Causal Influence Maximization in Hypergraph

Xinyan Su, Zhiheng Zhang

Abstract

Influence Maximization (IM) aims to identify a seed set of nodes that maximizes information dissemination within a network. While traditional IM algorithms often assign static weights to nodes to reflect their importance, this approach fails to capture the dynamic reality of social interactions. This paper introduces the Causal Influence Maximization (CauIM) framework, which addresses two critical challenges: unobservability of counterfactual states and environmental sensitivity of individual gains. By leveraging Individual Treatment Effects (ITE) and a novel gradient-based acceleration technique, the proposed G-CauIM and A-CauIM algorithms demonstrate superior effectiveness and efficiency in both synthetic and real-world hypergraph networks.

The Challenge: Beyond Static Node Weights

Traditional Influence Maximization models typically assume that a node's "value" or "gain" is a constant, solvable through explicit formulas based on network topology. However, real-world social dynamics are far more complex. The authors identify two primary flaws in the static weight assumption:

  1. Unobservability: We can only observe one state for an individual—either they were influenced (e.g., bought a product) or they weren't. We cannot directly observe the counterfactual: what would have happened if the intervention had been different.
  2. Environmental Sensitivity: An individual's likelihood to be influenced is not just inherent; it is dynamic. As neighbors in a network change their status, the potential gain from targeting a specific node shifts during the propagation process.
Figure 1: Illustration of unobservability and environmental sensitivity in a network where individual gains depend on surrounding status.

Furthermore, social structures are often better represented as hypergraphs, where edges (hyperedges) can connect more than two nodes, representing group-based interactions like book clubs or group chats.

The CauIM Framework

To address these dynamics, the researchers propose replacing static weights with the Individual Treatment Effect (ITE). In this context, ITE represents the difference in profit between a node being activated versus remaining inactive. The framework utilizes Hypergraph Convolutional Networks for representation learning to estimate these unobservable ITEs.

Figure 2: The CauIM workflow, including initialization, diffusion process modeling, ITE estimation, and seed selection.

The paper introduces two primary algorithms:

  • G-CauIM (Greedy): Uses a greedy selection process to identify optimal seeds based on estimated ITEs.
  • A-CauIM (Accelerated): Addresses the computational bottleneck of greedy search by approximating the diffusion process as a continuous, differentiable function. This allows the use of gradient descent and GPU acceleration, transforming a discrete search problem into a highly efficient optimization task.

Key Insights and Results

Challenging SUTVA

Most causal inference models rely on the Stable Unit Treatment Value Assumption (SUTVA), which assumes one person's treatment doesn't affect another. CauIM explicitly breaks this rule, modeling how the social "environment" dynamically shifts a node's value during propagation.

Performance and Efficiency

The framework was evaluated on diverse datasets, including GoodReads (author/category networks), Contact (human proximity), and Email-Eu (institutional communication).

  • Superior Gains: In all tests, G-CauIM and A-CauIM outperformed traditional greedy baselines. For instance, on the GoodReads dataset, G-CauIM achieved a total gain of 330.25, significantly higher than the baseline's 297.56.
  • Massive Speedups: The A-CauIM algorithm provided the most dramatic results in terms of efficiency. On the GoodReads dataset, while the traditional greedy baseline required one full day to complete, A-CauIM achieved comparable results in just 28 seconds.

Robustness

The model demonstrated high resilience to data errors. By adding Gaussian noise to ITE estimations, the authors found the framework remained stable until noise levels reached a very high threshold, suggesting it is well-suited for imperfect, real-world data.

Conclusion

By integrating causal inference with hypergraph theory, this research provides a more realistic and computationally feasible approach to Influence Maximization. While future work remains to address temporal network topologies and incomplete data visibility, the CauIM framework—particularly the accelerated A-CauIM—marks a significant step forward in making complex network optimization differentiable and scalable.

Summary updated

Abstract

Influence Maximization (IM) is to identify the seed set to maximize information dissemination in a network. Elegant IM algorithms could naturally extend to cases where each node is equipped with a specific weight, reflecting individual gains to measure the node's importance. Prevailing literature typically assumes such individual gains remain constant throughout the cascade process and are solvable through explicit formulas based on the node's characteristics and network topology. However, this assumption is not always feasible for two reasons: 1)Unobservability: The individual gains of each node are primarily evaluated by the difference between the outputs in the activated and non-activated states. In practice, we can only observe one of these states, with the other remaining unobservable post-propagation. 2)Environmental sensitivity: In addition to the node's inherent properties, individual gains are also sensitive to the activation status of surrounding nodes, which is dynamic during iteration even when the network topology remains static. To address these challenges, we extend the consideration of IM to a broader scenario with dynamic node individual gains, leveraging causality techniques. In our paper, we introduce a Causal Influence Maximization (CauIM) framework and develop two algorithms, G-CauIM and A-CauIM, where the latter incorporates a novel acceleration technique. Theoretically, we establish the generalized lower bound of influence spread and provide robustness analysis. Empirically, in synthetic and real-world experiments, we demonstrate the effectiveness and robustness of our algorithms.
BibTeX
@misc{su2023causal,
  author = {Xinyan Su and Zhiheng Zhang},
  title = {{Causal Influence Maximization in Hypergraph}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2301.12226},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12226},
}
Figure