Classification of topological phases with finite internal symmetries in all dimensions

Liang Kong, Tian Lan, Xiao-Gang Wen, Zhi-Hao Zhang, Hao ZhengJournal of High Energy Physics 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a unified mathematical framework for classifying topological phases of matter with internal symmetries, known as symmetry-protected trivial (SPT) and symmetry-enriched topological (SET) orders, across all spatial dimensions. By developing two complementary approaches – gauging symmetries and utilizing boundary-bulk relations – the authors provide a precise mathematical description and classification that aligns with and extends existing physical understanding.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the diverse landscape of quantum matter phases, particularly those exhibiting topological order and protected by symmetries, has been a significant challenge. While progress has been made in lower dimensions (1D and 2D), a unified and systematic classification scheme for these phases, encompassing all dimensions and various types of symmetries (including higher symmetries), has been lacking. Existing methods often relied on dimension-specific techniques, making a general theory elusive. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a comprehensive mathematical classification of SPT and SET orders in any spatial dimension.

Methods

The authors employ two primary mathematical approaches:

  1. Gauging the Symmetry: This method, inspired by 2D techniques, involves "gauging" the symmetry by introducing topological excitations. Mathematically, this is formalized using the concept of minimal modular extensions of unitary braided fusion categories. This approach is generalized to all dimensions, with special attention paid to the 1D case.
  2. Boundary-Bulk Relation: This approach leverages the relationship between the "bulk" of a topological phase and its "boundary." The authors propose that the classification of SPT/SET orders can be achieved by understanding the 1-dimensional higher bulk and its connection to the topological excitations. This method leads to a precise mathematical description and classification across all dimensions.

The paper emphasizes the equivalence of these two approaches, which strengthens their validity and leads to new predictions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. This paper is a theoretical and mathematical work, not based on experimental data or computational simulations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unified Classification: The paper offers a single, consistent mathematical framework for classifying topological phases with symmetries in any dimension, moving beyond dimension-specific approaches.
  • Two Complementary Views: The dual approach of "gauging symmetry" and "boundary-bulk relation" provides a robust and cross-validated classification. The equivalence of these methods is a key finding.
  • The Role of Higher Categories: The classification relies heavily on advanced mathematical structures like unitary braided fusion categories and their generalizations (n-categories), highlighting the deep connection between abstract mathematics and condensed matter physics.
  • Condensation Completion: The concept of "condensation completion" is introduced as a crucial tool for understanding topological defects and their descendants, particularly for describing boundaries and relating different dimensional descriptions.
  • Bridging Theory and Experiment: The mathematical predictions derived from this framework are expected to guide experimental searches and theoretical investigations into topological phases.

Key Results

  • Mathematical Framework: The paper establishes a precise mathematical description and classification of SPT/SET orders in all dimensions.
  • Generalization of 2D Results: The "gauging symmetry" approach successfully generalizes existing 2D classifications to higher dimensions.
  • 1D Case Treatment: The 1D case, which presents unique challenges due to the absence of braiding, is treated with special care and a complete classification is provided.
  • Equivalence of Approaches: The paper demonstrates the equivalence of the "gauging symmetry" and "boundary-bulk relation" approaches, providing strong evidence for the correctness of their classification scheme.
  • New Predictions: The unified framework leads to new mathematical predictions that can be tested against known physical results and potentially guide future research.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mathematical Rigor: While the paper presents mathematically rigorous results for 0D, 1D, and 2D cases, it acknowledges that the general formulation for higher dimensions is still physical and unrigorous in some aspects. The precise mathematical definition of unitary symmetric fusion n-categories, for instance, is still an open area.
  • Higher Categorical Notions: The paper relies on advanced concepts from higher category theory, and the full mathematical foundation for these notions in all dimensions is still under development.
  • Anti-unitary Symmetries: The paper primarily focuses on unitary symmetries, with only brief discussions on anti-unitary symmetries. A more comprehensive treatment of these symmetries is left for future work.
  • Physical Interpretations: While the mathematical framework is developed, further work is needed to fully explore the physical implications and interpretations of the various mathematical structures and equivalences.
  • Experimental Verification: The paper's predictions are theoretical and await experimental verification.

The authors suggest that future work should focus on developing the complete mathematical theory of multi-fusion higher categories, exploring the role of anti-unitary symmetries, and investigating the physical realization of the proposed classifications.

Summary updated

Abstract

A bstract We develop a mathematical theory of symmetry protected trivial (SPT) orders and anomaly-free symmetry enriched topological (SET) orders in all dimensions via two different approaches with an emphasis on the second approach. The first approach is to gauge the symmetry in the same dimension by adding topological excitations as it was done in the 2d case, in which the gauging process is mathematically described by the minimal modular extensions of unitary braided fusion 1-categories. This 2d result immediately generalizes to all dimensions except in 1d, which is treated with special care. The second approach is to use the 1-dimensional higher bulk of the SPT/SET order and the boundary-bulk relation. This approach also leads us to a precise mathematical description and a classification of SPT/SET orders in all dimensions. The equivalence of these two approaches, together with known physical results, provides us with many precise mathematical predictions.
BibTeX
@article{kong2020classification,
  author = {Liang Kong and Tian Lan and Xiao-Gang Wen and Zhi-Hao Zhang and Hao Zheng},
  title = {{Classification of topological phases with finite internal symmetries in all dimensions}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1007/jhep09(2020)093},
}
Figure