Abstract
The stable secondary-to-primary flux ratios of cosmic rays (CRs), represented by the boron-to-carbon ratio (B/C), are the main probes of the Galactic CR propagation. However, the fluorine-to-silicon ratio (F/Si) predicted by the CR diffusion coefficient inferred from B/C is significantly higher than the latest measurement of AMS-02. This anomaly is commonly attributed to the uncertainties of the F production cross sections. In this work, we give a careful test to this interpretation. We consider four different cross-section parametric models. Each model is constrained by the latest cross-section data. We perform combined fits to the B/C, F/Si, and cross-section data with the same propagation framework. Two of the cross-section models have good overall goodness of fit with $χ^2/n_{d.o.f.}\sim1$. However, the goodness of fit of the cross-section part is poor with $χ^2_{\rm{cs}}/n_{\rm{cs}}\gtrsim2$ for these models. The best-fitted F production cross sections are systematically larger than the measurements, while the fitted cross sections for B production are systematically lower than the measurements. This indicates that the F anomaly can hardly be interpreted by neither the random errors of the cross-section measurements nor the differences between the existing cross-section models. We then propose that the spatially dependent diffusion model could help to explain B/C and F/Si consistently. In this model, the average diffusion coefficient of the Ne-Si group is expected to be larger than that of the C-O group.
The Cosmic Fluorine Anomaly
In cosmic ray (CR) physics, the Boron-to-Carbon (B/C) ratio serves as the primary "standard candle" for determining how particles propagate through the Galaxy. Boron is a secondary nucleus, produced by the fragmentation of primary nuclei like Carbon and Oxygen as they traverse the interstellar medium. By measuring the B/C ratio, researchers can infer the properties of Galactic diffusion.
However, a significant discrepancy arises when these propagation parameters are applied to heavier species. Specifically, the Fluorine-to-Silicon (F/Si) ratio predicted by models tuned to B/C data is much higher than the high-precision measurements recently provided by the Alpha Magnetic Spectrometer (AMS-02). This mismatch is known as the Cosmic Fluorine Anomaly.
Testing the "Nuclear Excuse"
The most common explanation for this anomaly has been the uncertainty in nuclear production cross-sections—the probability that a parent nucleus (like Neon or Silicon) will shatter into Fluorine. To test if these uncertainties can truly bridge the gap, this study performed a simultaneous fit of B/C ratios, F/Si ratios, and actual laboratory cross-section data using the GALPROP framework and a Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) engine.
The researchers tested four major cross-section parametrization models: WE93, TS00, GAL12, and GAL22. The results show that even when allowing these models maximum flexibility, they cannot reconcile the CR flux data with laboratory measurements. To fit the AMS-02 fluorine data, the models required cross-section values that are statistically incompatible with experimental lab data ($\chi^2_{cs}/n_{cs} \gtrsim 2$). Furthermore, the "best fits" required systematically increasing fluorine production while decreasing boron production, a contradictory requirement that points to a fundamental issue in the propagation physics rather than random measurement errors.
A Spatial Solution: Dependent Diffusion
If nuclear physics isn't the culprit, the error must lie in our assumptions about Galactic propagation. The authors propose a spatially dependent diffusion model. Because heavier nuclei like Silicon and Neon fragment more easily than Carbon or Oxygen, they have shorter mean free paths and thus probe a more "local" Galactic environment.
In this model, the diffusion coefficient is not a global constant but varies spatially. The analysis reveals that the Ne-Si group (the parents of Fluorine) likely experiences a larger average diffusion coefficient than the C-O group (the parents of Boron). This spatial variation naturally explains the lower observed flux of Fluorine without requiring unrealistic adjustments to nuclear cross-sections.
Conclusion
This work systematically demonstrates that the Cosmic Fluorine Anomaly cannot be explained away by uncertainties in nuclear cross-sections. Instead, the discrepancy suggests that our understanding of Galactic CR transport must evolve to include spatial dependencies. While this model adds complexity, it provides a consistent physical framework that aligns both laboratory nuclear data and space-based cosmic ray observations. Future high-energy cross-section measurements will be vital to further validating this new paradigm.
Summary updated