Characteristics of patients with idiopathic normal pressure hydrocephalus for whom neurosurgeons hesitate to perform shunt surgery: a nationwide hospital-based survey in Japan

Ryo Kawai, Hiroaki Kazui, Tetsuya Ueba, Natsuko Nakamura, Marina Minami, Madoka Nakajima, Shigeki Yamada, Haruhiko Kishima, Hideki Kanemoto, Chifumi Iseki, Etsuro MoriResearch Square 2025 · DOI

Introduction

Idiopathic normal pressure hydrocephalus (iNPH) is frequently referred to as a "treatable dementia." It presents with a classic triad of symptoms: gait disturbance, cognitive decline, and urinary urgency. For many patients, shunt surgery—a procedure to drain excess cerebrospinal fluid—can lead to significant improvements in quality of life.

However, as the global population ages, clinicians increasingly face a "gray zone." Neurosurgeons must decide whether to operate on patients with advanced age (90+) or complex comorbidities like Alzheimer’s disease or renal failure. Currently, clinical guidelines do not provide definitive thresholds for these high-risk cases. This study presents a nationwide analysis of how Japanese neurosurgeons navigate these difficult decisions.

Methods

Researchers conducted a comprehensive survey of 1,220 specialist training facilities across Japan between October and December 2023. A total of 656 facilities (53.8%) provided data on their surgical policies and 2022 case volumes. The study utilized binary logistic regression to determine which facility-level factors—such as annual surgical volume or the presence of multidisciplinary specialists—influenced the decision to offer surgery to complex patient groups.

Key Results

The survey revealed that most facilities (57.1%) are "low volume," performing between one and five iNPH shunt surgeries annually. A significant portion of respondents (21.2%) performed no shunt surgeries in 2022.

When considering surgical indications, age and social support emerged as major hurdles:

  • Age Limits: Of the facilities that factor age into their decisions, 57.8% consider 90 years or older a contraindication for surgery.
  • Social Support: 56.0% of facilities hesitated to operate if a patient lacked adequate care or was already institutionalized, highlighting the importance of post-operative rehabilitation.
  • Comorbidities: Hesitation was highest for patients with Alzheimer’s disease (44.2%) and schizophrenia (42.7%).
Logistic regression analysis of factors influencing the indication for shunt surgery in patients aged ≥ 90 years.

The "Experience Paradox" and the Power of Collaboration

The analysis uncovered an "Experience Paradox": facilities with higher surgical volumes were statistically more likely to set a hard age limit at 90 years. This suggests that high-volume centers may have more standardized, data-driven protocols regarding surgical futility in the very elderly.

Conversely, the presence of a multidisciplinary support system—such as collaborating internal medicine departments or qualified dementia specialists—was a strong predictor of a willingness to operate on patients with psychiatric or medical comorbidities. When neurosurgeons have specialized support to manage a patient’s overall health, they are more confident in proceeding with surgical intervention.

Limitations and Future Directions

The study authors noted several limitations, including the potential for response bias and the fact that survey responses reflect intended policy rather than actual clinical practice. Additionally, the findings are specific to the Japanese healthcare and social support infrastructure.

To improve patient access to these life-changing treatments, the authors suggest establishing clearer referral pathways and educating dementia specialists on the specific criteria neurosurgeons use to evaluate surgical candidates.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> <bold>Background:</bold> There is a lack of consensus regarding the indications for shunt surgery in patients with idiopathic normal pressure hydrocephalus (iNPH) who present with physical or mental disorders. This study is the first nationwide analysis investigating current approaches of neurosurgeons to iNPH treatment and shunt surgery adaptation for patients with iNPH. <bold>Methods:</bold>We developed a questionnaire in collaboration with neurosurgeons and dementia specialists. From October 10 to December 11, 2023, the survey was conducted at 1,220 facilities. <bold>Results:</bold>A total of 656 facilities (53.8%) responded. Of them, 30 (4.6%) had a policy of not performing shunt surgery for patients with iNPH, and 139 (21.2%) did not perform any shunt surgeries in 2022. The most common number of shunt surgeries performed in 2022 was 1–5 surgeries per facility, accounting for 257 facilities (57.1%). Regarding indications for shunt surgery, 159 (35.3%) responded that age was not considered. Among 268 facilities (59.6%) that considered age, 155 (57.8%) responded that patients aged ≥90 years were not indicated for shunt surgery. Among 450 facilities (68.6%) that performed shunt surgery at least once in 2022, the percentages of facilities that hesitated to perform it due to the presence of cerebrovascular disease, orthopedic disease, dialysis, Parkinson’s syndrome, Alzheimer’s disease (AD), schizophrenia, “absence of disproportionately enlarged subarachnoid space hydrocephalus (DESH),” and “not receiving adequate care/institutionalized” were 45 (10.0%), 52 (11.5%), 134 (29.8%), 88 (19.5%), 192 (42.7%), 199 (44.2%), 187 (41.5%), and 252 (56.0%), respectively. To identify factors that influence the indications for shunt surgery, logistic regression analysis was performed. The results showed that the number of shunt surgeries performed in 2022 was significant predictor of age ≥90 years, cerebrovascular disease, Parkinson’s syndrome, AD, no DESH, and “not receiving adequate care/institutionalized.” Significant predictors for dialysis, AD, and schizophrenia included the presence of collaborating internal medicine facilities. For dialysis and AD, the classification of facilities and having a qualified dementia specialist were significant predictors, respectively. <bold>Conclusions:</bold> Characteristics of patients with iNPH for whom Japanese neurosurgeons hesitate to perform shunt surgery included patients aged ≥90 years; those with comorbid AD and schizophrenia, no DESH; and those “not receiving adequate care/institutionalized.”
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kawai2025characteristics,
  author = {Ryo Kawai and Hiroaki Kazui and Tetsuya Ueba and Natsuko Nakamura and Marina Minami and Madoka Nakajima and Shigeki Yamada and Haruhiko Kishima and Hideki Kanemoto and Chifumi Iseki and Etsuro Mori},
  title = {{Characteristics of patients with idiopathic normal pressure hydrocephalus for whom neurosurgeons hesitate to perform shunt surgery: a nationwide hospital-based survey in Japan}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-6301124/v1},
}
Figure