Bioprocessing Separations Consortium Three-Year Overview: Technical Advances Process Economics Influence, and State of the Science

Sue Jones, Eric C. D. Tan, Jennifer B. Dunn, Lauren Valentino, Edward Barry, Louis Edaño, Patricia Ignacio-deLeon, Phil Laible, Yupo J. Lin, James Coons, Taraka Dale, William Gasway, Benjamin Yap, Todd Pray, Ling Liang, Ning Sun, Eric Sundström, Jipeng Yan, Gregg T. Beckham, Mary J. Biddy, David Chiaramonte, Ryan Davis, Stefano Dell’Orco, Steve Deutch, Abhijit Dutta, Chai Engtrakul, Stefan J. Haugen, Erik Karp, Lorenz P. Manker, Kimberly A. Magrini, Bill Michener, Hanna R. Monroe, Brady Peterson, Patrick O. Saboe, Mike Sprague, A. Nolan Wilson, Michael Zu, Brian L. Bischoff, Jae‐Soon Choi, Zhenglong Li, Mi Lu, Ting Wu, Tim Theiss, Vanda Glezakou, Suh-Jane Lee, Jian Liu, Marie Swita, Michael R. Thorson, Huamin Wang, Charlie Freeman2020 · DOI

Official report metadata including title, authors, and issuance date.

Abstract

The Bioprocessing Separations Consortium solves separations challenges that are unique to bioprocessing. To do this, the Consortium uses two methods: applying existing technologies to new challenges and developing new technologies that may address these unique challenges better than today’s commercial technologies. In its research and development, the Consortium leverages its three core capabilities: materials development and evaluation, process development, and analysis and computation. In its first three years, from 2016 to 2019, the Consortium addressed four critical challenges in biochemical and thermochemical processing: lignin fractionation, process intensification, dilute carbon recovery, and inhibitor removal. Overall, across these projects, the Consortium has developed separations technologies for 10 bioprocesses, addressed 9 target compounds, developed 10 materials, and evaluated 4 processes for cost and sustainability.

Introduction: The Separations Bottleneck

Industrial separations are a significant energy consumer in the United States, accounting for roughly 15% of total national energy usage. In the context of the bio-based economy, this challenge is particularly acute. Unlike the mature petrochemical industry, which deals with relatively clean hydrocarbon streams, bioprocessing involves dilute products in complex, aqueous environments. These streams are often laden with "poisons"—inhibitors that can deactivate catalysts or kill the microorganisms responsible for fermentation.

The Bioprocessing Separations Consortium, a multi-national laboratory effort, was established to move beyond unoptimized bench-scale procedures and establish a "State of Technology" (SOT) for bioseparations. By tackling the "separations bottleneck," the Consortium aims to significantly lower the Minimum Fuel Selling Price (MFSP) of biofuels and bioproducts, potentially reducing prices by up to 50% through improved carbon recovery and process intensification.

The Bioprocessing Separations Consortium logo represents a collaborative effort to advance bioenergy technologies.

Strategic Research Areas

The Consortium’s research is organized around four critical challenges:

  1. Lignin Fractionation: Transforming lignin, often treated as a low-value waste product burned for process heat, into high-value chemical building blocks.
  2. Process Intensification: Combining multiple processing steps—such as fermentation and product recovery—into single units to reduce capital and energy costs.
  3. Dilute Carbon Recovery: Developing efficient methods to extract valuable organic molecules from the watery streams common in bioprocessing.
  4. Inhibitor Removal: Cleaning feedstocks to extend the operational life of downstream catalysts and microbial cultures.

Methodological Framework and Innovations

The Consortium leverages three core capabilities: materials development, process development, and computational analysis. These are applied to standardized "Design Cases" established by the DOE Bioenergy Technologies Office (BETO) to ensure results are benchmarked against industry standards like distillation and chromatography.

Novel Separation Technologies

  • HED-ISPR (Hybrid Extraction and Distillation - In Situ Product Recovery): This system extracts carboxylic acids and esters directly from the bioreactor during production. This "in situ" approach prevents products from reaching toxic concentrations, thereby increasing microbial productivity.
  • Electrodeionization (EDI): By using ion-exchange resins and electric fields, EDI captures organic acids and bases (such as NaOH) without the need for additional chemical regenerants. This approach significantly lowers lifecycle greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and water consumption.
  • Acoustic and Membrane Filtration: The Consortium explored multi-stage membrane filtration to fractionate lignin by molecular weight. Additionally, ultrasonic separation was used to concentrate lignocellulosic "fines," offering a potentially more energy-efficient alternative to centrifugation.
  • Nanostructured Adsorbents: Researchers designed "designer" materials, including surface-treated nanoparticles and xerogels, to selectively capture specific inhibitors like aldehydes from complex mixtures.

Key Results and Economic Impact

The first three years of the Consortium have yielded impressive technical and economic benchmarks:

  • Recovery Efficiency: HED-ISPR experiments successfully recovered 95% of C4 compounds from fermentation broth at 98.5% purity. Crucially, the energy footprint for this recovery was less than 20% of the product's heating value.
  • Sustainability Gains: The EDI system recovered 99% of NaOH and 95% of carboxylic acids. The development of modified resin wafers increased separation rates by 2.5x while simultaneously cutting energy consumption by 60%.
  • Lignin Flux: The multi-stage filtration approach achieved a flux 5 to 10 times greater than traditional single-step 450 Da filtration methods, enabling the transition of lignin into a source of monomeric acids.
  • Cost Savings: Adsorbent techniques capable of removing 34% of carbonyls from bio-oil were estimated to decrease conversion costs by nearly $1 per Gallon of Gasoline Equivalent (GGE).

Challenges and Future Outlook

Despite these successes, several hurdles remain for commercial implementation. Most current results are at the bench or lab scale (processing approximately 100g to 1kg). Scaling these technologies to field-pilot levels (>10 kg/hour) presents significant engineering challenges.

Future work will focus on evaluating how modified EDI resins and nanostructured adsorbents perform over thousands of hours in real-world industrial streams. Additionally, developing methods to regenerate catalysts within high-temperature, high-pressure environments remains a priority. By continuing to integrate materials science with process engineering and economic analysis, the Bioprocessing Separations Consortium is paving the way for a more efficient and sustainable bio-based economy.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Bioprocessing Separations Consortium solves separations challenges that are unique to bioprocessing. To do this, the Consortium uses two methods: applying existing technologies to new challenges and developing new technologies that may address these unique challenges better than today’s commercial technologies. In its research and development, the Consortium leverages its three core capabilities: materials development and evaluation, process development, and analysis and computation. In its first three years, from 2016 to 2019, the Consortium addressed four critical challenges in biochemical and thermochemical processing. First, the Consortium targeted the fractionation of lignin to enable valorization of this portion of biomass that offers diverse, complex, and valuable building blocks and products. Second, Consortium researchers developed technologies to enable process intensification, which can reduce equipment needs, energy consumption, and waste generation, thereby cutting bioprocessing capital costs and rendering processes more efficient. Third, the Consortium sought to recover carbon from dilute aqueous streams that are common to bioprocessing; recovering dilute carbon can improve process efficiency and economics. Finally, Consortium researchers designed and developed new materials and catalysts to reduce targeted foulants and poisons in bioprocessing streams that can limit the lifetime of downstream catalysts or fermenting microorganisms. Table 1 lists the technologies that were examined and places them in the context of the Consortium’s capabilities, types of bioprocesses, and critical challenges in bioprocessing separations. Overall, across these projects, we have developed separations technologies for 10 bioprocesses, addressed 9 target compounds in bioprocessing, developed 10 materials, and evaluated 4 processes for cost and sustainability.
BibTeX
@misc{jones2020bioprocessing,
  author = {Sue Jones and Eric C. D. Tan and Jennifer B. Dunn and Lauren Valentino and Edward Barry and Louis Edaño and Patricia Ignacio-deLeon and Phil Laible and Yupo J. Lin and James Coons and Taraka Dale and William Gasway and Benjamin Yap and Todd Pray and Ling Liang and Ning Sun and Eric Sundström and Jipeng Yan and Gregg T. Beckham and Mary J. Biddy and David Chiaramonte and Ryan Davis and Stefano Dell’Orco and Steve Deutch and Abhijit Dutta and Chai Engtrakul and Stefan J. Haugen and Erik Karp and Lorenz P. Manker and Kimberly A. Magrini and Bill Michener and Hanna R. Monroe and Brady Peterson and Patrick O. Saboe and Mike Sprague and A. Nolan Wilson and Michael Zu and Brian L. Bischoff and Jae‐Soon Choi and Zhenglong Li and Mi Lu and Ting Wu and Tim Theiss and Vanda Glezakou and Suh-Jane Lee and Jian Liu and Marie Swita and Michael R. Thorson and Huamin Wang and Charlie Freeman and Ryan Davis},
  title = {{Bioprocessing Separations Consortium Three-Year Overview: Technical Advances Process Economics Influence, and State of the Science}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.2172/1635502},
}
Figure