Benefit assessment of extended dosing in cancer patients after their withdrawal from clinical trials

Feng Yang, Zhe Huang, Jianfu Heng, Kunyan LiFrontiers in Pharmacology 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study evaluates the clinical and economic impact of "extended dosing"—allowing cancer patients to continue receiving investigational drugs after they have withdrawn from a clinical trial. While the survival benefit was numerically higher but not statistically significant (17.3 vs. 12.9 months), extended dosing provided a crucial treatment alternative and significant financial relief by providing experimental therapies free of charge.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Clinical trials are governed by rigid protocols. If a patient shows slight disease progression or manageable adverse events, they are often "withdrawn" according to strict criteria, even if the physician believes the patient is still deriving a net benefit from the drug. Once a patient exits a trial, they typically lose access to the investigational therapy, forcing them back onto conventional treatments that may be less effective or more expensive.

While "compassionate use" or "expanded access" programs exist, there is a lack of systematic data on how these programs—referred to here as extended dosing—actually perform in a real-world hospital setting. The authors sought to quantify the survival outcomes, the "gap period" (the time a patient is without treatment during the approval process), and the economic benefits for patients at a major Chinese cancer center.

Methods

The researchers conducted a 1:1 matched cohort study at Hunan Cancer Hospital, analyzing data from 2016 to 2020.

  • Trial Group: 23 patients who requested and received extended dosing after withdrawing from various clinical trials (mostly Phase I and II).
  • Control Group: 23 patients matched by cancer type, original trial assignment, reason for withdrawal, and baseline health status (ECOG score, age, etc.) who moved to conventional therapy.
  • Matching: To ensure a fair comparison, the authors used a 1:1 matching method to minimize confounding variables between the two groups.
  • Follow-up: Patients were monitored every three months for health status, survival, and medical costs.

Datasets

The study utilized a localized dataset from Hunan Cancer Hospital.

  • Initial Pool: 1,918 patients withdrawn from clinical trials during the study period.
  • Final Analysis: 23 matched pairs (46 patients total).
  • Characteristics: The majority of patients (69.6%) had lung cancer and were receiving posterior-line therapies (78.3%).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Gap Period" Vulnerability: One of the most critical findings is the identification of a 16.48-day average gap between trial withdrawal and the start of extended dosing. This period includes the time for investigators to assess risks and for the Ethics Committee to grant approval. Minimizing this gap is vital for maintaining disease control.
  • Defining Eligibility: The authors propose four categories of patients who should be prioritized for extended dosing, including those with "progression" in non-target lesions but good control in target lesions, and those who were effectively treated despite minor eligibility violations.
  • Economic Buffer: In many regions, the cost of late-stage cancer drugs is a massive burden. Because investigational drugs in these programs are provided free of charge by sponsors, extended dosing acts as a significant financial safety net.
  • Ethical Imperative: The paper argues that investigators and sponsors have a moral responsibility to provide continuous access to drugs for patients who are clearly benefiting, bridging the gap between clinical research and compassionate care.

Key Results

  • Overall Survival (OS): The median OS was 17.3 months for the extended dosing group compared to 12.9 months for the control group. Although this 4.4-month difference is clinically notable, it did not reach statistical significance ($p > 0.250$), likely due to the small sample size.
  • Cost Savings: The median cost for therapeutic drugs in the conventional treatment (control) group was 15,720 RMB. Patients in the extended dosing group saved this entire amount, as the investigational drugs were free.
  • Approval Rate: The Ethics Committee approved 31 out of 33 applications for extended dosing, suggesting a high level of institutional support for the practice when backed by investigator risk-benefit assessments.

Limitations and Future Work

The primary limitation is the small sample size ($n=23$ pairs), which limited the statistical power to prove a significant survival advantage. Additionally, the study included a heterogeneous mix of cancer types and drug classes (targeted therapy, immunotherapy, etc.), which may respond differently to extended dosing.

The authors suggest that future work should focus on:

  1. Standardizing Guidelines: Creating clearer national or international regulations for the administration and cost-sharing of extended dosing.
  2. Larger Multi-center Studies: To confirm survival benefits across broader populations.
  3. Streamlining Approvals: Finding ways to reduce the "gap period" to ensure patients don't face treatment interruptions.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Background:</b> Clinical trials have been widely recognized as an effective treatment approach by physicians and cancer patients alike. Physicians' evaluations suggest that many patients are likely to continue experiencing benefits from extended dosing of investigational new drugs even after withdrawing from clinical trials. <b>Objective:</b> Given the uncertainty surrounding the efficacy and safety of investigational new drugs, it is essential to continually assess the benefits of extended dosing for patients. <b>Methods:</b> The trial group for this study comprised patients who requested extended dosing after withdrawing from clinical trials at Hunan Cancer Hospital between 2016 and 2020. The control group consisted of patients who received conventional treatment and were enrolled in a 1:1 ratio. Follow-up assessments were conducted every 3 months for both groups, and included monitoring of patients' health status, survival time, disease control or remission, treatment modalities received, and medical costs. <b>Results:</b> A total of twenty-three patient pairs were successfully matched for this study. The Ethics Committee approved extended dosing for all patients in the trial group, with an average gap period of 16.48 days between their withdrawal from clinical trials and continuous access to the investigational drugs. The median overall survival for patients after withdrawal from clinical trials was 17.3 months in the extended dosing group and 12.9 months in the control group, with no significant difference observed between the two groups (<i>p</i> > 0.250). The median total cost of treatment after the previous clinical trial was 38,006.76 RMB, of which the median cost of therapeutic drugs for conventional treatment was 15,720 RMB, while extended dosing was provided free of charge. <b>Conclusion:</b> Extended dosing can indeed provide benefits, including survival benefits and economic benefits, to cancer patients after their withdrawal from clinical trials and will clinically present an additional treatment option for patients.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2023benefit,
  author = {Feng Yang and Zhe Huang and Jianfu Heng and Kunyan Li},
  title = {{Benefit assessment of extended dosing in cancer patients after their withdrawal from clinical trials}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Pharmacology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fphar.2023.1178002},
}
Figure