Breakdown of the scaling relation of anomalous Hall effect in Kondo lattice ferromagnet USbTe

Hasan Siddiquee, Christopher Broyles, Erica Kotta Shouzheng Liu, Shiyu Peng, Tai Kong, Byungkyun Kang, Qiang Zhu, Yongbin Lee, Liqin Ke, Hongming Weng, Jonathan D. Denlinger, L. Andrew Wray, Sheng Ran

Abstract

The interaction between strong correlation and Berry curvature is an open territory in the field of quantum materials. Here we report large anomalous Hall conductivity in a Kondo lattice ferromagnet USbTe which is dominated by intrinsic Berry curvature at low temperatures. However, the Berry curvature induced anomalous Hall effect does not follow the scaling relation derived from Fermi liquid theory. The onset of the Berry curvature contribution coincides with the Kondo coherent temperature. Combined with ARPES measurement and DMFT calculations, this strongly indicates that Berry curvature is hosted by the flat bands induced by Kondo hybridization at the Fermi level. Our results demonstrate that the Kondo coherence of the flat bands has a dramatic influence on the low temperature physical properties associated with the Berry curvature, calling for new theories of scaling relations of anomalous Hall effect to account for the interaction between strong correlation and Berry curvature.

Introduction

The Anomalous Hall Effect (AHE) is a fundamental phenomenon in condensed matter physics, typically categorized into extrinsic scattering mechanisms and intrinsic Berry curvature contributions. In weakly interacting systems, these contributions are distinguished by well-defined scaling relations, such as the quadratic scaling of Hall conductivity with longitudinal conductivity ($\sigma_{xy} \sim \sigma_{xx}^2$) for intrinsic effects. However, the behavior of AHE in strongly correlated systems—where electron-electron interactions are dominant—remains an "open territory."

This study focuses on USbTe, a Kondo lattice ferromagnet. In such materials, localized $f$-electrons hybridize with conduction electrons to form a complex state characterized by "heavy" fermions. The researchers aimed to understand how this strong correlation interacts with the material's topological properties, specifically the Berry curvature.

Methods

The research team employed a "multi-messenger" approach, integrating high-precision experimental data with state-of-the-art theoretical simulations:

  • Transport and Magnetization: Measurements were conducted down to 2 K to track the evolution of resistivity and the Hall effect, allowing the team to observe how the AHE changes with temperature.
  • Angle-Resolved Photoemission Spectroscopy (ARPES): This technique was used to directly visualize the electronic band structure at the Advanced Light Source, providing a map of how energy bands evolve as the material cools.
  • Theoretical Modeling: Because standard density functional theory (DFT) often fails in strongly correlated systems, the team used Dynamical Mean Field Theory (DMFT) and LQSGW. These methods are specifically designed to handle the powerful electron-electron repulsions present in heavy fermion materials.

Key Results

The investigation yielded several groundbreaking insights into the nature of topological transport in correlated systems:

  • Massive Hall Conductivity: At 2 K, the anomalous Hall conductivity in USbTe reaches approximately 560 $\Omega^{-1}cm^{-1}$. This magnitude is comparable to that observed in famous topological Weyl semimetals, indicating a strong intrinsic topological component.
  • Breakdown of Scaling Relations: The most surprising finding is that the standard scaling relation completely fails in the intermediate temperature range. The AHE even undergoes a sign change during cooling, signaling a fierce competition between different physical mechanisms.
  • Kondo Coherence as a Trigger: The intrinsic Berry curvature contribution does not appear immediately upon the onset of magnetism. Instead, it switches on only when the temperature drops below the Kondo coherent temperature (~80 K).
  • Topological Flat Bands: ARPES and DMFT data confirm that the Berry curvature is hosted by "flat bands"—narrow energy regions where electrons become extremely heavy due to Kondo hybridization. This suggests that topology can be engineered or "tuned" by electron correlations.

Discussion and Conclusion

The study of USbTe demonstrates that the Kondo coherence of flat bands has a dramatic influence on low-temperature physical properties associated with Berry curvature. The observed breakdown of standard scaling relations highlights a significant gap in current theoretical frameworks, which are currently unable to describe transport in the "crossover" regime where electrons transition into a coherent Kondo state.

These findings open the door to using strong correlations to engineer topological properties in quantum materials. Future work will likely focus on developing new mathematical models that account for how the scattering (or "damping") of heavy electrons affects topological transport, potentially leading to the development of more robust or efficient electronic components.

Summary updated

Abstract

The interaction between strong correlation and Berry curvature is an open territory of in the field of quantum materials. Here we report large anomalous Hall conductivity in a Kondo lattice ferromagnet USbTe which is dominated by intrinsic Berry curvature at low temperatures. However, the Berry curvature induced anomalous Hall effect does not follow the scaling relation derived from Fermi liquid theory. The onset of the Berry curvature contribution coincides with the Kondo coherent temperature. Combined with ARPES measurement and DMFT calculations, this strongly indicates that Berry curvature is hosted by the flat bands induced by Kondo hybridization at the Fermi level. Our results demonstrate that the Kondo coherence of the flat bands has a dramatic influence on the low temperature physical properties associated with the Berry curvature, calling for new theories of scaling relations of anomalous Hall effect to account for the interaction between strong correlation and Berry curvature.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{siddiquee2023breakdown,
  author = {Hasan Siddiquee and Christopher Broyles and Erica Kotta Shouzheng Liu and Shiyu Peng and Tai Kong and Byungkyun Kang and Qiang Zhu and Yongbin Lee and Liqin Ke and Hongming Weng and Jonathan D. Denlinger and L. Andrew Wray and Sheng Ran},
  title = {{Breakdown of the scaling relation of anomalous Hall effect in Kondo lattice ferromagnet USbTe}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-023-36221-9},
}
Figure