Changer le regard des étudiants sur les métiers de la comptabilité : Les effets de la simulation de gestion

Guillaume Dumas, Yann QuéménerFinance 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how business simulation exercises, compared to traditional tutorials, impact accounting students' perceptions of essential soft skills. The findings suggest that simulations provide a more realistic view of the profession, making accounting careers more appealing by bridging the gap between student perceptions and employer expectations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The accounting profession often suffers from negative stereotypes, being perceived as dull and boring, which deters students from pursuing it. This perception is further exacerbated by a perceived lack of crucial "soft skills" among accounting graduates, creating a gap between what employers expect and what students believe is important. This study aims to address this issue by exploring how pedagogical approaches can influence students' understanding and perception of these vital soft skills.

Methods

The researchers employed a quasi-experimental design, comparing two groups of undergraduate accounting students. One group received traditional tutorial instruction, focusing on applying knowledge through exercises. The other group participated in a management simulation, where they applied their knowledge to make decisions and manage a fictitious company. Both groups received the same lectures and had identical final assessments. Data was collected through questionnaires assessing students' perceptions of the importance of various soft skills for employers.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from 166 undergraduate management and business administration students. This included demographic information, their career intentions, and their perceptions of soft skills. Additionally, the researchers analyzed 120 job advertisements for management accountants to identify the soft skills employers explicitly sought.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Stereotypes are a major hurdle: The pervasive negative stereotypes surrounding accounting are a significant barrier to attracting students.
  • Soft skills are critical: Beyond technical knowledge, employers increasingly value soft skills like communication, collaboration, and adaptability.
  • Simulations offer a realistic glimpse: Business simulations provide a more immersive and practical experience, allowing students to understand the real-world application of soft skills in a business context.
  • Bridging the perception gap: Management simulations appear to be more effective than traditional methods in aligning students' perceptions of soft skills with those actually demanded by the profession.
  • Gender plays a role: Female students, in particular, may perceive a higher expectation of soft skills due to concerns about career opportunities and potential biases.

Key Results

  • Students who participated in the management simulation group generally perceived a wider range of soft skills as more important to employers compared to those in the traditional tutorial group.
  • Specifically, interpersonal skills like collaboration, team player, managing conflict, and effective communication were rated higher by the simulation group.
  • Intrapersonal skills such as proactivity, taking initiative, and offering ideas were also perceived as more important by students in the simulation group.
  • The study found no significant difference in hard skills acquisition between the two groups, indicating that management simulations do not hinder technical learning.
  • The analysis of job advertisements revealed a strong emphasis on both interpersonal skills (e.g., effective communicator, team player) and intrapersonal skills (e.g., analytical thinking, proactivity), highlighting the profession's need for versatile individuals.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their methodology was quasi-experimental, meaning students were not randomly assigned to groups, which could introduce some bias. They also note that it's challenging to definitively isolate the effect of the teaching practice from the general experience of participating in a simulation.

Future research directions suggested include:

  • Examining other active learning methods like flipped classrooms and problem-based learning.
  • Investigating the impact of these methods on the acquisition of "hybrid skills" (a combination of hard and soft skills).
  • Exploring the perceptions of soft skills among students in master's programs.
  • Further research into how universities can implement pedagogical measures to support and promote gender pay equality within the profession.

Summary updated

Abstract

La comptabilité véhicule souvent injustement, une image terne et ennuyeuse, auprès du grand public et des jeunes étudiants choisissant leur orientation. Dans cet article, nous questionnons l’effet de pratiques pédagogiques sur la perception par les étudiants, des soft skills attendues par les employeurs. Pour cela nous réalisons une quasi-expérimentation dans laquelle nous comparons les perceptions des étudiants selon que le cours ait été animé sous un format classique (application des connaissances par le biais d’exercices avec corrigé par l’enseignant) ou sous la forme d’une simulation de gestion (application des connaissances en vue de prendre des décisions et piloter une entreprise fictive). Les résultats de la recherche montrent qu’une simulation de gestion, plus que les travaux dirigés classiques, permettent aux primo-apprenants en comptabilité, d’avoir une meilleure perception des soft skills attendues par les praticiens et les recruteurs. Nos résultats rappellent l’importance de donner une représentation réaliste (éloignée des clichés) de la profession, afin de rendre les filières d’enseignement de la comptabilité plus attractives.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dumas2025changer,
  author = {Guillaume Dumas and Yann QUÉMÉNER},
  title = {{Changer le regard des étudiants sur les métiers de la comptabilité : Les effets de la simulation de gestion}},
  booktitle = {Finance},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.4000/14123},
}
Figure