Body map proto-organization in newborn macaques

Michael J. Arcaro, Peter F. Schade, Margaret S. Livingstone

TL;DR

Newborn macaque brains already possess a sophisticated, adult-like topographic organization of their somatosensory and motor systems. This "proto-organization" appears to be hardwired at birth, serving as a scaffold for later development, and is surprisingly resistant to significant changes in sensory experience, even in visually deprived individuals.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The adult primate brain is characterized by "topographic maps" – organized representations of sensory information, like a map of the body on the cortex. A key question in developmental neuroscience is whether these maps are innate or learned through experience. Previous studies suggested that early somatosensory areas in newborn primates might be functionally immature. This paper investigates whether the complex, large-scale topographic organization of the somato-motor system is present at birth in macaques and how it develops and adapts to sensory experience.

Methods

The researchers used functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) to map the somatotopic organization of the somato-motor system in newborn and juvenile macaques. They employed two main analysis techniques:

  • Regression Analysis: This standard fMRI technique identifies brain regions that show increased activity in response to specific tactile stimuli (face, hand, foot).
  • Independent Component Analysis (ICA): This data-driven approach is used to identify underlying patterns of activity across the brain that are statistically independent. ICA was particularly useful for isolating and visualizing the spatial maps of body part representations.

Body map analysis was then performed by combining the ICA maps to create a gradient representation of where different body parts were mapped in the brain. They also tracked the refinement of individual finger representations over time.

Datasets

The study used fMRI data from 9 macaque monkeys, ranging in age from 11 days to 981 days (approximately 32 months). This included:

  • Newborn monkeys (youngest tested at 11 days old).
  • Juvenile monkeys.
  • Two monkeys raised with visual form deprivation for their first year.

No new benchmarks were introduced; the study focused on characterizing existing brain organization.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Innate Blueprint: The most striking finding is that the large-scale topographic organization of the somato-motor system is present at birth, remarkably similar to that of adult monkeys. This suggests a strong genetic or "hardwired" component to brain organization.
  • Scaffolding for Development: This pre-existing organization acts as a "scaffolding," guiding and constraining how sensory experiences shape the brain during development, rather than being entirely built from scratch by experience.
  • Limited Cross-Modal Plasticity: Even in monkeys deprived of visual input for their first year, relying heavily on touch, their somatotopic maps remained largely unchanged compared to controls. This indicates that significant shifts in sensory experience alone are not sufficient to induce large-scale cross-modal remapping of these fundamental body maps.
  • Refinement, Not Creation: While the overall map is present at birth, finer details, like the precise representation of individual fingers, are refined over the first two years of life, coinciding with the development of fine motor skills.

Key Results

  • Adult-like Maps at Birth: fMRI revealed spatially distinct representations of the face, hand, and foot in the somato-motor cortex of newborn macaques, organized in a topographic gradient similar to adults.
  • Multiple Body Maps: Beyond the primary somato-motor cortex, multiple topographic body maps were identified across frontal, parietal, and insular cortices, as well as in subcortical structures like the putamen and thalamus.
  • Overrepresentation: Similar to adults, newborn macaques showed an overrepresentation of the face and hands in primary somatosensory cortex, occupying a larger cortical area compared to the feet.
  • Finger Refinement: While coarse representations of fingers were present at birth, fine-grained differentiation of individual finger maps took approximately two years to develop.
  • Visual Deprivation Impact: Visually deprived monkeys showed no significant differences in their somatotopic organization compared to age-matched controls, and importantly, no somatosensory responses were detected in visual cortex.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Response Immaturity: While the organization is adult-like, the magnitude of evoked fMRI responses in younger monkeys was weaker than in older ones, suggesting that response properties are still maturing in the first few months.
  • In Utero Experience: The study acknowledges that in-utero tactile and motor experience might play a role in establishing this initial organization, though it was not directly tested.
  • Mechanism of Proto-organization: The paper proposes that this proto-organization arises from a combination of molecular cues and activity-dependent sorting, but the precise mechanisms remain to be fully elucidated.
  • Development of Action Domains: The authors speculate that the early somatotopic organization provides the foundation for later development of specialized "action domains" in motor cortex, but the developmental timeline of these domains requires further investigation.
  • Cross-Modal Plasticity Nuances: While large-scale cross-modal remapping was not observed in the visually deprived monkeys, the paper notes that the lack of trauma to the visual system might have limited the potential for such plasticity, suggesting that further research could explore this in different contexts.

Summary updated

Abstract

Topographic sensory maps are a prominent feature of the adult primate brain. Here, we asked whether topographic representations of the body are present at birth. Using functional MRI (fMRI), we find that the newborn somatomotor system, spanning frontoparietal cortex and subcortex, comprises multiple topographic representations of the body. The organization of these large-scale body maps was indistinguishable from those in older monkeys. Finer-scale differentiation of individual fingers increased over the first 2 y, suggesting that topographic representations are refined during early development. Last, we found that somatomotor representations were unchanged in 2 visually impaired monkeys who relied on touch for interacting with their environment, demonstrating that massive shifts in early sensory experience in an otherwise anatomically intact brain are insufficient for driving cross-modal plasticity. We propose that a topographic scaffolding is present at birth that both directs and constrains experience-driven modifications throughout somatosensory and motor systems.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{arcaro2019body,
  author = {Michael J. Arcaro and Peter F. Schade and Margaret S. Livingstone},
  title = {{Body map proto-organization in newborn macaques}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.1912636116},
}

Loading related content...

Figure