Bias-Exchange Metadynamics Simulation of Membrane Permeation of 20 Amino Acids

Zanxia Cao, Yunqiang Bian, Guodong Hu, Liling Zhao, Zhenzhen Kong, Yuedong Yang, Jihua Wang, Yaoqi ZhouInternational Journal of Molecular Sciences 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study presents the first comprehensive simulation of how all 20 standard amino acids cross a lipid bilayer membrane, revealing that hydrophobicity is the primary driver of permeation. Using advanced computational techniques, the researchers mapped the free energy landscapes for each amino acid, providing crucial insights into the fundamental interactions governing membrane transport.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how molecules, particularly amino acids, traverse cell membranes is fundamental to biology and medicine. Cell membranes act as selective barriers, controlling what enters and exits cells. While some molecules can pass through relatively easily, others require specific transporters. Amino acids, the building blocks of proteins, are essential for cellular function, and their interaction with and passage through membranes is a key aspect of protein folding, stability, and the function of membrane proteins. Furthermore, the ability of certain peptides to cross membranes (cell-penetrating peptides) is exploited for drug delivery and has implications for antibiotic development. However, the precise energetic landscape and mechanisms governing the permeation of individual amino acids across lipid bilayers remain poorly understood. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by systematically simulating the membrane permeation of all 20 standard amino acids.

Methods

The researchers employed bias-exchange metadynamics (BEMD) simulations, a powerful computational technique for exploring free energy landscapes. BEMD involves running multiple simulation replicas, each biased to explore different regions of the conformational space. These biases are then exchanged between replicas, allowing for efficient sampling of rare events like membrane permeation.

Key aspects of their methodology include:

  • Comprehensive Sampling: They simulated the permeation of all 20 standard amino acids across a dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC) lipid bilayer. DPPC is a common model for mammalian cell membranes.
  • Collective Variables (CVs): To guide the simulations, they used three collective variables:
  • The z-projection of the amino acid's position relative to the membrane center (for overall translocation).
  • The backbone torsion angles ($\phi$ and $\psi$) of the amino acid (to capture conformational changes).
  • The number of hydrogen bonds between the amino acid and surrounding water molecules (to understand hydration effects).
  • Large System Size: They used a relatively large membrane system (256 lipids) to minimize finite-size effects that can influence permeation energetics.
  • Free Energy Profile Analysis: The simulations generated free energy profiles (FEPs) that map the energy cost of an amino acid moving from the aqueous phase to the center of the lipid bilayer.
  • Convergence Testing: They performed extensive convergence tests using different initial conformations and simulation lengths for challenging amino acids (Arg+ and Trp) to ensure the reliability of their results.

Datasets

The study did not introduce new benchmark datasets. Instead, it relied on:

  • Simulated Lipid Bilayer System: A DPPC lipid bilayer system was prepared and equilibrated using established force fields (Berger for lipids, GROMOS 53A6 for amino acids and SPC water).
  • Experimental Data for Validation: The simulated free energy profiles were compared against existing experimental data on membrane permeation propensities, specifically referencing the work of Hessa et al. [9].

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hydrophobicity Reigns Supreme: The study strongly suggests that hydrophobicity is the dominant factor driving amino acid permeation into lipid bilayers. More hydrophobic amino acids generally face lower energy barriers.
  • Polarity is a Barrier: Polar amino acids encounter larger free energy barriers compared to their nonpolar counterparts, indicating that their interactions with the hydrophobic core of the membrane are energetically unfavorable.
  • Charged Amino Acids Face the Toughest Challenge: Negatively charged amino acids (Asp- and Glu-) exhibit the highest energy barriers, making them the most difficult to penetrate the membrane. Positively charged amino acids (Arg+ and Lys+) also face barriers but are more permeable than negatively charged ones, with strong interactions with the lipid headgroups.
  • Conformational Flexibility is Key: The ability of amino acids to undergo conformational transitions (changes in their backbone torsion angles) during membrane crossing plays a crucial role in reducing their free energy barriers. This highlights the dynamic nature of membrane permeation.
  • Water Defects are Minor: While polar and charged amino acids can bring water molecules into the membrane, the formation of significant "water defects" at the membrane's hydrophobic core is minimal, suggesting that direct interaction with lipids is more important.
  • Pore Formation is Rare and Specific: Pore formation, a more disruptive mechanism, was observed only for charged amino acids (Arg+, Lys+, Asp-, Glu-) at the membrane center, with Lys+ even inducing a lipid flip-flop.

Key Results

  • First Comprehensive FEPs: The paper provides the first set of simulated free energy profiles for the membrane permeation of all 20 standard amino acids.
  • Correlation with Experiments: The simulated free energy costs showed a moderate but significant correlation (R ≈ 0.52-0.56) with experimental measurements of membrane-permeating propensity, validating the computational approach.
  • Hierarchical Permeability: A clear hierarchy of permeation difficulty was established: negatively charged < polar < nonpolar < positively charged amino acids.
  • Specific Energy Values: For example, the free energy cost for Arg+ translocation was found to be 23 kJ/mol, and for Trp, it was around 18 kJ/mol.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Membrane vs. Real Membrane: The study used a simplified DPPC lipid bilayer model. Real cell membranes are more complex, containing cholesterol, proteins, and a more heterogeneous lipid composition, which could influence permeation.
  • Amino Acid Analogs vs. Full Residues: While they included backbone and side chains, the simulations focused on individual amino acids, not their incorporation into larger peptides or proteins, which might alter their behavior.
  • Force Field Accuracy: The accuracy of the force fields used can always be a limitation in molecular simulations.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that understanding the role of hydrophobicity can help in designing non-natural amino acids with enhanced cell permeability for applications like drug delivery. Further studies could explore the permeation of amino acids in more complex membrane environments and their role in protein insertion.

Summary updated

Abstract

Thermodynamics of the permeation of amino acids from water to lipid bilayers is an important first step for understanding the mechanism of cell-permeating peptides and the thermodynamics of membrane protein structure and stability. In this work, we employed bias-exchange metadynamics simulations to simulate the membrane permeation of all 20 amino acids from water to the center of a dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC) membrane (consists of 256 lipids) by using both directional and torsion angles for conformational sampling. The overall accuracy for the free energy profiles obtained is supported by significant correlation coefficients (correlation coefficient at 0.5-0.6) between our results and previous experimental or computational studies. The free energy profiles indicated that (1) polar amino acids have larger free energy barriers than nonpolar amino acids; (2) negatively charged amino acids are the most difficult to enter into the membrane; and (3) conformational transitions for many amino acids during membrane crossing is the key for reduced free energy barriers. These results represent the first set of simulated free energy profiles of membrane crossing for all 20 amino acids.
BibTeX
@article{cao2018bias,
  author = {Zanxia Cao and Yunqiang Bian and Guodong Hu and Liling Zhao and Zhenzhen Kong and Yuedong Yang and Jihua Wang and Yaoqi Zhou},
  title = {{Bias-Exchange Metadynamics Simulation of Membrane Permeation of 20 Amino Acids}},
  journal = {International Journal of Molecular Sciences},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/ijms19030885},
}
Figure