Abstract
The crowdfunding market size has increased exponentially, reaching tens of billions of dollars and showing the popularity of crowdfunding. However, according to Kickstarter, 35% of backers did not receive rewards on time. To maintain the trust between creators and backers and sustain crowdfunding business growth, it is crucial to understand how on-time and late reward delivery projects differ. In this paper, we analyze characteristics of on-time and late reward delivery projects, focusing on project descriptions, creator profiles, and the activeness and linguistic patterns of creators and backers. Our analysis reveals that the less complicated a project is and the more actively a creator responds to backers, the higher the probability of on-time reward delivery.
Introduction: The Fulfillment Gap
While most crowdfunding research focuses on the fundraising phase—predicting campaign success or analyzing backer dynamics—very little attention has been paid to the reward delivery phase. Late deliveries damage backer trust and reduce the likelihood of future investments on the platform. This paper aims to bridge that gap by identifying the distinguishing properties of on-time versus late reward delivery projects.
Methodology and Data
The authors took a data-driven, statistical approach to compare on-time and late projects using a sample of 2,949 successfully funded Kickstarter projects launched between 2009 and 2014. Because Kickstarter does not strictly track fulfillment dates, three independent labelers manually reviewed project updates and comments to establish ground truth.
Projects were categorized into four feature sets:
- Project characteristics: Funding goals, reward tiers, and description readability.
- Creator characteristics: Past history and bio readability.
- Activeness: Update frequency and comment response times.
- Linguistic patterns: Text analysis of updates and comments using the Linguistic Inquiry and Word Count (LIWC) dictionary.
Key Insights: Complexity and Category
A primary finding is that complexity is the enemy of punctuality. Projects with lower funding goals, less pledged money, and fewer reward tiers are significantly more likely to deliver on time. Massive funding success can be a double-edged sword if a creator is overwhelmed by the logistics of overfunding.
Furthermore, the project category serves as a strong predictor of delivery risk. Projects involving live performances or classes (e.g., dance and theater) usually deliver on time. In contrast, categories requiring complex manufacturing and physical shipping (e.g., technology and games) are highly prone to delays.
Results and Linguistic Analysis
The study identified several statistically significant differences:
- Project Stats: On-time projects had significantly lower average funding goals ($7,670 vs. $13,584) and less total pledged money ($14,419 vs. $30,126).
- Readability: On-time projects featured simpler, more readable descriptions (average SMOG score of 30.12 vs. 38.59).
- Communication: Creators of on-time projects posted updates more frequently and responded to comments faster.
- Linguistic "Tells": Creators of late projects used significantly more "cognitive process" words (e.g., cause, know, ought), likely explaining the reasons for delays. Conversely, on-time creators used more positive and affective language.
Conclusion and Future Directions
This study highlights that successful fundraising does not guarantee successful fulfillment. While the manual labeling process limits the dataset size, these findings provide a foundation for building predictive models that can flag high-risk projects early. Future work should focus on developing recommendation systems to guide creators toward better project design and communication strategies, ultimately fostering a more trustworthy crowdfunding ecosystem.
Summary updated