Abstract
Additive Manufacturing (AM), also known as 3D printing, using high-temperature thermoplastics has been proposed for the production of structures in space. To determine whether this is feasible, a systematic study investigating the impact of the space environment on the AM process must be conducted. Existing investigations have focussed on AM in microgravity and AM of either low-temperature thermoplastics or individual high-temperature thermoplastics at low pressure. This study examines the mechanical characteristics of high temperature, space compatible thermoplastic parts produced by AM in a low-pressure environments. Four different thermoplastic filaments were investigated—polyether ether ketone (PEEK), polyether ketone ketone (PEKK), and two types of polyetherimide (PEI) (ULTEM 9085 and ULTEM 1010). Their mechanical performance, internal structures, and crystallinity were compared to those manufactured under atmospheric conditions. It was observed that the low pressure enabled the manufacture of ULTEM 1010 specimens, which could not be achieved in ambient atmosphere. The low pressure additionally improved the interlayer adhesion of PEEK and ULTEM 9085 specimens. PEEK, PEKK, and ULTEM 1010 specimens exhibited bubbling when printed under low-pressure conditions, most noticeable in the compression and H-90° samples, resulting in worse mechanical properties than samples manufactured in atmosphere. The mechanical performance of bending and H-0° specimens remained consistent irrespective of the printing environment; this was thought to be due to conduction to the print bed being the dominant form of heat transfer, resulting in similar thermal histories.
Introduction
In-Space Manufacturing (ISM) is poised to revolutionize spacecraft design by enabling the production of large structures and spare parts directly in orbit. This approach bypasses the volume and structural load constraints imposed by rocket fairings during launch. Fused Filament Fabrication (FFF) is a primary candidate for ISM, but its application in the vacuum of space presents significant thermal challenges. Unlike terrestrial printing, where convection is a major cooling mechanism, a vacuum environment limits heat transfer to conduction and radiation. This study systematically investigates how these low-pressure conditions affect the mechanical and microstructural properties of four high-performance, space-grade polymers: PEEK, PEKK, ULTEM 9085, and ULTEM 1010.
Experimental Methodology
The researchers utilized a modified commercial FFF 3D printer integrated into a vacuum chamber. A critical modification was the addition of a liquid-cooled extruder to prevent "heat creep"—the premature melting of filament—which is exacerbated in a vacuum due to the lack of air cooling. The chamber was evacuated to pressures below 10 Pa to simulate a space-like environment.
To capture the anisotropic nature of 3D-printed parts, specimens were printed in various orientations (H-0°, H-90°, V-90°) and subjected to mechanical load testing, Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) for fracture analysis, and Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) to assess polymer crystallinity.
Results and Discussion
The Thermal Impact of Vacuum
The transition to a low-pressure environment fundamentally shifts the thermal history of the printed parts. In the absence of convection, geometry becomes the primary determinant of cooling. Flat, wide parts (H-0° and bending specimens) maintained consistent performance across both environments because their thermal history was dominated by conduction to the heated print bed. Conversely, smaller or taller geometries that rely on convection for cooling tended to overheat.
Mechanical Performance and "The Bubbling Menace"
Overheating in a vacuum led to the formation of internal voids or "bubbling" within the polymer. This was particularly evident in PEEK and PEKK specimens, where bubbling reduced the effective load-bearing cross-section. For instance, PEKK H-90° specimens experienced a ~50% drop in stiffness and a 35% drop in yield strength due to these internal defects.
However, the slower cooling rate in a vacuum offered a significant advantage for interlayer adhesion. Because the extruded plastic remained above its glass transition temperature for longer, it fused more effectively with previous layers. This was most notable in ULTEM 9085, which saw a 128.9% increase in yield strength for vertical (V-90°) specimens. Furthermore, the vacuum environment enabled the successful printing of ULTEM 1010, which consistently delaminated when printed under ambient atmospheric conditions.
Conclusion
While low-pressure additive manufacturing improves interlayer bonding and enables the use of certain difficult materials like ULTEM 1010, the lack of convective cooling introduces a significant risk of overheating and bubbling in small-geometry parts. Future work will focus on mitigating these thermal issues through optimized print paths (increasing revisit time), adjusted print temperatures, and pre-processing filaments to reduce outgassing. Developing robust thermal models will be essential for predicting part performance in the unique environment of space.
Summary updated