative transmission can increase it for near sensors. However, at high HAP power, energy is abundant, and cooperative transmission significantly reduces information outage for far sensors without negatively impacting near sensors.
  • Optimal Parameters Exist: The simulations demonstrate that there are optimal values for activation energy thresholds and energy harvest time ratios that minimize the overall network outage probability, indicating that system design requires careful parameter tuning.

Key Results

  • The proposed cluster cooperation scheme significantly outperforms direct transmission in terms of outage probability for sensors in the far cluster.
  • When the HAP transmit power ($P_o$) is high (e.g., > 38 dBm), the outage probability of far cluster sensors is drastically reduced without sacrificing the performance of near cluster sensors.
  • The analytical results derived using Markov chains coincide well with Monte Carlo simulation results, validating the theoretical framework.
  • The paper shows that increasing the number of sensors in the near cluster (M) can improve the performance of the far cluster, especially at lower HAP transmit powers, by increasing the likelihood of successful relaying.
  • Simulation results indicate the existence of an optimal activation energy threshold ($B_a$) that minimizes network outage probability, with this optimal value increasing with HAP transmit power.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Half-Duplex Assumption: The model assumes sensors operate in half-duplex mode, meaning they cannot transmit and receive simultaneously.
  • Perfect Synchronization: The analysis relies on perfect network-level synchronization between sensors and the HAP, which might be challenging to achieve in real-world deployments.
  • Random Relay Matching: The paper uses a random relay matching protocol for simplicity. Future work could explore more sophisticated relay selection protocols that consider battery status and channel gains for further optimization.
  • Discrete Battery Levels: While the Markov chain model uses discrete battery levels for analysis, real sensor batteries have continuous capacity. The paper suggests that a sufficiently large number of discrete levels (e.g., L=200) provides accurate results.
  • Simplified Channel Model: The channel gains are assumed to be constant during a transmission block and independent from block to block.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring more complex relay matching protocols and potentially extending the model to consider more realistic scenarios.

Summary updated

Abstract

A wireless-powered sensor network (WPSN) consisting of one hybrid access point (HAP), a near cluster and the corresponding far cluster is investigated in this paper. These sensors are wireless-powered and they transmit information by consuming the harvested energy from signal ejected by the HAP. Sensors are able to harvest energy as well as store the harvested energy. We propose that if sensors in near cluster do not have their own information to transmit, acting as relays, they can help the sensors in a far cluster to forward information to the HAP in an amplify-and-forward (AF) manner. We use a finite Markov chain to model the dynamic variation process of the relay battery, and give a general analyzing model for WPSN with cluster cooperation. Though the model, we deduce the closed-form expression for the outage probability as the metric of this network. Finally, simulation results validate the start point of designing this paper and correctness of theoretical analysis and show how parameters have an effect on system performance. Moreover, it is also known that the outage probability of sensors in far cluster can be drastically reduced without sacrificing the performance of sensors in near cluster if the transmit power of HAP is fairly high. Furthermore, in the aspect of outage performance of far cluster, the proposed scheme significantly outperforms the direct transmission scheme without cooperation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2017cluster,
  author = {Chao Zhang and Pengcheng Zhang and Weizhan Zhang},
  title = {{Cluster Cooperation in Wireless-Powered Sensor Networks: Modeling and Performance Analysis}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2017},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=TRtkUpCD60y},
}
Figure