Capacity Comparison between MIMO-NOMA and MIMO-OMA with Multiple Users in a Cluster

Ming Zeng, Animesh Yadav, Octavia A. Dobre, Georgios I. Tsiropoulos, H. Vincent Poor

Abstract

In this paper, the performance of multiple-input multiple-output non-orthogonal multiple access (MIMO-NOMA) is investigated when multiple users are grouped into a cluster. The superiority of MIMO-NOMA over MIMO orthogonal multiple access (MIMO-OMA) in terms of both sum channel capacity and ergodic sum capacity is proved analytically. Furthermore, it is demonstrated that the more users are admitted to a cluster, the lower is the achieved sum rate, which illustrates the tradeoff between the sum rate and maximum number of admitted users. On this basis, a user admission scheme is proposed, which is optimal in terms of both sum rate and number of admitted users when the signal-to-interference-plus-noise ratio thresholds of the users are equal. When these thresholds are different, the proposed scheme still achieves good performance in balancing both criteria. Moreover, under certain conditions, it maximizes the number of admitted users. In addition, the complexity of the proposed scheme is linear to the number of users per cluster. Simulation results verify the superiority of MIMO-NOMA over MIMO-OMA in terms of both sum rate and user fairness, as well as the effectiveness of the proposed user admission scheme.

Introduction

As the telecommunications industry moves toward 5G and 6G standards, spectral efficiency has become a primary design constraint. Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access (NOMA) has emerged as a critical technology to meet these demands by allowing multiple users to share the same time and frequency resources through power-domain multiplexing. While previous research has demonstrated NOMA's potential through simulations or simplified two-user models, two significant gaps remained: the lack of a rigorous analytical proof of NOMA's superiority in multi-user clusters and a clear understanding of how total throughput scales as more users are added to a single cluster.

This research addresses these gaps by providing a formal proof that MIMO-NOMA strictly outperforms MIMO Orthogonal Multiple Access (MIMO-OMA) in terms of channel capacity. Additionally, it identifies a fundamental tradeoff between user count and sum rate, proposing a linear-complexity admission scheme to optimize system performance.

Theoretical Framework and Methodology

The study models a downlink multiuser MIMO system where a Base Station (BS) communicates with users grouped into clusters. The system utilizes two core NOMA mechanisms:

  1. Superposition Coding (SC): The BS transmits a composite signal where users are assigned varying power levels based on their channel conditions.
  2. Successive Interference Cancellation (SIC): Receivers isolate their intended data by decoding and subtracting signals meant for users with weaker channel conditions.

To establish the superiority of NOMA, the authors employed mathematical induction. They proved that for any given power allocation used in an OMA configuration, there exists a corresponding NOMA configuration that achieves a higher sum rate. This proof holds for both instantaneous sum channel capacity and ergodic (average) sum capacity, regardless of the specific channel distribution.

The "More is Less" Paradox

A significant contribution of this paper is the identification of a tradeoff between the number of users in a cluster and the total achieved sum rate. Contrary to the intuition that more users might increase total system throughput, the authors found that as more users are admitted to a cluster, the sum rate actually decreases.

This occurs because satisfying the Signal-to-Interference-plus-Noise Ratio (SINR) requirements of additional users—particularly those with weaker channels—requires the BS to divert power away from "stronger" users. This redistribution, combined with an increased interference floor, results in a lower overall sum rate for the cluster. This finding highlights the necessity of a strategic user admission policy.

Proposed User Admission Scheme

To navigate the tradeoff between sum rate and user capacity, the authors developed a User Admission Scheme. The algorithm iteratively calculates the minimum power required to satisfy each user's specific Quality of Service (QoS) or SINR threshold. If the cumulative power required exceeds the total power budget of the BS, the admission process terminates.

Key features of this scheme include:

  • Optimality: It is optimal in terms of both sum rate and the number of admitted users when users share equal SINR thresholds.
  • Efficiency: The scheme operates with linear complexity ($O(L)$), where $L$ is the number of users per cluster, making it computationally feasible for real-time implementation compared to exhaustive search methods.

Simulation Results and Discussion

The theoretical findings were validated using Monte Carlo simulations. The simulation environment utilized a BS and users each equipped with three antennas ($M=3, N=3$) and a standard path-loss model ($114 + 38 \log_{10}(d)$).

  • Sum Rate Performance: NOMA consistently maintained a higher sum rate (bps/Hz) than OMA across transmit power levels ranging from 10 to 50 dBm.
  • User Fairness: Using Jain’s Fairness Index, the study demonstrated that NOMA provides a more balanced rate distribution. While OMA tends to favor users with the best channel conditions to maximize throughput, NOMA ensures more equitable access.
  • Algorithm Effectiveness: The proposed linear admission scheme achieved performance nearly identical to an exhaustive search algorithm but with significantly lower computational overhead.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This research provides the first formal analytical proof that MIMO-NOMA is superior to MIMO-OMA for multi-user clusters. While it confirms NOMA's spectral advantages, it also cautions designers about the sum-rate degradation that occurs as clusters grow larger.

Future work may address current limitations, such as the assumption of perfect Successive Interference Cancellation (SIC). In practical applications, residual interference from imperfect decoding can accumulate. Additionally, exploring the impact of imperfect Channel State Information (CSI) and developing optimal multi-cluster user pairing strategies remain vital areas for further investigation.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{zeng2017capacity,
  author = {Ming Zeng and Animesh Yadav and Octavia A. Dobre and Georgios I. Tsiropoulos and H. Vincent Poor},
  title = {{Capacity Comparison between MIMO-NOMA and MIMO-OMA with Multiple Users in a Cluster}},
  journal = {IEEE J. Sel. Areas Commun.},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1109/jsac.2017.2725879},
}
Figure