TL;DR
This paper tackles the limitation of existing discourse relation datasets by expanding the analysis of discourse signals beyond news articles to include academic, how-to, and interview genres. By adapting and applying a signal anchoring scheme, the authors provide a richer understanding of how discourse relations are signaled differently across genres, revealing that while discourse markers (DMs) are common, other linguistic features are crucial for genre-specific signaling.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Understanding how sentences and larger text units connect to form coherent discourse is fundamental for natural language processing tasks like summarization and information extraction. Discourse relations (e.g., cause, contrast, elaboration) are often signaled by linguistic cues. However, existing large-scale corpora for studying these signals, like the Penn Discourse Treebank (PDTB) and the Rhetorical Structure Theory Signalling Corpus (RST-SC), are primarily limited to the Wall Street Journal (WSJ) news domain. This limits our understanding of how discourse signaling varies across different genres. The paper aims to bridge this gap by adapting an existing signal identification and anchoring scheme to new genres and analyzing the distribution of these signals across relations and genres.
Methods
The core of this research involves adapting and applying a signal identification and anchoring scheme, previously developed by Liu and Zeldes (2019), to a new dataset. This scheme involves annotating specific tokens or spans of text that act as signals for discourse relations. The authors then analyze the distribution of these signals across different discourse relations and genres. They also propose a taxonomy of discourse signals, building upon existing work, to better capture the variety of cues used. The methodology includes:
- Signal Anchoring: Identifying and marking specific linguistic elements (discourse markers, lexical items, punctuation, etc.) that signal discourse relations within text.
- Genre Adaptation: Extending the annotation process to genres beyond news, specifically academic articles, how-to guides, and interviews.
- Taxonomy Development: Refining and expanding a taxonomy of discourse signals to accommodate genre-specific cues.
- Distributional Analysis: Quantitatively examining how different signal types and subtypes are distributed across various discourse relations and genres.
Datasets
The primary dataset used in this study is the Georgetown University Multilayer (GUM) corpus. This corpus is chosen for its rich annotation layers, including discourse relations (rst). For this study, a subset of four genres from GUM was selected:
- Academic articles
- How-to guides
- Interviews
- News
This selection was based on previous findings suggesting these genres exhibit varying degrees of discourse signaling. The study also references and compares findings with the Rhetorical Structure Theory Signalling Corpus (RST-SC), which is primarily based on Wall Street Journal (WSJ) news articles.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Beyond Discourse Markers: While discourse markers (DMs) like "but" and "however" are common signals, they are far from the only ones. A significant portion of discourse relations are signaled by other linguistic features, including lexical items, punctuation, and even structural patterns.
- Genre-Specific Signaling: Discourse signaling is not uniform across genres. Different genres employ distinct strategies to signal relationships between text units, reflecting their specific communicative purposes and registers. For instance, academic writing might favor words like "hypothesized," while how-to guides rely on imperative verbs and instructional phrases.
- Ambiguity and Context are Key: Many signal tokens are ambiguous and can appear in multiple discourse relations. This highlights the importance of considering the surrounding context and genre to accurately interpret their function.
- The Value of Anchoring: Anchoring signals directly to text spans is crucial for understanding their role and for developing more effective computational models. This approach reveals that semantic and lexical signals are more prevalent than DMs in many cases.
Key Results
- The study successfully adapted the signal anchoring scheme to three new genres, producing a new layer of annotation for the GUM corpus.
- Analysis of 12 documents across four genres revealed that while DMs are present, semantic and lexical signals constitute a much larger proportion of the identified signals (83.85% vs. 16.15% for DMs).
- Specific genres showed distinct signaling patterns:
- How-to guides were the most signaled genre, likely due to their highly organized and explicit instructional nature.
- Academic articles showed a diverse range of signals, including genre-specific terms and formal linguistic features.
- News articles in this GUM subset were less signaled than expected, potentially due to differences in source data and relation granularity compared to RST-SC.
- Interviews, being partly spoken and less structured, presented unique annotation challenges, with some signals remaining unanchored.
- Certain relations were found to be more frequently signaled by DMs (e.g., CONDITION, CONCESSION), while others were predominantly signaled by semantic or lexical cues (e.g., JUSTIFY, EVALUATION).
Limitations and Future Work
- Limited Genre Scope: The study focused on four genres out of eight available in the GUM corpus. Future work could expand to the remaining genres to provide a more comprehensive understanding.
- RST-DT vs. GUM Relation Granularity: Differences in the number and granularity of discourse relations between RST-DT and GUM might influence comparability.
- Annotation Tool Development: While a new tool was developed, further refinement could improve inter-annotator agreement.
- Investigating Other Annotation Layers: The study primarily focused on the RST layer. Future research could explore how signals are represented through other GUM annotation layers (e.g., coreference, bridging) to gain deeper linguistic insights.
- Computational Modeling: The findings provide valuable data for developing more sophisticated computational models that can leverage contextual information to disambiguate discourse signals and improve discourse parsing.
- Qualitative Analysis of Signal Validity: The paper suggests further qualitative analysis to quantitatively measure the validity of discourse signals, considering their ambiguity and context.
Summary updated