Child wasting and concurrent stunting in low- and middle-income countries

Andrew Mertens, Jade Benjamin‐Chung, Jacob John, Alan Hubbard, Mark J. van der Laan, Jeremy Coyle, Oleg Sofrygin, Weixin Cai, Wendy Jilek, Sonali Rosete, Anna Nguyen, Nolan N. Pokpongkiat, Stephanie Djajadi, Anmol Seth, Esther Jung, Esther O. Chung, Ivana Malenica, Nima S. Hejazi, Haodong Li, Ryan Hafen, Vishak Subramoney, Jonas Häggström, Thea Norman, Parul Christian, Kenneth H. Brown, Benjamin F. ArnoldmedRxiv 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Sustainable Development Goal 2.2 aims to eliminate child wasting by 2030. However, current measurement methods rely on cross-sectional surveys that fail to capture the onset, recovery, and persistence of the condition. By analyzing 21 longitudinal cohorts, this study demonstrates that wasting is a highly dynamic process with incidence peaking between birth and 3 months. While point prevalence is low (5.6%), cumulative incidence reaches 29.2% by age 24 months. Early wasting increases the risk of later growth faltering and concurrent stunting, significantly raising mortality risk. These findings suggest a critical need for interventions targeting the first six months of life and seasonal fluctuations.

Introduction: The Hidden Churn of Malnutrition

Global health organizations typically measure "wasting" (low weight-for-length) using cross-sectional surveys—essentially taking a snapshot of a population at a single point in time. While useful for broad comparisons, these snapshots fail to capture the "churn" of malnutrition: how many children fall into wasting, how long they stay there, and how often they recover.

The current paradigm focuses on children aged 6–59 months, assuming this is the window of highest risk. However, if wasting is a dynamic process with frequent onset and recovery, cross-sectional data will significantly underestimate the total number of children affected and miss the critical windows where interventions would be most effective. This paper seeks to fill that gap by looking at how wasting evolves month-to-month in the first two years of life.

Methods and Data Sources

The study utilized the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation’s Knowledge Integration (ki) database, pooling data from 21 longitudinal cohorts across 10 low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) in South Asia, Sub-Saharan Africa, and Latin America. The dataset included approximately 11,448 children and 198,154 total anthropometry measurements.

Unlike standard surveys, these cohorts measured children’s length and weight repeatedly (mostly monthly) from birth to 24 months. Key technical aspects included:

  • Z-score Calculation: Used the 2006 WHO Child Growth Standards to calculate weight-for-length (WLZ), length-for-age (LAZ), and weight-for-age (WAZ).
  • Episode Definition: To distinguish between a single prolonged bout and recurring malnutrition, the team defined a new "incident episode" only after a child had "recovered" (maintained a WLZ > -2 for at least 60 days).
  • Seasonality Analysis: Researchers linked monthly rainfall data to cohort locations to calculate a "seasonality index," testing the hypothesis that WLZ fluctuates with agricultural and infection cycles tied to rain.

Key Insights

1. Prevalence vs. Incidence

The most significant finding is the massive gap between point prevalence and cumulative incidence. While only ~5.6% of children were wasted at any single check-in, nearly 30% had experienced wasting at some point by age two. In South Asia, this number climbed to 52.2%. This indicates that wasting affects far more children than can be inferred through cross-sectional surveys; we are missing the majority of the burden by relying on snapshots.

2. The "Birth Peak"

Onset of wasting peaks between birth and 3 months. This contradicts the common belief that wasting peaks later (12–15 months) when complementary feeding begins. It suggests that maternal health and prenatal nutrition are far more influential on wasting than previously emphasized.

3. The Rainy Season Slump

In areas with high seasonality, the population's average WLZ dropped significantly during the rainiest months. In high-seasonality regions, mean WLZ was 0.27 z-score lower during peak rainfall compared to the opposite time of year. In some cohorts, the swing exceeded 0.5 z-score. This suggests that malnutrition is often a rhythmic crisis tied to the environment.

4. The Malnutrition "Double Whammy"

Early wasting acts as a gateway. Children wasted before 6 months had faster recovery and shorter episodes than those wasted later, but they were significantly more likely to experience concurrent wasting and stunting (low height-for-age) later in life—a condition associated with the highest risks of mortality.

Discussion and Policy Implications

The results strongly motivate a shift in global health policy. Wasting is often acute but short-lived, with a median episode length of 42 days. While over 80% of children eventually recover from moderate wasting, those wasted at birth struggle to "catch up" to their peers.

To meet international targets, interventions must move beyond the 6–59 month window:

  • Maternal and Neonatal Support: Preventive interventions must reach pregnant and lactating mothers and children under 6 months old.
  • Seasonal Targeting: Food security programs should be seasonally timed to coincide with environmental risks.
  • Longitudinal Tracking: Future monitoring should prioritize longitudinal data to better capture the dynamic nature of recovery and relapse.

Limitations

The authors acknowledge that most cohorts did not systematically record nutritional therapy (like RUTF), which could influence recovery times. Furthermore, these highly monitored research cohorts might have better outcomes than the general population due to frequent check-ups. Finally, survivorship bias may lead to an underestimation of wasting severity in children who died before recovery could be documented.

Conclusion

By analyzing child growth as a dynamic process rather than a static state, this study reveals a much higher burden of wasting than previously recognized. Addressing this burden requires a focus on the earliest months of life and a better understanding of the seasonal rhythms that drive nutritional instability.

Summary updated

Abstract

Summary Sustainable Development Goal 2.2, to end malnutrition by 2030, includes elimination of child wasting, defined as weight-for-length more than 2 standard deviations below international standards. Prevailing methods to measure wasting rely on cross-sectional surveys that cannot measure onset, recovery, and persistence — key features that inform preventive interventions and disease burden estimates. We analyzed 21 longitudinal cohorts to show wasting is a highly dynamic process of onset and recovery, with incidence peaking between birth and 3 months. By age 24 months 29.2% of children had experienced at least one wasting episode, more than 5-fold higher than point prevalence (5.6%), demonstrating that wasting affects far more children than can be inferred through cross-sectional surveys. Children wasted before 6 months had faster recovery and shorter episodes than children wasted at older ages, but early wasting increased the risk of later growth faltering, including concurrent wasting and stunting (low height-for-age), increasing their risk of mortality. In diverse populations with high seasonal rainfall, population average weight-for-length varied substantially (>0.5 z in some cohorts), with the lowest mean Z-scores during the rainiest months, creating potential for seasonally targeted interventions. Our results elevate the importance of establishing interventions to prevent wasting from birth to age 6 months, likely through improved maternal nutrition, to complement current programs that focus on children ages 6-59 months.
BibTeX
@misc{mertens2020child,
  author = {Andrew Mertens and Jade Benjamin‐Chung and Jacob John and Alan Hubbard and Mark J. van der Laan and Jeremy Coyle and Oleg Sofrygin and Weixin Cai and Wendy Jilek and Sonali Rosete and Anna Nguyen and Nolan N. Pokpongkiat and Stephanie Djajadi and Anmol Seth and Esther Jung and Esther O. Chung and Ivana Malenica and Nima S. Hejazi and Haodong Li and Ryan Hafen and Vishak Subramoney and Jonas Häggström and Thea Norman and Parul Christian and Kenneth H. Brown and Benjamin F. Arnold},
  title = {{Child wasting and concurrent stunting in low- and middle-income countries}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.06.09.20126979},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure