Choice Poetics by Example

Peter Mawhorter, Carmen Zegura, Alex Gray, Arnav Jhala, Michael Mateas, Noah Wardrip–Fruin

TL;DR

This paper introduces "Choice Poetics," a formal framework for analyzing how narrative choices impact player experience in games. By applying this framework to Undertale and Papers, Please, the authors demonstrate its utility in understanding player engagement and the subtle mechanisms that drive player behavior, such as complicity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Designing compelling narrative choices in games is challenging. While many games offer choices, understanding why certain choices resonate with players, how they shape player experience, and how to systematically design them remains an open question. Existing approaches often rely on intuition or broad categorizations of player types. The authors aim to provide a more rigorous, formalist method to dissect the impact of choices, moving beyond subjective interpretation to a concrete, analytical framework. This framework is particularly useful for understanding how choices can influence player psychology, such as encouraging complicity or fostering different play styles.

Methods

The core of the paper is the application of "Choice Poetics," a formalist framework for analyzing narrative choices. The framework involves four key steps:

  1. Goal Analysis: Identifying and prioritizing player goals (e.g., gaining experience, acting ethically, providing for family). This can involve defining specific "player models" that represent different sets of prioritized goals.
  2. Likelihood Analysis: Mapping out the potential outcomes of each choice option and assessing their likelihood from the player's perspective.
  3. Prospective Analysis: Describing the player's anticipated impression of each option based on the analyzed goals and outcomes. This involves using labels like "advances" or "hinders" to denote how options affect player goals.
  4. Retrospective Analysis: Examining the actual outcomes of choices and their impact on player goals, comparing them to the prospective analysis to identify any discrepancies.

The paper demonstrates this framework through "by-hand" analysis of specific choices in two games, illustrating how to apply these steps to understand player motivations and the psychological effects of choices.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on analyzing existing games (Undertale and Papers, Please) rather than training or evaluating models on datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Formalizing Player Experience: Choice Poetics provides a structured way to move from subjective feelings about a choice to a concrete analysis of its mechanics and potential impact.
  • Player Models are Crucial: Different player goals and priorities (player models) lead to vastly different interpretations and preferences for the same choice. For example, a "power player" in Undertale prioritizes XP and gold, while a "story player" prioritizes immersion and ethical considerations.
  • Uncertainty as a Complicity Driver: In Papers, Please, uncertainty about the true nature of applicants is a key mechanism that the game uses to subtly push players towards complicity with an authoritarian regime. By making the "deny" option seem like the "safer" or more justifiable choice (especially when considering family needs), the game can override ethical considerations.
  • The Power of Subtle Design: Even seemingly small choices, when repeated and framed by specific mechanics and narrative contexts, can have profound effects on player behavior and perception.
  • Bridging Human and Algorithmic Analysis: While developed with algorithmic generation in mind, Choice Poetics offers a valuable tool for human critics and designers to systematically dissect and understand narrative choices.

Key Results

The paper demonstrates how Choice Poetics can:

  • Contrast Player Experiences: In Undertale, the analysis shows how the "fight" or "spare" choice encourages different play styles based on player models (power vs. story player), leading to divergent game experiences and fostering community discussion.
  • Explain Complicity Mechanisms: In Papers, Please, the analysis reveals how the introduction of uncertainty, combined with high-priority goals like providing for family, transforms a potential moral dilemma into a choice where complicity feels justified. The paper shows how removing this uncertainty would fundamentally alter the player's perception of the choice.
  • Validate Existing Analyses: The conclusions drawn from the Choice Poetics analysis align with other critical interpretations of these games, lending credibility to the framework's effectiveness.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Subjectivity of Player Models: The authors acknowledge that defining player models involves assumptions about player goals and priorities, which might not perfectly reflect every individual player. They suggest that contrasting analyses with different player models or gathering empirical data can help refine these assumptions.
  • Focus on Specific Choices: The analyses are detailed but focus on specific, often central, choices within the games. A broader understanding would require analyzing a wider range of choices and their interconnections.
  • Future Work: The authors plan to further develop the theory by exploring computational models, analyzing play traces for automated analysis, and using it for on-line player modeling to enable responsive stories. They also aim to continue dialogue with game scholars and designers to refine the framework and apply it to more examples.

Summary updated

Abstract

Choice poetics is a formalist framework that seeks to concretely describe the impacts choices have on player experiences within narrative games. Developed in part to support algorithmic generation of narrative choices, the theory includes a detailed analytical framework for understanding the impressions choice structures make by analyzing the relationships among options, outcomes, and player goals. The theory also emphasizes the need to account for players’ various modes of engagement, which vary both during play and between players. In this work, we illustrate the non-computational application of choice poetics to the analysis of two different games to further develop the theory and make it more accessible to others. We focus first on using choice poetics to examine the central repeated choice in “Undertale,” and show how it can be used to contrast two different player types that will approach a choice differently. Finally, we give an example of fine-grained analysis using a choice from the game “Papers, Please,” which breaks down options and their outcomes to illustrate exactly how the choice pushes players towards complicity via the introduction of uncertainty. Through all of these examples, we hope to show the usefulness of choice poetics as a framework for understanding narrative choices, and to demonstrate concretely how one could productively apply it to choices “in the wild.”
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mawhorter2018choice,
  author = {Peter Mawhorter and Carmen Zegura and Alex Gray and Arnav Jhala and Michael Mateas and Noah Wardrip–Fruin},
  title = {{Choice Poetics by Example}},
  booktitle = {Arts},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/arts7030047},
}
Figure