Business Models for the Next Generation of Mobile Communications

Ghoul Smail, Weijia Jia

Abstract: The transition to 5G mobile networks, based on high-speed wireless broadband, promises to revolutionize how individuals and businesses use telecommunications. However, it also presents a challenge: solving the explosive growth in data demand while reversing the declining profitability of the mobile broadband market. This paper presents a business analysis and mathematical modeling approach for Operator Mobile Networks (OMNs) planning 5G deployment beyond 2020. By proposing a new pricing model and analyzing Price Elasticity of Demand (PED), the study demonstrates that 5G is highly beneficial due to lower unit costs compared to 4G LTE, increased data consumption, and subscriber growth. While site reuse significantly reduces deployment costs, challenges remain regarding the limited coverage of millimeter-wave systems and small cell solutions.

TL;DR

This paper explores how mobile network operators (OMNs) can escape the "profitability trap" during the transition to 5G. By combining subscriber growth forecasting (Bass model) with techno-economic analysis, the authors demonstrate that 5G is significantly more cost-effective per gigabyte than 4G, provided operators leverage existing infrastructure and adopt context-aware pricing models.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The telecommunications industry is facing a "scissors effect": while mobile data traffic is exploding, the profitability of traditional mobile broadband is decreasing. Operators are caught in a trap where the cost to expand network capacity often exceeds the revenue generated from flat-rate data plans.

The 'scissors effect' where revenue declines faster than unit costs, leading to a profitability trap.

As the industry moves toward 5G, operators need a roadmap that balances the massive Capital Expenditure (CAPEX) required for new infrastructure with sustainable revenue models. The authors seek to answer: How can OMNs deploy 5G profitably, and what pricing strategies will actually work in a world of near-limitless data demand?

Methods

The authors employ a multi-disciplinary approach to model the 5G business case:

  • Bass Diffusion Model: Used to predict 5G adoption rates in Shanghai over a six-year period (2020–2025). This model distinguishes between "innovators" (early adopters) and "imitators" to forecast when the market will reach saturation.
  • Techno-Economic Modeling: The researchers compared two primary deployment scenarios: full replacement of base station equipment at new sites versus reusing existing sites and upgrading them with new Radio Access Technology (RAT).
  • Elasticity Modeling: They introduced two key economic concepts to find the "sweet spot" for pricing: Price Elasticity of Volume (PED), measuring how sensitive data consumption is to price changes, and Volume Elasticity of Revenue ($E_R(V)$), measuring how revenue responds to changes in total data volume.
  • Context-Aware Pricing: A proposed shift from simple volume-based charging to a model based on time of use, content type (e.g., video vs. web), and location.

Datasets

The paper uses a case study approach focused on Shanghai, China.

  • Demographic Data: Population density (3,854/km²), total population (25 million), and existing subscriber counts (30 million) were used to calibrate the Bass model.
  • Cost Benchmarks: CAPEX and OPEX figures were sourced from industry literature (e.g., Tellabs, Ericsson, and IEEE studies), including specific costs for Macro Base Stations (MaBS), Micro Base Stations (MiBS), and Femtocells (FBS).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Efficiency of 5G: The authors estimate 5G network costs at approximately $0.75 per GB, which is significantly lower than 4G LTE. This unit-cost reduction is the primary driver for 5G's viability.
  • The Power of Site Reuse: Reusing existing 4G sites for 5G deployment is "significantly lower" in CAPEX than building new sites. For OMNs, the most cost-efficient path isn't a "rip and replace" but a strategic upgrade of the current macro grid.
  • Pricing Sweet Spot: Through their elasticity modeling, they found that revenue is maximized when the Price Elasticity of Demand is exactly one. In their specific model, this occurred at a price of roughly $2 per GB.
Determining the optimal price point where Price Elasticity of Demand (PED) equals one.
  • The "Extended Package" Policy: To prevent users from feeling they are wasting unused data in large 5G bundles, the authors propose a rollover policy where unused data expires after one month. This encourages users to opt for larger, more profitable packages.

Key Results

  • Profitability: The study found that selling 100 GB of 5G data is much more profitable than selling 150 GB at a lower price point ($125 profit vs. $37.50), highlighting the danger of aggressive price wars.
  • Cost Savings: 5G millimeter-wave (mmW) sites were estimated to have 30% lower CAPEX and OPEX compared to 4G LTE-A RAT when deployed in smart city contexts.
  • Network Density: To compensate for wall penetration losses (12 dB attenuation), the authors calculated that a network at 2.6 GHz would need to be 5 times denser than a standard outdoor network to provide adequate indoor coverage.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Coverage vs. Capacity: A major hurdle identified is the trade-off between the high capacity of 5G mmW and its limited coverage (especially through walls).
  • Monopoly Assumption: The current model assumes a monopoly market to simplify the analysis. The authors acknowledge that real-world competition would significantly complicate pricing strategies and ROI.
  • Future Work: The authors plan to expand their research to include prospective comparisons between their proposed context-aware pricing and traditional "flat-rate" or "capped" pricing strategies in competitive multi-operator environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Next Generation of mobile network 5G, which will be based on a high-speed wireless broadband connection, could bring important changes to the way individuals and businesses employ telecommunications services and solve the issues related to the explosive growth in demand for mobile traffic, and the profitability decreasing of the mobile Broadband market. Therefore, the OMNs (Operator Mobile Networks) should plan for deploying 5G mobile network beyond 2020, which is the expected year for launching 5G. A business analysis study and mathematic modelling approach was considered. Also, a new pricing model is proposed to be consistent with the growth of mobile broadband. The results show that 5G is very beneficial, not only because of its lower cost compared with 4G LTE, but also due to the increment of average data consumptions offered by 5G mobile technologies and the increasing growth of number of users. We also found that good analysis of Price Elasticity of Volume (PED) gives an important margin of benefit. We confirm that the reuse of existing sites have a large impact on reducing costs when a denser macro network deployed. However, we encountered a lack of the limited capacity related to the macro sites and coverage limited with small cell solutions like femtocells, picocells deployed with 5G millimeter Wave system and Wi-Fi.
BibTeX
@article{smail2017business,
  author = {Ghoul Smail and Weijia Jia},
  title = {{Business Models for the Next Generation of Mobile Communications}},
  journal = {International Journal of Mobile Network Communications \& Telematics},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.5121/ijmnct.2017.7202},
}
Figure