Biomechanical evaluation of ortho-bridge system and proximal femoral nail antirotation in intertrochanteric fractures with lateral wall fracture based on finite element analysis

Yuntao Long, Na Liu, Xiaomeng Huang, Weiming Liang, Jianke Liu, Zhaozhao Huang, Yanhui Zhang, Wen Wang

TL;DR

This study uses finite element analysis to demonstrate that adding an ortho-bridge system (OBS) to standard proximal femoral nail antirotation (PFNA) fixation significantly improves the stability of complex hip fractures. By reinforcing the lateral femoral wall, the combined approach reduces mechanical stress on both the bone and the surgical implants, potentially lowering the risk of post-operative failure in elderly patients.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Intertrochanteric fractures—breaks occurring between the two bony protrusions at the top of the femur—account for nearly 40% of all hip fractures in the elderly. A critical factor in the success of the repair is the "lateral wall" (the outer side of the femur). When this wall is fractured, the injury becomes highly unstable.

While intramedullary nails like the PFNA are the current "gold standard," they often fail to adequately reconstruct a shattered lateral wall. This can lead to complications like the screw "cutting out" of the bone, the nail breaking, or the fracture collapsing. Currently, there is no global clinical consensus on the best way to reinforce this lateral wall. The authors investigate whether the OBS—a versatile internal fixation system—can provide the necessary mechanical support when used alongside a standard nail.

Methods

The researchers employed Finite Element Analysis (FEA), a computational method used to simulate how structures react to real-world forces.

  1. Model Generation: They used CT scan data from a 68-year-old male to create a high-fidelity 3D model of a femur, distinguishing between cortical (hard outer) and cancellous (spongy inner) bone.
  2. Fracture Simulation: They digitally "broke" the model to simulate an intertrochanteric fracture with lateral wall involvement.
  3. Fixation Comparison: They created two scenarios:
  4. Group A: Fixation using only the PFNA nail.
  5. Group B: Fixation using PFNA combined with the Ortho-Bridge System (OBS).
  6. Loading Conditions: To simulate a normal walking state, they applied a joint reaction force of 2,469.6 N (4.2x body weight) to the femoral head and an abductor muscle load of 1,117.2 N (1.9x body weight) to the greater trochanter.

Datasets

The study did not use a large-scale public dataset. Instead, it relied on a single-subject high-resolution CT dataset from a 68-year-old male volunteer (60 kg) with no prior femoral diseases. This served as the geometric foundation for the 3D reconstructions in Mimics and Geomagic Studio.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Safe Stress" Threshold: The authors highlight a biological "sweet spot" for bone healing. According to Frost’s mechanostat theory, bone grows best when stress is around 20 MPa. If stress exceeds 60 MPa, the bone tissue can be damaged.
  • PFNA Alone Overloads the Bone: In the simulation, using PFNA alone resulted in stress levels on the lateral wall of 86.8 MPa. This exceeds the safety threshold, explaining why these fractures often fail to heal or collapse when fixed with a nail alone.
  • The OBS as a Mechanical Shield: Adding the OBS dropped the lateral wall stress to 59 MPa. This brings the stress back into a range that supports safe bone growth without "stress shielding" (where the implant takes too much load, causing the bone to wither).
  • Protecting the Hardware: The OBS doesn't just help the bone; it protects the nail. By sharing the load, it significantly reduced the stress on the nail's spiral blade, which is a common point of mechanical failure in clinical practice.

Key Results

The addition of the OBS showed clear biomechanical advantages across all metrics:

  • Stress Reduction (Bone): The maximum stress on the proximal femur decreased by 28.21% (from 203.05 MPa to 158.37 MPa) when the OBS was added.
  • Stress Reduction (Lateral Wall): Stress on the critical lateral wall bone dropped by 46.92%.
  • Stress Reduction (Implant): The maximum stress on the main intramedullary nail dropped by 32.19%, and stress on the spiral blade plummeted by 71.93%.
  • Stability: The overall displacement (movement) of the fracture assembly decreased by 22.6% (from 4.30 mm to 3.51 mm), indicating a much stiffer and more stable repair.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Static vs. Dynamic: The study used a static "snapshot" of a walking load. It does not account for the repetitive, cyclic loading (fatigue) that occurs over thousands of steps during recovery.
  • Simplified Material Properties: The bone was modeled as homogeneous and isotropic (uniform in all directions). In reality, bone—especially osteoporotic bone—is highly complex and varies significantly between individuals.
  • Single Model: Because the study used only one patient's geometry, the results may not be perfectly generalizable to patients with different bone shapes or densities.
  • Clinical Translation: While the physics-based simulation is promising, the authors emphasize that long-term clinical trials are necessary to prove that these mechanical gains lead to fewer re-operations in real patients.

Summary updated

Abstract

In cases of intertrochanteric fractures with lateral wall involvement, PFNA fixation alone may compromise the biomechanical integrity of the lateral femoral wall, increasing the risk of postoperative complications. The addition of OBS to PFNA significantly reduces stress on the lateral femoral wall. Consequently, OBS should be considered for lateral wall fixation when managing intertrochanteric fractures combined with lateral wall fractures.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{long2024biomechanical,
  author = {Yuntao Long and Na Liu and Xiaomeng Huang and Weiming Liang and Jianke Liu and Zhaozhao Huang and Yanhui Zhang and Wen Wang},
  title = {{Biomechanical evaluation of ortho-bridge system and proximal femoral nail antirotation in intertrochanteric fractures with lateral wall fracture based on finite element analysis}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fbioe.2024.1368492},
}
Figure