Clinical Analysis of Nasal Bone Fracture

Shiori Kitaya, Nobuo Ohta, Yutaro Saito, Yutaka Tateda, Naoya Noguchi, Muneharu Yamazaki, Yoshitaka Takanashi, Takahiro Suzuki, Fumi Shoji, Yukiko Takahashi, Yuji Yaginuma, Sachiko Matsutani, Yusuke Kusano, Ryoukichi Ikeda, Jun Suzuki, Risako Kakuta, Kazuhiro Nomura, Mitsuru Sugawara, Yukio KatoriNippon 2020 · DOI

Abstract

This clinical study evaluates 57 cases of nasal bone fractures treated at Tohoku Medical and Pharmaceutical University Hospital between 2017 and 2019. While demographics align with historical trends—predominantly young males injured during sports—modern CT imaging reveals a higher incidence of complex "saddle nose" (depressed) deformities and significant involvement of the adjacent maxillary bone (70.2%). The study emphasizes the importance of comprehensive imaging and the efficacy of closed reduction under general anesthesia for optimal recovery.

Introduction

Nasal bone fractures are the most common facial fractures, representing approximately 40% of all facial bone injuries in clinical practice. Despite their frequency, the anatomical nuances—such as specific fracture levels and the involvement of the nasal-maxillary suture—are often overlooked in favor of simple visual diagnosis. This research utilizes high-resolution CT imaging to provide a detailed clinical profile of these injuries, correlating the mechanism of impact with specific skeletal damage patterns.

Methods and Demographics

The researchers conducted a retrospective review of 57 patients (41 males, 16 females). The average age of the cohort was 26.5 years, with a significant concentration (54.4%) in the teenage years (10–19 age group). This demographic distribution reflects the high activity levels and participation in contact sports among young males.

Figure 5: Age and gender distribution of the 57 study participants, showing a peak in the teenage years.

Injury Mechanisms and Deformity Patterns

Sports-related impacts were the primary cause of fractures (49.1%), followed by falls (22.8%) and traffic accidents (10.5%). Historically, "deviated" (lateral) noses have been the most common presentation. However, this study noted a shift: the ratio of deviated to "saddle" (depressed) deformities was 5:3. This higher proportion of depressed fractures is likely due to high-energy frontal impacts common in sports like baseball and soccer.

Figure 4: Distribution of nasal deformity types (deviated, saddle, mixed) categorized by the mechanism of injury.

Anatomical Insights

Granular CT analysis revealed that the term "nasal fracture" often understates the actual skeletal damage. A staggering 70.2% of cases involved a fracture of the maxillary frontal process, and 50.9% showed separation (dehiscence) of the nasal-maxillary suture. Fractures occurred most frequently in the middle section of the nasal bone, which serves as a structural failure point between the thicker upper bone and the flexible lower cartilage.

Treatment and Outcomes

Surgical intervention (closed reduction) was performed in 71.9% of cases. The authors advocate for the use of general anesthesia (utilized in 97.6% of surgeries) to allow for a more thorough and painless realignment compared to local anesthesia. The clinical success rate was high, with 80.5% of surgical patients achieving a "cured" status (complete resolution of deformity and symptoms).

Conclusion

Modern nasal bone fractures are frequently multi-structure facial injuries. Comprehensive CT evaluation is essential to identify hidden complications such as septal fractures or orbital involvement. Timely surgical intervention, ideally within two weeks of injury, remains the gold standard for restoring both aesthetic appearance and nasal function.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{kitaya2020clinical,
  author = {Shiori Kitaya and Nobuo Ohta and Yutaro Saito and Yutaka Tateda and Naoya Noguchi and Muneharu Yamazaki and Yoshitaka Takanashi and Takahiro Suzuki and Fumi Shoji and Yukiko Takahashi and Yuji Yaginuma and Sachiko Matsutani and Yusuke Kusano and Ryoukichi Ikeda and Jun Suzuki and Risako Kakuta and Kazuhiro Nomura and Mitsuru Sugawara and Yukio Katori},
  title = {{Clinical Analysis of Nasal Bone Fracture}},
  booktitle = {Nippon},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3950/jibiinkoka.123.1283},
}
Figure