Climate Change, Carbon Peaks, and Carbon Neutralization: A Bibliometric Study from 2006 to 2023

Qiong Chen, Hongyu Zhang, Yui‐yip Lau, Tianni Wang, Wen Wang, Guangsheng ZhangSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study provides a comprehensive bibliometric analysis of research on climate change, carbon peaks, and carbon neutralization from 2006 to 2023. It reveals a significant surge in publications, particularly in recent years, highlighting China's central role and commitment to achieving carbon neutrality by 2060. The findings offer valuable insights into research trends, key contributors, and geographical focus, informing future research directions and policy implications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The escalating threat of climate change necessitates urgent global action. While significant research efforts are underway to understand and mitigate climate change, there's a need for a systematic overview of the current research landscape concerning "carbon peaks" (the point at which carbon emissions stop increasing and begin to decline) and "carbon neutralization" (achieving a balance between emitted and absorbed carbon). This paper addresses the question of what key contributions the research community has made in this area, whether these contributions are concentrated in specific geographical regions or themes, and how the research has evolved over time. This understanding is crucial for guiding future research and informing policy decisions, especially in light of China's ambitious "dual carbon" goals.

Methods

The study employs a bibliometric analysis approach, a quantitative method for analyzing scholarly literature. Specifically, the researchers utilized two primary tools:

  • VOSviewer: This software was used to visualize and analyze bibliometric networks, including co-citation networks and keyword co-occurrence maps. This helps in identifying influential authors, research institutions, and emerging themes.
  • Python: This programming language was used for data curation and analysis, likely for processing the large volume of retrieved literature and generating specific metrics.

The analysis focused on identifying trends in publication numbers over time, mapping author and country collaborations, analyzing the output of research institutions, and examining the co-occurrence of keywords to understand research hotspots.

Datasets

The study's data source is the Web of Science Core Collection database. The search query included terms related to "climate change," "carbon neutrality," and "emission peak" for the period from 2006 to 2023. After de-duplication and sorting, 674 valid literature records were included in the analysis. No new datasets were introduced; the study relies on existing published academic literature.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Explosive Growth in Research: The most striking insight is the dramatic increase in research output on climate change, carbon peaks, and carbon neutralization, particularly from 2021 onwards. This surge indicates a growing global urgency and academic focus on these critical issues.
  • China's Dominance: China is not only a central focus of the research but also the leading country in terms of publications. This reflects the government's strong commitment to its "dual carbon" targets and the significant research efforts undertaken by Chinese institutions.
  • Interdisciplinary Nature: The research spans both macro-level themes like sustainability and climate change, as well as micro-level disciplines such as renewable energy and carbon trading, underscoring the interdisciplinary nature of the field.
  • Collaborative Efforts, Yet Fragmented Networks: While there's evidence of collaboration among scholars and institutions, the study notes that the connection between research teams can be weak, suggesting room for improved interdisciplinary and international collaboration.

Key Results

  • Publication Trends: Research in this field can be divided into three periods: 2006-2015 (4.30% of papers), 2016-2020 (11.72% of papers), and 2021-present (83.98% of papers). The recent period shows an exponential increase in publications.
  • Leading Authors: The top researchers identified include Wang Peng, Li Jiashuo, Geng Yong, Yang Yang, and Wang Jing.
  • Leading Countries: Chinese scholars publish the most articles, followed by American and English scholars.
  • Top Institutions: The Chinese Academy of Sciences, Tsinghua University, and the University of the Chinese Academy of Sciences are the leading institutions in terms of research output.
  • Key Keywords: The most frequent keywords include "carbon neutrality," "China," "climate change," "neutrality," "sustainable development," "emissions," "sustainability," "renewable energy," "carbon emission," and "policy."

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on Trends, Not Solutions: The study acknowledges that it primarily analyzes research trends and does not delve into specific measures or solutions for achieving carbon peaks and neutralization.
  • Future Research Directions: The authors suggest that future work could focus on analyzing specific strategies for achieving carbon peaks and neutralization, potentially through scenario analysis or empirical studies. They also highlight the need for interdisciplinary research and further exploration of international collaboration. The study also points out that while China is a major focus, understanding the challenges and opportunities for other countries in achieving carbon neutrality remains an important area for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Climate change poses a threat to the survival of the human race. Increased interest in climate change, carbon peaks, and carbon neutralization and rising recognition of the challenges inherent to highlighting this issue provides the opportunity to carry out a bibliometric study to identify what research can generate ideas regarding climate change, carbon peaks, and carbon neutralization. As expected, it may align with the dual goals of the Chinese government agenda in terms of a carbon peak and carbon neutralization in 2030 and 2060, respectively. The recent argument has induced calls for improved transparency and standardization in the approaches adopted to synthesize climate change, carbon peak, and carbon neutralization research. Nevertheless, key questions are still unanswered, namely, what are the key contributions that the research community has produced in relation to climate change, carbon peaks, and carbon neutralization? Have their contributions been inclined toward specific geographical areas, directions, and themes? As such, software tools for bibliometric analysis, VOSviewer, and Python were used to conduct a systematic quantitative analysis of the relevant literature on climate change, carbon peaks, and carbon neutralization. The results show that carbon peaks and carbon neutralization have received wide attention from academic scholars. In the meantime, China faces the unfolding challenges of economic, technological, and political factors that need to be addressed to achieve carbon peak and carbon neutralization. This study provides policy implications for achieving China’s emission reduction targets.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2023climate,
  author = {Qiong Chen and Hongyu Zhang and Yui‐yip Lau and Tianni Wang and Wen Wang and Guangsheng Zhang},
  title = {{Climate Change, Carbon Peaks, and Carbon Neutralization: A Bibliometric Study from 2006 to 2023}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su15075723},
}
Figure