Beyond Fish and Bicycles: Exploring the Varieties of Online Women's Ideological Spaces

Utkucan Balci, Chen Ling, Emiliano De Cristofaro, Megan Squire, Gianluca Stringhini, Jeremy Blackburn

Introduction

While the "Manosphere"—a collection of male-oriented, often reactionary online spaces—has been the subject of extensive academic and journalistic scrutiny, women-oriented ideological spaces are frequently treated as a monolith under the broad umbrella of "feminism." This oversimplification overlooks a complex and increasingly fractured landscape. This research presents the first large-scale, data-driven taxonomy of online women’s ideological spaces, analyzing over 6 million posts across 14 subreddits and two migration platforms. The study reveals that these spaces range from mainstream liberal feminism to radical "Gender-Critical" (GCF) groups and "Manosphere Analogs"—communities that mirror the tactics and ideologies of male incels or "Red Pill" groups.

Methodology

To map this landscape, the researchers employed a multi-dimensional, computational approach across three primary datasets: Reddit (6.8 million posts), Ovarit.com (a GCF migration site), and Thepinkpill.co (a Femcel migration site). The methodology included:

  • Community Discovery and Clustering: Using pre-trained subreddit embeddings (word2vecf) and Agglomerative Clustering with UMAP, the team identified 14 related communities based on user-base overlap and quantitatively defined their boundaries.
  • Topic Modeling: Top2Vec was utilized to find semantic clusters in text, allowing researchers to understand the specific discourse within each community without pre-defining categories.
  • Toxicity and Targeting: Google’s Perspective API measured "Severe Toxicity" and "Identity Attack" scores, while Named Entity Recognition (NER) via SpaCy identified the specific groups targeted by these communities, particularly after they were banned from mainstream platforms.

A New Taxonomy of Women's Spaces

The study successfully categorized the 14 subreddits into three distinct ideological clusters:

  1. Mainstream Feminism: Communities like r/Feminism and r/AskFeminists, which focus on traditional feminist discourse and career barriers.
  2. Gender-Critical Feminism (GCF): Groups like r/GenderCritical that focus heavily on gender identity and trans-exclusionary rhetoric.
  3. Manosphere Analogs: A diverse group including "Femcels" (female involuntary celibates), Female Dating Strategy (FDS), Red Pill Women, and Women Going Their Own Way (WGTOW).

The Fringe Connection and "Pilled" Rhetoric

One of the most striking findings is that Gender-Critical Feminism shares more user-base similarities with Manosphere Analogs than with mainstream feminism. This suggests that GCF functions as a "fringe" community with ideological ties to reactionary spaces rather than being a subset of mainstream feminist thought.

Furthermore, communities like FDS and Femcels mirror the "pilled" rhetoric of the male Manosphere. They utilize similar linguistic structures, such as acronyms like HVM ("High Value Male"), and objectify the opposite sex. Even seemingly mundane topics are weaponized; while mainstream feminists might discuss clothing in the context of professional barriers, GCF groups use the topic to debate gender identity and express transphobic views.

The Deplatforming Paradox

The research also examined the effects of the June 2020 and January 2021 Reddit bans. When GCF and Femcel groups were deplatformed, the results were mixed. For GCF communities migrating to Ovarit, general toxicity decreased. Conversely, for Femcels migrating to ThePinkPill, toxicity increased.

Crucially, however, identity attacks increased in both communities after migration. This suggests a "Deplatforming Paradox": while removing a group from a mainstream platform may reduce its general reach or surface-level toxicity, it often causes the community to become more insular, radicalized, and aggressive toward specific "out-groups."

Toxicity and Targeting Behavior

GCF, Femcels, and WGTOW emerged as the most toxic communities in the study. GCF had the highest proportion of posts with high "Identity Attack" scores on Reddit (4.63%). NER analysis showed a clear distinction in targets: GCF predominantly targets transgender identities, while Femcels focus their aggression on specific ethnicities, religious groups, and men (often referred to by the derogatory term "Moids").

Conclusion and Future Directions

This research highlights the necessity of viewing women's online spaces through a nuanced, multi-categorical lens. The proximity of GCF to Manosphere Analogs and the intensification of identity attacks post-deplatforming suggest that these spaces are key sites for understanding modern radicalization.

Future work should expand beyond Reddit-centric data to include platforms like TikTok and Discord. Additionally, longitudinal research is needed to determine if these fringe spaces act as a "gateway," drawing users away from mainstream feminism and toward more radical, reactionary ideologies.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{balci2023beyond,
  author = {Utkucan Balci and Chen Ling and Emiliano De Cristofaro and Megan Squire and Gianluca Stringhini and Jeremy Blackburn},
  title = {{Beyond Fish and Bicycles: Exploring the Varieties of Online Women's Ideological Spaces}},
  booktitle = {WebSci},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1145/3578503.3583618},
}
Figure