Bridging the Gap Between Imitation Learning and Inverse Reinforcement Learning

Bilal Piot, Matthieu Geist, Olivier Pietquin

TL;DR

This paper introduces the "set-policy framework" to formally bridge the gap between Imitation Learning (IL) and Inverse Reinforcement Learning (IRL), showing they are equivalent under a specific transformation. This unification leads to new algorithms that leverage the strengths of both approaches, resulting in more robust and performant agents.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Learning from Demonstrations (LfD) is a powerful paradigm where an agent learns by observing an expert. Traditionally, this has been approached through two main methods: Imitation Learning (IL), which directly mimics expert actions, and Inverse Reinforcement Learning (IRL), which infers the expert's underlying reward function. While both aim to replicate expert behavior, they are often seen as distinct and even opposing. IL struggles to account for the environment's dynamics, while IRL is notoriously ill-posed and often requires solving complex Markov Decision Processes (MDPs) repeatedly. This paper addresses the challenge of unifying these two approaches, aiming to create a framework that benefits from both the directness of IL and the dynamic awareness of IRL, while mitigating their individual weaknesses.

Methods

The core contribution is the set-policy framework. This framework redefines IL and IRL in terms of "set-policies," which represent the set of actions an agent might take in a given state, rather than a single deterministic action. The key insight is the demonstration of a bijective operator, specifically the inverse optimal Bellman operator (J*), that maps between the solution spaces of IL and IRL. This operator establishes a formal equivalence: a score function in IL corresponds to a reward function in IRL, and vice-versa.

This framework allows for:

  • Unification: IL and IRL are shown to be two sides of the same coin, allowing for algorithms that combine their strengths.
  • New Algorithms: The framework naturally leads to the derivation of existing IRL algorithms (like CSI and SCIRL) and provides a general method for designing new IL algorithms that incorporate environmental dynamics.
  • Mitigation of Weaknesses: IL gains the ability to consider environmental dynamics, and IRL becomes better-defined and potentially more efficient.

The paper also proposes two meta-algorithms for safe IRL, which can be instantiated to derive specific algorithms.

Datasets

The paper uses synthetic datasets generated from Garnet problems. These are randomly generated MDPs designed to be representative of real-world scenarios, allowing for controlled experiments. The authors modify these Garnet problems to test algorithms under various conditions, including known/unknown dynamics and different reward function representations (tabular vs. Radial Basis Functions).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • IL and IRL are fundamentally linked: The paper proves that IL and IRL are not opposing paradigms but rather different perspectives on the same underlying problem, connected by the inverse optimal Bellman operator.
  • The "set-policy" is a powerful abstraction: By moving from deterministic policies to sets of actions, the framework elegantly captures the essence of both IL and IRL.
  • Dynamics are crucial for robust learning: The experiments highlight that IRL algorithms that leverage environmental dynamics (even if imperfectly known) generally outperform IL algorithms that ignore them, especially in complex scenarios.
  • Unification simplifies algorithm design: The set-policy framework provides a clear path to derive existing algorithms and design new ones, streamlining research in this area.
  • Set-policy based algorithms are more robust: Experimental results show that algorithms derived from this framework exhibit lower variance in their performance, indicating greater stability.

Key Results

The experiments compare algorithms derived from the set-policy framework (CSI, SCIRL) against traditional trajectory-matching IRL algorithms and IL algorithms (Tree, Classif, RCAL).

  • Outperformance: CSI and SCIRL generally outperform trajectory-matching IRL algorithms, especially when data is scarce.
  • Robustness: Set-policy based algorithms (CSI, SCIRL, RCAL) demonstrate lower standard deviations in performance, indicating more stable learning.
  • Importance of Dynamics: IRL algorithms that utilize dynamics information (even limited) show better performance than IL algorithms that ignore it.
  • Feature Engineering Matters for Parametric IRL: For algorithms like SCIRL, a good representation of the reward function (e.g., tabular basis) is crucial for high performance.
  • CSI's Adaptability: CSI, being non-parametric, shows good performance across various settings, especially when dynamics are known or when enough non-expert data is available.
  • RCAL's Versatility: RCAL, which combines IL and IRL principles, performs consistently well across different experimental settings.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Parametric IRL Sensitivity: The performance of parametric IRL algorithms (like SCIRL) is sensitive to the choice of features for representing the reward function.
  • Data Requirements: IRL algorithms, especially when dynamics are unknown, can require a significant amount of non-expert data to achieve good performance.
  • Computational Efficiency: While set-policy based algorithms are generally more efficient than trajectory-matching methods, some still involve complex computations.

The authors suggest that the set-policy framework can be used to develop new IL algorithms that explicitly incorporate environmental dynamics. They also note that the framework can be extended to handle more complex scenarios, such as non-stationary environments or partial observability. The potential for using online RL to gather more non-expert data to improve reward estimation is also highlighted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Learning from demonstrations is a paradigm by which an apprentice agent learns a control policy for a dynamic environment by observing demonstrations delivered by an expert agent. It is usually implemented as either imitation learning (IL) or inverse reinforcement learning (IRL) in the literature. On the one hand, IRL is a paradigm relying on the Markov decision processes, where the goal of the apprentice agent is to find a reward function from the expert demonstrations that could explain the expert behavior. On the other hand, IL consists in directly generalizing the expert strategy, observed in the demonstrations, to unvisited states (and it is therefore close to classification, when there is a finite set of possible decisions). While these two visions are often considered as opposite to each other, the purpose of this paper is to exhibit a formal link between these approaches from which new algorithms can be derived. We show that IL and IRL can be redefined in a way that they are equivalent, in the sense that there exists an explicit bijective operator (namely, the inverse optimal Bellman operator) between their respective spaces of solutions. To do so, we introduce the set-policy framework that creates a clear link between the IL and the IRL. As a result, the IL and IRL solutions making the best of both worlds are obtained. In addition, it is a unifying framework from which existing IL and IRL algorithms can be derived and which opens the way for the IL methods able to deal with the environment's dynamics. Finally, the IRL algorithms derived from the set-policy framework are compared with the algorithms belonging to the more common trajectory-matching family. Experiments demonstrate that the set-policy-based algorithms outperform both the standard IRL and IL ones and result in more robust solutions.
BibTeX
@article{piot2017bridging,
  author = {Bilal Piot and Matthieu Geist and Olivier Pietquin},
  title = {{Bridging the Gap Between Imitation Learning and Inverse Reinforcement Learning}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Neural Networks Learn. Syst.},
  year = {2017},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=8xZinFMYuuq},
}
Figure