TL;DR
This study investigates how different surface finishing techniques (polishing vs. polishing + glazing) affect the color, gloss, roughness, and wettability of 3D-printed denture materials. The findings highlight that glazing significantly enhances gloss and chroma but also increases roughness, suggesting a trade-off between esthetics and surface texture that clinicians must consider for optimal denture performance.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The advent of additive manufacturing (3D printing) has revolutionized denture fabrication, offering advantages over traditional methods. However, Material Jetting (MJT) technology, while capable of producing complex, polychromatic dentures with high accuracy, has been underexplored regarding the impact of post-processing surface treatments on its material properties. Specifically, understanding how finishing techniques like polishing and glazing influence critical esthetic and functional attributes such as color stability, gloss, surface texture (roughness), and wettability is crucial for ensuring the clinical success and patient satisfaction with MJT-fabricated dentures. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by systematically evaluating these properties under two distinct finishing protocols.
Methods
The researchers utilized a PolyJet MJT 3D printer to fabricate 420 specimens from 21 different color variants of a polychromatic denture resin (TrueDent). These specimens were divided into two groups: one subjected to polishing alone, and the other to polishing followed by glazing with a nano-filled, light-cured coating (Optiglaze).
The following properties were meticulously measured:
- Color Stability: Assessed using a digital spectrophotometer before and after surface treatments. Color differences (ΔE00) were calculated using the CIEDE2000 formula, with established perceptibility and acceptability thresholds for both tooth and gingival shades. Chroma differences (ΔC*) were also recorded.
- Surface Gloss: Quantified using a glossmeter.
- Surface Roughness: Evaluated using an optical profilometer.
- Wettability: Measured by determining contact angles using an optical tensiometer.
Statistical analyses, including one-sided t-tests and Fisher's Protected Least Significant Differences, were employed to determine the significance of the observed changes.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The study used custom-fabricated specimens based on a commercial denture resin.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Glazing is a double-edged sword for esthetics: While glazing significantly boosts color saturation (chroma) and gloss, making the dentures appear more vivid and reflective, it also leads to increased surface roughness. This presents a direct trade-off that clinicians need to balance.
- Color shifts can be substantial: Glazing frequently caused color changes (ΔE00) that exceeded both perceptibility and acceptability thresholds, suggesting that existing shade guides might not be sufficient for glazed MJT dentures. A dedicated glazed shade guide might be necessary.
- Hydrophilicity matters for hygiene: Despite increased roughness, glazed surfaces became more hydrophilic (lower contact angles). This is a critical finding, as increased hydrophilicity is linked to reduced microbial colonization, potentially improving denture hygiene.
- MJT is distinct: The findings for MJT materials differ from those reported for other 3D printing technologies (SLA/DLP) or milled materials, underscoring the need for specific research on MJT.
Key Results
- Color: Glazing generally resulted in color shifts (ΔE00) exceeding perceptibility and acceptability thresholds for most shades. Glazed samples showed higher chroma (more vivid colors).
- Gloss: Glazed specimens exhibited significantly higher gloss values (p < 0.0001) compared to polished-only specimens.
- Roughness: Glazed specimens generally displayed significantly higher surface roughness (p < 0.0001 for most) than polished samples.
- Wettability: Polished samples showed higher contact angles (more hydrophobic), while glazed samples were more hydrophilic (p < 0.0001 for most).
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- In vitro setting: The study was conducted in a laboratory and did not replicate the complex oral environment, including aging protocols, immersion liquids, or time periods.
- Operator variability: While one investigator performed treatments, human factors and manual application of glaze could introduce variability.
- Limited scope of treatments: Only two surface treatments (polishing alone and polishing with one type of glaze) were tested.
- Measurement limitations: Potential variations due to sample placement and the use of specific equipment.
Future research directions suggested include:
- Microbiological testing: To confirm the hypothesized hygiene benefits of increased hydrophilicity.
- Simulated aging studies: To assess mechanical and optical stability under conditions like brushing and thermocycling.
- Exploration of different glazes and application methods: To optimize the glazing process.
- Comparative studies: To benchmark MJT dentures against those fabricated by milling or other 3D printing technologies.
- Long-term clinical studies: To validate in vitro findings and guide clinical decision-making.
Summary updated