Carbon Monitor Europe near-real-time daily CO2 emissions for 27 EU countries and the United Kingdom

Piyu Ke, Zhu Deng, Biqing Zhu, Bo Zheng, Yilong Wang, Oliviér Boucher, Simon Ben Arous, Chuanlong Zhou, Robbie M. Andrew, Xinyu Dou, Taochun Sun, Xuanren Song, Zhao Li, Feifan Yan, Duo Cui, Yifan Hu, Da Huo, Jean-Pierre Chang, Richard Engelen, Steven J. Davis, Philippe Ciais, Zhu Liu

TL;DR

This paper introduces "Carbon Monitor Europe" (CM-EU), a new dataset providing near-real-time daily CO2 emissions for 27 EU countries and the UK, broken down by six key sectors. This fills a critical gap by offering timely data that captures short-term emission fluctuations, unlike traditional annual inventories, which is essential for monitoring climate policies and responding to global events.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Current official CO2 emissions inventories, like those reported to the UNFCCC, are typically annual and come with a significant time lag of over a year. This delay makes it impossible to quickly assess the impact of major events such as the COVID-19 pandemic, economic shifts, or geopolitical conflicts on emissions. Furthermore, these inventories often lack the temporal resolution needed to effectively monitor the progress of climate policies like the EU's Green Deal, which requires frequent and detailed insights into emission trends. The authors address this by developing a dataset that provides daily, country-level CO2 emissions with a much shorter latency.

Methods

The CM-EU dataset is built upon the methodology of the global Carbon Monitor initiative. The core approach involves using annual CO2 emissions data from the Emissions Database for Global Atmospheric Research (EDGAR) for the baseline year 2019. This annual data is then disaggregated into daily estimates for 2020 and 2021 by leveraging a variety of activity data sources for six specific sectors: power, industry, ground transportation, domestic aviation, international aviation, and residential.

Key activity data sources include:

  • Power: Hourly electricity generation data from ENTSO-E and BMRS.
  • Industry: Monthly Industrial Production Index (IPI) and daily electricity generation data.
  • Ground Transportation: TomTom traffic congestion data, which captures daily variations in road traffic.
  • Aviation: Individual commercial flight data from Flightradar24.
  • Residential: Population-weighted heating degree days derived from ERA5 reanalysis data.

For countries not covered by specific data sources (e.g., Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, Romania, Sweden for power), emissions are estimated using linear relationships with the total daily emissions of other covered countries in the same sector.

Datasets

The primary datasets used in the creation of CM-EU include:

  • EDGAR (Emissions Database for Global Atmospheric Research): Used as the baseline for annual CO2 emissions in 2019.
  • ENTSO-E Transparency platform & BMRS (Balancing Mechanism Reporting Service): For hourly electricity generation data.
  • Eurostat: For Industrial Production Index (IPI) data.
  • Central Statistics Office (Ireland) & Office for National Statistics (UK): For country-specific IPI data.
  • TomTom Traffic Index: For daily traffic congestion data.
  • FlightRadar24: For individual commercial flight data.
  • Copernicus Climate Change Service (C3S) ERA5 reanalysis: For daily air temperature data.

The CM-EU dataset itself is a newly introduced benchmark, providing near-real-time daily CO2 emissions for 27 EU countries and the UK from January 2019 to December 2021.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of Near-Real-Time Data: The study highlights how timely emissions data can reveal rapid responses to events like lockdowns and economic shifts, which annual inventories miss entirely.
  • Sectoral Dynamics: The breakdown by sector is crucial, showing distinct emission patterns and responses across power, industry, transport, aviation, and residential use. For instance, aviation emissions saw a dramatic drop during COVID-19, while residential emissions showed more seasonal variations.
  • Data Fusion is Key: The methodology successfully integrates diverse data streams (electricity generation, traffic, flights, temperature) to construct a comprehensive emissions picture.
  • Policy Monitoring Potential: CM-EU offers a vital tool for policymakers to track the effectiveness of climate mitigation strategies in near real-time, enabling quicker adjustments and interventions.

Key Results

The CM-EU dataset provides daily CO2 emissions for 27 EU countries and the UK from January 2019 to December 2021. The paper presents figures showing smoothed daily emissions for various countries and sectors, illustrating significant drops in emissions during 2020 (due to COVID-19) and subsequent rebounds in 2021. For example, the EU27 & UK saw a relative change of -2.71% (-88.48 Mt CO2) in 2021 compared to 2019. Sectoral analysis reveals that while power and industry emissions showed some recovery, international aviation experienced a substantial decrease. The technical validation section demonstrates good agreement between CM-EU estimates and other datasets (EDGAR, BP, IEA, GCP, Eurostat, national statistics, Kayrros, CREA, CICERO), with relative differences generally within acceptable ranges, particularly for annual and quarterly totals.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Uncertainty: The authors acknowledge uncertainties inherited from the EDGAR baseline data and the downscaling methods. Overall uncertainty is estimated at ±13.6%. Specific sector uncertainties range from ±9.3% (ground transport) to ±40.0% (residential).
  • Data Gaps: For some countries and sectors, emissions were estimated by assuming linear relationships with other countries due to data limitations.
  • Assumptions: The methodology relies on assumptions such as constant emission factors and linear relationships between activity data and emissions, which may not hold true in all cases. For example, the residential sector's reliance on gas consumption data might not fully capture emissions from coal and oil use in some countries.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that the methodology can be extended to cover more countries and sectors. Further investigation into the differences in emission factors deduced by Kayrros versus CM-EU for France's power sector is also noted as an area for future research. The authors also highlight the potential for CM-EU to be updated with more recent data as it becomes available.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the urgent need to implement the EU countries pledges and to monitor the effectiveness of Green Deal plan, Monitoring Reporting and Verification tools are needed to track how emissions are changing for all the sectors. Current official inventories only provide annual estimates of national CO<sub>2</sub> emissions with a lag of 1+ year which do not capture the variations of emissions due to recent shocks including COVID lockdowns and economic rebounds, war in Ukraine. Here we present a near-real-time country-level dataset of daily fossil fuel and cement emissions from January 2019 through December 2021 for 27 EU countries and UK, which called Carbon Monitor Europe. The data are calculated separately for six sectors: power, industry, ground transportation, domestic aviation, international aviation and residential. Daily CO<sub>2</sub> emissions are estimated from a large set of activity data compiled from different sources. The goal of this dataset is to improve the timeliness and temporal resolution of emissions for European countries, to inform the public and decision makers about current emissions changes in Europe.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ke2023carbon,
  author = {Piyu Ke and Zhu Deng and Biqing Zhu and Bo Zheng and Yilong Wang and Oliviér Boucher and Simon Ben Arous and Chuanlong Zhou and Robbie M. Andrew and Xinyu Dou and Taochun Sun and Xuanren Song and Zhao Li and Feifan Yan and Duo Cui and Yifan Hu and Da Huo and Jean-Pierre Chang and Richard Engelen and Steven J. Davis and Philippe Ciais and Zhu Liu},
  title = {{Carbon Monitor Europe near-real-time daily CO2 emissions for 27 EU countries and the United Kingdom}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41597-023-02284-y},
}
Figure