TL;DR
This paper introduces RSA2C, a novel actor-critic reinforcement learning algorithm that integrates state attribution methods (specifically RKHS-SHAP) directly into the learning process. By using these attributions to guide policy updates, RSA2C achieves improved stability, efficiency, and interpretability, particularly in environments with noisy or perturbed states.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Traditional actor-critic (AC) methods in reinforcement learning (RL) are powerful but often lack transparency. While they learn effective policies, it's difficult to understand why a particular action is chosen. Existing explainable RL (XRL) methods often provide post-hoc explanations or focus on high-level policy structures, failing to offer fine-grained, dimension-level insights into how individual state features influence decisions. This is problematic because state features can have vastly different impacts on the reward, and treating them equally can lead to suboptimal or unstable learning. The paper aims to bridge this gap by developing an AC algorithm that intrinsically uses state attributions to enhance both learning performance and interpretability.
Methods
The core innovation is RSA2C (RKHS-SHAP-based Advanced Actor-Critic), which leverages Reproducing Kernel Hilbert Spaces (RKHS) and SHAP (SHapley Additive exPlanations) for explainability.
- RKHS for Function Approximation: RSA2C uses RKHS to represent the Actor (policy), Value Critic, and Advantage Critic. This allows for non-parametric function approximation with tunable capacity and geometry.
- RKHS-SHAP for Attribution: Instead of traditional, computationally expensive SHAP, the paper employs RKHS-SHAP. This method computes SHAP values analytically using kernel mean embeddings (KME) for on-manifold attributions and conditional mean embeddings (CME) for off-manifold attributions. This significantly reduces computational cost and variance.
- Mahalanobis-Gated Attributions: The computed SHAP values are not just for visualization. They are converted into Mahalanobis-gated weights. These weights are used to modulate the Actor's gradients and the Advantage Critic's targets. Specifically, they are incorporated into an operator-valued kernel for the Actor, effectively creating a Mahalanobis distance that guides the policy.
- Two-Timescale AC: RSA2C employs a two-timescale update mechanism, where the critics (Value and Advantage) update faster than the Actor. This ensures that the attribution signals are relatively stable when used to update the Actor.
- Online Sparsification: To manage the complexity of RKHS representations, an online sparsification scheme (using the Approximate Linear Dependence method) is used to keep the dictionaries of kernel centers compact.
Datasets
The paper evaluates RSA2C on three standard continuous-control environments from Gymnasium:
- Pendulum-v1
- BipedalWalker-v3
- Ant-v5
No new benchmarks were introduced.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Attributions as Learning Signals: The most significant insight is that state attributions (SHAP values) can be directly integrated into the RL training loop, not just for post-hoc explanation. This transforms them into powerful learning signals that can guide policy updates.
- Mahalanobis Distance for Feature Importance: Using SHAP values to create Mahalanobis-gated weights for the kernel effectively imbues the policy with a learned notion of feature importance, allowing it to adapt to the heterogeneous impact of state dimensions.
- Stability Through Explainability: By using attributions to modulate gradients and targets, RSA2C demonstrates improved stability, especially in the presence of state perturbations or noise. This suggests that understanding which features are important helps the agent learn more robustly.
- RKHS-SHAP Efficiency: The adoption of RKHS-SHAP offers a computationally tractable way to obtain reliable, low-variance state attributions, making explainable RL feasible for online learning.
Key Results
- Efficiency: RSA2C achieves comparable or better final returns than baselines while often requiring significantly less computational cost (e.g., lower FLOPs and faster time-to-solution) compared to deep RL methods like SAC and PPO, especially on CPU.
- Stability: RSA2C demonstrates strong robustness to state perturbations and noise. In experiments with varying noise levels, RSA2C variants maintained stable returns and low variance, outperforming baselines like Advanced AC, Uniform SHAP, and RKHS-AC. For instance, on BipedalWalker-v3, mean returns remained stable around 270 across different noise variances, while SAC's variance increased rapidly.
- Interpretability: Visualizations (beeswarm and heatmap plots) of SHAP attributions show that RSA2C captures meaningful feature contributions that align with the underlying physics of the tasks. RSA2C-CME, which models feature dependencies, provides richer and more directionally accurate attributions than RSA2C-KME.
- Performance: RSA2C variants consistently achieved higher final returns than Advanced AC and RKHS-AC in ablation studies. While deep RL methods like SAC sometimes achieved higher asymptotic returns, RSA2C offered a better trade-off between performance, stability, and computational cost.
Limitations and Future Work
- Scalability in High Dimensions: The authors acknowledge that RKHS-based representations, while powerful, face scalability challenges in very high-dimensional state spaces. As dimensionality increases, kernel similarity estimation and dictionary maintenance become more complex, potentially reducing efficiency relative to deep RL methods. This was observed in the Ant-v5 experiments.
- Memory Footprint: For complex tasks and long training horizons, the memory footprint of RKHS dictionaries can increase, limiting extension to extremely complex scenarios.
- Future Work: The authors suggest exploring scalable kernel approximations (like Random Fourier Features) for high-dimensional or pixel-based observations. They also propose combining kernel-based attributions with deep RL to improve both stability and expressiveness.
Summary updated