Calculation of Moments of Number of Comparisons used by the Randomized Quick Sort Algorithm

Sumit Kumar Jha

TL;DR

This paper revisits and clarifies a method for calculating the moments (like mean and variance) of the number of comparisons made by the randomized Quick Sort algorithm. The authors emphasize that this approach simplifies the computation and also applies to calculating moments for the total path length of binary search trees.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Quick Sort is a fundamental sorting algorithm, but analyzing its performance, particularly the number of comparisons it makes, can be mathematically complex. While the mean and variance of comparisons for randomized Quick Sort are known (thanks to Knuth), deriving these quantities can involve intricate calculations. This paper aims to provide a clearer and more computationally efficient way to derive these moments, building upon existing work by Kirschenhofer, Prodinger, and Tichy. The problem is to find a streamlined mathematical framework for these performance metrics.

Methods

The core of the paper's method involves using probability generating functions (PGFs) and double generating functions. They start by defining the PGF for the number of comparisons in Quick Sort ($G_n(z)$) and then introduce a double generating function ($H(z,u)$) that encapsulates these PGFs for all $n$. By manipulating these generating functions, particularly through differential equations, they derive formulas for the factorial moments of the number of comparisons. The paper also leverages Taylor's theorem and properties of differential equations to derive closed-form expressions for these moments. A key aspect is the re-emphasis of a method that simplifies the derivation process compared to direct combinatorial counting.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Computational Efficiency: The primary insight is that the generating function approach, as revisited and presented here, significantly reduces the computational effort required to derive the moments of Quick Sort's comparison count.
  • Unified Framework: The method isn't limited to Quick Sort's comparisons; it's shown to be applicable to calculating moments for the total path length of binary search trees, highlighting a broader utility of the technique.
  • Clarity and Re-emphasis: The paper aims to re-emphasize and clarify an existing method, making it more accessible and demonstrating its power.
  • Differential Equations as a Tool: The paper effectively uses differential equations derived from the generating functions to solve for the moments, showcasing a powerful analytical tool for algorithm analysis.

Key Results

The paper successfully re-derives and presents the formulas for the mean and variance of the number of comparisons for randomized Quick Sort, confirming Knuth's results:

  • Mean ($E[C_n]$): $2((n + 1)H_n – n)$, where $H_n$ is the $n$-th harmonic number.
  • Variance ($Var(C_n)$): $7n² - 4(n + 1)²H_n^{(2)} – 2(n + 1)H_n + 13n$, where $H_n^{(2)}$ is the $n$-th generalized harmonic number of order 2.

The paper also derives formulas for the first few factorial moments ($\beta_s(n)$) and their generating functions ($f_s(u)$), which are crucial intermediate steps.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Asymptotic Theory: The authors mention that for a deeper understanding of the asymptotic behavior of the differential equations involved, readers should refer to a specific paper [1]. This suggests that the current paper focuses on exact derivations rather than asymptotic analysis.
  • Generalization: While the paper shows applicability to binary search trees, further exploration of its use for other algorithmic analyses is a natural extension.
  • Higher Moments: The paper focuses on the first two moments (mean and variance) and derives formulas for the first few factorial moments. Analyzing even higher moments could provide more detailed insights into the distribution of comparisons.

Summary updated

Abstract

We revisit the method of Kirschenhofer, Prodinger and Tichy to calculate the moments of comparisons used by the quick sort algorithm. We reemphasize that this approach helps in calculating these quantities with less computation. We also point out that as observed by Knuth this method also gives moments for total path length of a binary search tree built over a random set of n keys.
BibTeX
@misc{jha2016calculation,
  author = {Sumit Kumar Jha},
  title = {{Calculation of Moments of Number of Comparisons used by the Randomized Quick Sort Algorithm}},
  year = {2016},
  eprint = {1609.01870},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1609.01870},
}
Figure