Abstract
A number of Japanese neurosurgeons hesitate to perform shunt surgery in patients with idiopathic normal pressure hydrocephalus (iNPH) aged ≥ 90 years, with comorbid Alzheimer’s disease (AD) or schizophrenia, lacking disproportionately enlarged subarachnoid space hydrocephalus (DESH) findings, or having insufficient care support or being institutionalized. Multidisciplinary collaboration with internal medicine, including neurology and psychiatry, may help expand appropriate surgical indications for these patients.
Introduction
Idiopathic normal pressure hydrocephalus (iNPH) is a significant, treatable neurological condition primarily affecting the elderly. It is characterized by a clinical triad: gait disturbance, cognitive decline, and urinary incontinence. The standard treatment is shunt surgery, which effectively drains excess cerebrospinal fluid. However, as the global population ages, neurosurgeons are increasingly faced with complex cases involving patients over 85 years old or those with significant comorbidities such as Alzheimer’s disease, Parkinson’s disease, or cardiovascular issues.
Current clinical guidelines do not provide exhaustive criteria for these high-risk or complex scenarios. This often leads to a disconnect between dementia specialists, who diagnose the condition, and neurosurgeons, who must weigh the surgical risks. This study investigates the specific clinical and social factors that cause Japanese neurosurgeons to hesitate, aiming to identify and address the bottlenecks in iNPH care.
Methodology and Data Collection
The researchers developed a detailed questionnaire in collaboration with experts from the Japanese Society of Normal Pressure Hydrocephalus. The survey targeted 1,220 neurosurgical facilities across Japan, categorized by their certification level (core, collaborating, and other facilities).
Data was collected via the REDCap platform between October and December 2023. The questionnaire assessed annual surgical volumes and surgeon willingness to operate based on age, physical and neuropsychiatric comorbidities, imaging results, and social living situations. Binary logistic regression was employed to determine which facility characteristics predicted a higher willingness to operate on complex cases.
Key Results
Of the 1,220 facilities surveyed, 656 responded, yielding a 53.8% response rate. A primary finding was the relatively low volume of iNPH surgeries performed across the country.
As shown in the data, the majority of facilities (57.1%) performed only 1–5 surgeries in 2022, while 21.2% performed none. Key hesitation factors identified include:
- Advanced Age: 57.8% of facilities consider patients ≥ 90 years old to be contraindicated for surgery.
- Comorbidities: High hesitation rates were noted for patients with schizophrenia (44.2%), Alzheimer’s disease (42.7%), and those on dialysis (29.8%).
- Imaging Findings: 41.5% of surgeons hesitate if DESH (disproportionately enlarged subarachnoid space hydrocephalus) is absent on MRI, despite evidence that surgery can still be effective.
- Social Support: 56.0% of facilities hesitate to operate on patients who lack adequate family care or are institutionalized.
Discussion and Insights
The study reveals several critical insights into the current state of iNPH treatment in Japan:
- Experience Breeds Confidence: Facilities with higher surgical volumes are significantly more likely to operate on complex patients. This suggests that increased experience allows surgeons to better manage risks and recognize the potential benefits of surgery even in the presence of comorbidities.
- The DESH Dilemma: The reliance on DESH as a primary surgical indicator may be overly rigid. Broadening the interpretation of imaging in the context of clinical symptoms could expand access to treatment.
- Social Barriers to Care: The high rate of hesitation due to lack of social support highlights that postoperative care and rehabilitation are viewed as integral to surgical success. This is a significant hurdle in an aging society where family support may be limited.
- The Power of Collaboration: Facilities with active multidisciplinary teams (including neurology and psychiatry) showed a significantly higher willingness to operate on complex cases. Collaboration helps mitigate the perceived risks of neuropsychiatric comorbidities.
Limitations and Future Directions
The study is limited by a potential selection bias, as high-volume facilities might have been more likely to respond. Additionally, the survey measured surgical intentions rather than actual outcomes, and did not differentiate between the severity levels of comorbidities.
Future efforts should focus on developing educational materials for nursing home staff regarding postoperative monitoring. Most importantly, fostering interdisciplinary collaboration is essential to ensure that patients with iNPH receive appropriate surgical intervention, regardless of age or complex medical backgrounds.
Summary updated