Change in brain asymmetry reflects level of acute alcohol intoxication and impacts on inhibitory control

Julien Dubois, Ryan M. Field, Sami Jawhar, Austin Jewison, Erin Koch, Zahra M. Aghajan, Naomi Miller, Katherine L. Perdue, Moriah Taylor

TL;DR

This study uses time-domain functional near-infrared spectroscopy (TD-fNIRS) to show that changes in prefrontal brain asymmetry during an inhibitory control task are a more sensitive indicator of acute alcohol intoxication than behavioral performance or blood alcohol content (BAC) alone. These novel brain-based metrics offer a promising avenue for more robustly assessing impairment.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Acute alcohol intoxication is known to impair cognitive functions, particularly inhibitory control – the ability to suppress unwanted actions. While behavioral measures like reaction time and accuracy are commonly used to assess this impairment, they can be unreliable, especially at lower doses. Furthermore, the neural mechanisms underlying alcohol's effect on inhibitory control, and how these effects vary with dose, are not fully understood. Existing neuroimaging studies have produced conflicting results, potentially due to variations in alcohol dosing and measurement techniques. This paper aims to bridge this gap by investigating how different doses of alcohol affect both inhibitory control behavior and prefrontal brain activity, using a sensitive neuroimaging technique and novel analytical approaches.

Methods

The researchers employed a single-blind, placebo-controlled, randomized design with 48 healthy social drinkers. Each participant completed three study visits, receiving either a placebo, a low dose (target BAC 0.04%), or a moderate dose (target BAC 0.08%) of alcohol.

Key techniques and novel approaches include:

  • Time-Domain Functional Near-Infrared Spectroscopy (TD-fNIRS): This advanced neuroimaging technique was used to measure hemodynamic brain activity (oxygenated and deoxygenated hemoglobin) in the prefrontal cortex. TD-fNIRS offers enhanced depth sensitivity compared to traditional continuous-wave fNIRS.
  • Go/No-go Task: Participants performed an inhibitory control task where they had to respond to "go" stimuli and withhold responses to "no-go" stimuli. This task was administered before and after alcohol consumption.
  • Novel Lateralization Metrics: Beyond standard GLM-based analyses of prefrontal activity, the study introduced new metrics to quantify brain asymmetry. These included:
  • Direction Metric: A measure of the average signed difference between right and left prefrontal activity.
  • Angle and Magnitude Metrics: These metrics analyzed the temporal co-variation of left and right prefrontal activity by treating their time courses as a trajectory in a 2D plane, capturing both the direction and strength of hemispheric interaction.
  • Statistical Modeling: Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) regression models were used to assess the predictive power of BAC, behavioral performance, and the novel lateralization metrics on post-task performance.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from 48 healthy participants. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Behavioral Insensitivity at Low Doses: The study found that behavioral performance on the inhibitory control task was only significantly impaired at the moderate alcohol dose, not the low or placebo doses. This highlights the limitations of behavioral measures for detecting subtle intoxication effects.
  • Prefrontal Asymmetry as a Sensitive Indicator: Changes in prefrontal brain asymmetry, particularly in the right prefrontal cortex during inhibitory control, were observed to be dose-dependent and more sensitive to alcohol's effects than behavioral measures.
  • Novel Metrics Reveal Dose-Dependent Differences: The newly developed angle and magnitude metrics for brain asymmetry were able to significantly differentiate between placebo, low, and moderate alcohol doses, offering a more granular understanding of alcohol's impact on brain function.
  • Brain Metrics Complement BAC: Crucially, the lateralization metrics provided information about inhibitory impairment that was complementary to, and not overlapping with, BAC. This suggests that brain activity patterns can capture aspects of impairment (like tolerance) that BAC alone might miss.
  • Placebo Effect Modulates Brain Activity: The study found that participants who reported a placebo effect (believing they had consumed alcohol when they hadn't) showed distinct patterns in their brain activity compared to those who did not, suggesting a significant psychological component to alcohol's perceived effects.

Key Results

  • Behavioral Impairment: Moderate alcohol doses led to significantly worse performance (decreased d-prime) on the Go/No-go task compared to pre-dose and placebo conditions.
  • Brain Activity Differences:
    • Right lateralized prefrontal activity was observed during inhibitory control (go-no-go blocks), consistent with prior literature.
  • This right lateralization was significantly reduced in the moderate alcohol dose compared to the low dose.
  • The novel angle metric showed significant differences between placebo and both alcohol doses, and between the two alcohol doses themselves.
  • Predictive Power: OLS models showed that lateralization metrics (direction and angle) were significant predictors of post-behavioral performance, and models incorporating these metrics outperformed models relying solely on BAC. Specifically, models including lateralization metrics explained more variance in behavioral performance than BAC alone.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Dose Attenuation: The achieved BAC levels in the low and moderate dose sessions were lower than targeted, which may have limited the observed behavioral effects to only the moderate dose.
  • BAC Overlap: There was overlap in BAC values across dosing sessions, meaning some participants had similar BACs in different conditions, which could have influenced group-level statistics.
  • Placebo Effect: A significant portion of participants reported a placebo effect, which, along with session order, could have confounded some analyses.
  • Handedness: The study had a small number of left-handed participants, preventing a robust analysis of handedness as a potential confounder for brain asymmetry.
  • Blood Flow Confound: Alcohol consumption can affect blood flow, which could be a confound. However, the authors argue that their cross-hemispheric metrics are less susceptible to this.

Future work could explore these novel lateralization metrics in real-time applications, such as for brain-computer interfaces, and investigate their utility in clinical settings for assessing impairment beyond BAC. Further research could also explore the impact of handedness and refine dosing protocols to achieve more precise BAC targets.

Summary updated

Abstract

Alcohol is one of the most commonly used substances and frequently abused, yet little is known about the neural underpinnings driving variability in inhibitory control performance after ingesting alcohol. This study was a single-blind, placebo-controlled, randomized design with participants (N = 48 healthy, social drinkers) completing three study visits. At each visit participants received one of three alcohol doses; namely, a placebo dose [equivalent Blood Alcohol Concentration (BAC) = 0.00%], a low dose of alcohol (target BAC = 0.04%), or a moderate dose of alcohol (target BAC = 0.08%). To measure inhibitory control, participants completed a Go/No-go task paradigm twice during each study visit, once immediately before dosing and once after, while their brain activity was measured with time-domain functional near-infrared spectroscopy (TD-fNIRS). BAC and subjective effects of alcohol were also assessed. We report decreased behavioral performance for the moderate dose of alcohol, but not the low or placebo doses. We observed right lateralized inhibitory prefrontal activity during go-no-go blocks, consistent with prior literature. Using standard and novel metrics of lateralization, we were able to significantly differentiate between all doses. Lastly, we demonstrate that these metrics are not only related to behavioral performance during inhibitory control, but also provide complementary information to the legal gold standard of intoxication (i.e. BAC).
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dubois2023change,
  author = {Julien Dubois and Ryan M. Field and Sami Jawhar and Austin Jewison and Erin Koch and Zahra M. Aghajan and Naomi Miller and Katherine L. Perdue and Moriah Taylor},
  title = {{Change in brain asymmetry reflects level of acute alcohol intoxication and impacts on inhibitory control}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-023-37305-8},
}

Loading related content...

Figure