Author Correction: Early-childhood linear growth faltering in low- and middle-income countries
Jade Benjamin‐Chung, Andrew Mertens, John M. Colford, Alan Hubbard, Mark J. van der Laan, Jeremy Coyle, Oleg Sofrygin, Weixin Cai, Anna Nguyen, Nolan N. Pokpongkiat, Stephanie Djajadi, Anmol Seth, Wendy Jilek, Esther Jung, Esther O. Chung, Sonali Rosete, Nima S. Hejazi, Ivana Malenica, Haodong Li, Ryan Hafen, Vishak Subramoney, Jonas Häggström, Thea Norman, Kenneth H. Brown, Parul Christian, Benjamin F. Arnold, Souheila Abbeddou, Linda S. Adair, Tahmeed Ahmed, Asad Ali, Hasmot Ali, Per Ashorn, Rajiv Bahl, Maurício L. Barreto, France Bégin, Pascal Bessong, Maharaj Kishan Bhan, Nita Bhandari, Santosh K. Bhargava, Zulfiqar A Bhutta, Robert E. Black, Ladaporn Bodhidatta, Delia B. Carba, Inés González-Casanova, William Checkley, Jean E. Crabtree, Kathryn G. Dewey, Christopher Duggan, Caroline Fall, Abu Syed Golam Faruque, Wafaie Fawzi, José Quirino da Silva Filho, Robert H. Gilman, Richard L. Guerrant, Rashidul Haque, Sonja Y. Hess, Eric R. Houpt, Jean H. Humphrey, Najeeha Talat Iqbal, Elizabeth Yakes Jimenez, Jacob John, Sushil Matthew John, Gagandeep Kang, Margaret Kosek, Michael S. Kramer, Alain Labrique, Sang Lee, Aldo Â. M. Lima, Mustafa Mahfuz, Tjale Cloupas Mahopo, Kenneth Maleta, Dharma Manandhar, Karim Manji, Reynaldo Martorell, Sarmila Mazumder, Estomih Mduma, Venkata Raghava Mohan, Sophie E. Moore, Ishita Mostafa, Robert Ntozini, Mzwakhe Emanuel Nyathi, Maribel Paredes Olórtegui, William A. Petri, Prasanna Samuel Premkumar, Andrew M. Prentice, Najeeb Rahman, Harshpal Singh Sachdev, Kamran Sadiq, Rajiv Sarkar, Naomi Saville, Saijuddin Shaikh, Bhim P. Shrestha, Sanjaya K. Shrestha, Alberto M. Soares, Bakary Sonko, Aryeh D. Stein, Erling Svensen, Sana Syed, Fayaz Umrani, Honorine WardNature2024 · DOI · OpenAlex
This article summarizes a formal correction to a high-impact 2023 Nature study concerning childhood stunting in low- and middle-income countries. The authors identified a coding error in their meta-analysis denominator that led to an underestimation of stunting incidence in early infancy. While the corrected rates are higher, the study’s original scientific conclusions regarding growth faltering trends remain robust.
The Statistical Oversight: Defining the "At-Risk" Population
The core of the correction addresses a statistical oversight in how the incidence of stunting was calculated. In epidemiology, calculating incidence requires a "denominator at risk"—the group of individuals who could potentially develop a condition.
The original research code incorrectly included children who were already stunted in the denominator for new cases. Because a child who is already stunted is no longer "at risk" of becoming stunted, their inclusion artificially inflated the denominator and diluted the reported incidence rates. This correction serves as a textbook example of the nuances required in longitudinal data analysis.
Methodological Adjustments
The authors re-ran their meta-analyses for stunting proportions (specifically for Figure 3a and Extended Data Figures 8–10) using a corrected denominator. This updated approach ensures that only children who have not yet reached the threshold for stunting are counted in the "at-risk" pool for new incidence.
Beyond the statistical recalculation, the authors also:
Updated Replication Code: Links were revised to reflect the corrected analytical pipeline.
Refined Labeling: Y-axis labels were corrected from "Incidence proportion" to "Proportion" in specific figures (Fig. 4b and Extended Data Fig. 12).
Corrected Citations: Typographical errors in figure citations within the "Linear growth velocity" section of the Methods were fixed.
Updated Findings and Key Insights
The correction reveals that the window between birth and three months is even more critical than previously reported. The "incident stunting" (new cases) in this period is higher when the denominator is correctly constrained to those actually at risk.
Quantitative Changes in Stunting Metrics:
* Overall Incidence (Birth to 3 Months): Originally reported as 16%, the corrected figure is 18%.
* Cohort Range: The range of incidence across different cohorts (compiled by The Ki Child Growth Consortium) was originally cited as 6% to 47%; the corrected range is 7% to 57%.
* Post-Birth Levels: Age-stratified stunting incidence levels are now higher across the board following birth.
Conclusion
The authors explicitly state that these corrections do not change the inferences drawn from the study. While the magnitude of the problem was slightly underestimated, the timing and progression of the phenomenon were correctly identified. For researchers building on this work, the authors have updated the HTML and PDF versions of the article and provided revised figures in the Supplementary Information to ensure future analyses avoid this specific denominator error.
Summary updated
BibTeX
@inproceedings{benjaminchung2024author,
author = {Jade Benjamin‐Chung and Andrew Mertens and John M. Colford and Alan Hubbard and Mark J. van der Laan and Jeremy Coyle and Oleg Sofrygin and Weixin Cai and Anna Nguyen and Nolan N. Pokpongkiat and Stephanie Djajadi and Anmol Seth and Wendy Jilek and Esther Jung and Esther O. Chung and Sonali Rosete and Nima S. Hejazi and Ivana Malenica and Haodong Li and Ryan Hafen and Vishak Subramoney and Jonas Häggström and Thea Norman and Kenneth H. Brown and Parul Christian and Benjamin F. Arnold and Souheila Abbeddou and Linda S. Adair and Tahmeed Ahmed and Asad Ali and Hasmot Ali and Per Ashorn and Rajiv Bahl and Maurício L. Barreto and France Bégin and Pascal Bessong and Maharaj Kishan Bhan and Nita Bhandari and Santosh K. Bhargava and Zulfiqar A Bhutta and Robert E. Black and Ladaporn Bodhidatta and Delia B. Carba and Inés González-Casanova and William Checkley and Jean E. Crabtree and Kathryn G. Dewey and Christopher Duggan and Caroline Fall and Abu Syed Golam Faruque and Wafaie Fawzi and José Quirino da Silva Filho and Robert H. Gilman and Richard L. Guerrant and Rashidul Haque and Sonja Y. Hess and Eric R. Houpt and Jean H. Humphrey and Najeeha Talat Iqbal and Elizabeth Yakes Jimenez and Jacob John and Sushil Matthew John and Gagandeep Kang and Margaret Kosek and Michael S. Kramer and Alain Labrique and Sang Lee and Aldo Â. M. Lima and Mustafa Mahfuz and Tjale Cloupas Mahopo and Kenneth Maleta and Dharma Manandhar and Karim Manji and Reynaldo Martorell and Sarmila Mazumder and Estomih Mduma and Venkata Raghava Mohan and Sophie E. Moore and Ishita Mostafa and Robert Ntozini and Mzwakhe Emanuel Nyathi and Maribel Paredes Olórtegui and William A. Petri and Prasanna Samuel Premkumar and Andrew M. Prentice and Najeeb Rahman and Harshpal Singh Sachdev and Kamran Sadiq and Rajiv Sarkar and Naomi Saville and Saijuddin Shaikh and Bhim P. Shrestha and Sanjaya K. Shrestha and Alberto M. Soares and Bakary Sonko and Aryeh D. Stein and Erling Svensen and Sana Syed and Fayaz Umrani and Honorine Ward},
title = {{Author Correction: Early-childhood linear growth faltering in low- and middle-income countries}},
booktitle = {Nature},
year = {2024},
doi = {10.1038/s41586-024-08344-6},
}