CC-VPSTO: Chance-Constrained Via-Point-based Stochastic Trajectory Optimisation for Safe and Efficient Online Robot Motion Planning

Lara Brudermüller, Guillaume Berger, Julius Jankowski, Raunak Bhattacharyya, Nick Hawes

TL;DR

This paper introduces CC-VPSTO, a novel framework for robot motion planning that safely navigates uncertain environments by ensuring constraints (like avoiding collisions) are met with high probability. It achieves this by using a clever Monte Carlo approximation of chance constraints and integrating it into a real-time Model Predictive Control (MPC) system, demonstrating its effectiveness in simulations and on a physical robot.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Robots operating in the real world constantly face uncertainty. This can come from noisy sensors, imprecise actuators, or unpredictable environments. Ensuring a robot's safety, particularly avoiding collisions or respecting physical limits, is paramount. Traditional "robust" control methods often err on the side of extreme caution, leading to inefficient or overly conservative movements. This paper tackles the challenge of generating robot trajectories that are both safe (satisfying constraints with high probability) and efficient (completing tasks quickly) in dynamic and uncertain environments, specifically within a real-time, online planning context.

Methods

The core of the paper is the Chance-Constrained Via-Point-Based Stochastic Trajectory Optimisation (CC-VPSTO) framework. It addresses the intractability of directly solving chance-constrained optimization problems by:

  • Monte Carlo (MC) Approximation: Instead of analytically calculating the probability of constraint violation, CC-VPSTO uses MC sampling to estimate this probability. This involves generating multiple "scenarios" or "samples" of the uncertain environment and checking if the proposed trajectory violates constraints in those scenarios.
  • Confidence-Bounded Surrogate Constraint: A key novelty is the introduction of a "confidence-bounded" surrogate constraint. This isn't just about meeting the probability threshold with the sampled data; it also accounts for the approximation error introduced by using a finite number of samples. This ensures that a solution satisfying the surrogate constraint is highly likely to satisfy the true, underlying chance constraint. They achieve this by deriving a threshold (kthresh) based on the number of samples (N) and a desired confidence level (1-β).
  • Integration with VP-STO and MPC: The CC-VPSTO framework is integrated into an existing motion planner called VP-STO, which uses via-points to represent trajectories. This is then embedded within a Model Predictive Control (MPC) loop, allowing for real-time, reactive planning where the robot continuously replans its path based on updated environmental information.
  • Gradient-Free Optimization: Due to the non-smooth nature of the problem, they employ a gradient-free optimization technique (CMA-ES) to find the optimal via-points.

Datasets

The paper does not introduce new datasets. Instead, it uses simulated environments and a real-world robot experiment to evaluate its approach. The "datasets" in this context are generated on-the-fly based on predefined uncertainty models (e.g., Gaussian distributions for obstacle positions, random walk models for obstacle dynamics).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Balancing Safety and Efficiency: The most significant insight is the principled way CC-VPSTO balances probabilistic safety with task efficiency. By adjusting the chance constraint threshold (η), users can explicitly trade off how conservative the robot needs to be versus how quickly it aims to complete its task.
  • The Importance of Confidence: Simply using a naive Monte Carlo approximation can lead to overly optimistic solutions that violate the true constraints. The paper highlights the critical need to account for the approximation error using a confidence bound, ensuring reliability even with limited samples.
  • Generality of the Approach: CC-VPSTO makes minimal assumptions about the uncertainty distribution, system dynamics, or cost functions. This makes it highly versatile for various robotics applications beyond just collision avoidance.
  • Real-time Applicability: Integrating the chance-constrained optimization into an MPC framework demonstrates that safe planning under uncertainty can be achieved in real-time, enabling reactive robot behavior.

Key Results

  • Simulation Experiments:
    • CC-VPSTO successfully generated collision-free trajectories with high probability across various scenarios, including Gaussian and multimodal uncertainty distributions.
  • The confidence-bounded approach (kbinom) consistently provided tighter bounds and better performance compared to a naive sample average approximation and a Rademacher complexity-based baseline, especially with fewer samples.
  • In MPC simulations, CC-VPSTO achieved high success rates (e.g., >90% for low η) and low collision rates, demonstrating its effectiveness in dynamic environments.
  • Robot Experiment:
    • On a physical robot, CC-VPSTO successfully navigated a stochastic conveyor belt obstacle, generating efficient trajectories that respected the probabilistic collision constraint.
  • The results showed a clear trade-off: higher η values led to shorter motion durations but a slightly increased (though still low) collision rate.
  • The approach demonstrated robustness even when the independence assumption of the MC samples was not strictly met in the MPC loop.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Independence Assumption: While the framework is designed to be general, Proposition 1 relies on the independence of Bernoulli variables, which might not strictly hold in the MPC setting due to the optimization process. The authors acknowledge this and suggest that their approach is a heuristic in such cases, though it performs well empirically.
  • Computational Cost: The Monte Carlo sampling and evaluation can be computationally intensive, especially with complex uncertainty models or high confidence requirements.
  • Handling Violations: The framework allows for probabilistic violations but doesn't explicitly define a recovery mechanism if a violation occurs.
  • Future Work:
    • Adaptive Sampling: Developing methods to adapt the number of samples (N) based on uncertainty complexity.
  • Discounted Chance Constraints: Incorporating time-varying probabilities of violation for future time steps.
  • Adaptive Parameters: Dynamically adjusting η and β during online execution.
  • Recursive Feasibility: Ensuring that a feasible solution always exists in the MPC loop.
  • Distributionally Robust Optimization: Addressing epistemic uncertainty (uncertainty in the uncertainty model itself).
  • Parallelization and GPU Acceleration: Improving computational efficiency.
  • Extending to Other Constraints: Applying the framework to interaction forces and human-robot interaction.

Summary updated

Abstract

Safety in the face of uncertainty is a key challenge in robotics. We introduce a real-time capable framework to generate safe and task-efficient robot motions for stochastic control problems. We frame this as a chance-constrained optimisation problem constraining the probability of the controlled system to violate a safety constraint to be below a set threshold. To estimate this probability we propose a Monte--Carlo approximation. We suggest several ways to construct the problem given a fixed number of uncertainty samples, such that it is a reliable over-approximation of the original problem, i.e. any solution to the sample-based problem adheres to the original chance-constraint with high confidence. To solve the resulting problem, we integrate it into our motion planner VP-STO and name the enhanced framework Chance-Constrained (CC)-VPSTO. The strengths of our approach lie in i) its generality, without assumptions on the underlying uncertainty distribution, system dynamics, cost function, or the form of inequality constraints; and ii) its applicability to MPC-settings. We demonstrate the validity and efficiency of our approach on both simulation and real-world robot experiments.
BibTeX
@misc{brudermuller2024cc,
  author = {Lara Brudermüller and Guillaume Berger and Julius Jankowski and Raunak Bhattacharyya and Nick Hawes},
  title = {{CC-VPSTO: Chance-Constrained Via-Point-based Stochastic Trajectory Optimisation for Safe and Efficient Online Robot Motion Planning}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2402.01370},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01370},
}
Figure