Behavioral traits that define social dominance are the same that reduce social influence in a consensus task

Mariana Rodriguez-Santiago, Paul Nührenberg, James Derry, Oliver Deußen, Linda Karen Garrison, Sylvia Fernanda Garza, Fritz A. Francisco, Hans A. Hofmann, Alex Jordan

Abstract

In many vertebrate societies, social dominance is achieved through aggression and intimidation. While these traits are effective for securing resources, their impact on group leadership is complex. This study examines the influence of dominant and subordinate male cichlid fish (Astatotilapia burtoni) across different social contexts. We demonstrate that while dominant males lead routine movements and occupy central network positions, they are remarkably ineffective in complex consensus tasks. Conversely, subordinate males—typically passive and socially peripheral—emerge as superior agents of social change. This discrepancy is driven by the "signal-to-noise" ratio of behavior: the aggressive actions of dominant males mask informative cues, whereas the clean, directed movements of subordinates are easily interpreted by the group. These results suggest that the very traits that allow individuals to reach positions of power may simultaneously make them ineffective leaders in complex scenarios.

Introduction

We often conflate social dominance with social influence. In many species, including humans, individuals reach the top of the hierarchy through aggression, intimidation, and coercion. While these traits are effective for securing mating opportunities or territory, they are also socially aversive. This research addresses a fundamental question in behavioral ecology: Do the same traits that make an individual dominant also make them a better leader?

Specifically, the study investigates the "signal-to-noise" problem of social information. If a leader is constantly chasing or attacking others, can the group distinguish between an aggressive charge and a purposeful movement toward a resource? By dissociating dominance from influence, the authors challenge the assumption that the most powerful individuals are the most effective at guiding a group toward a consensus.

Methods and Materials

Experimental Model

The researchers utilized the cichlid fish Astatotilapia burtoni, a species where males exist in two distinct, reversible phenotypes: highly aggressive, brightly colored "dominants" and passive, cryptically colored "subordinates."

The Association and Consensus Tasks

  1. Association Task: Individual "informant" fish were trained to associate a specific colored light (orange vs. cyan) with a food reward.
  2. Consensus Test: Once an informant (either dominant or subordinate) mastered the task, they were introduced to a group of eight naive fish. The researchers measured how quickly the group reached a consensus—defined as seven or more fish moving toward the correct stimulus within one second.

Behavioral Tracking and Analysis

To capture granular data, the team employed a sophisticated tracking pipeline:

  • Deep Learning: Mask R-CNN (a convolutional neural network) was used to segment and track 168 individual fish across high-resolution video recordings.
  • Visual Connectivity: The researchers reconstructed 2D trajectories and estimated spine poses to calculate what each fish could actually see from its perspective.
  • Social Network Analysis: Directed interaction networks were built based on "initiator-responder" events to determine network centrality and influence.

Key Results

The Failure of Dominant Leadership

Despite their status, groups with dominant informants were no faster at reaching a consensus than groups with no informant at all (completely naive groups). While dominant males had significantly higher betweenness centrality in routine social networks ($p < .01$), this centrality was driven by aggression rather than helpful guidance.

Subordinate Success

In contrast, groups with subordinate informants reached consensus significantly faster than those with dominant informants ($p = .015$). Subordinates, despite being socially peripheral in routine contexts, became the most effective agents of social change in the complex association task.

Signal-to-Noise and Spatial Dynamics

The study identified two primary reasons for this disparity:

  1. Signal-to-Noise Ratio: Subordinate males had a significantly higher ratio of informative "signal" (moving toward the goal) versus uninformative "noise" (aggressive chasing) compared to dominants ($p < .001$).
  2. Spatial Separation: Dominant males were found to be physically isolated. Because their behavior is aversive, other fish maintained a greater distance from them. Subordinates remained physically closer to the group, providing more opportunities for observational learning and "physical leadership."

Discussion and Implications

These findings demonstrate that influence is not a fixed trait but is highly context-dependent. A dominant male might be influential in a routine scenario, such as a simple flight response, but completely ineffective in a complex scenario requiring group coordination.

Limitations

The authors note that these dynamics may vary across species. For instance, in some primates, subordinates may "play dumb" or underperform in the presence of dominants to avoid conflict. Additionally, while this study focused on visual cues, cichlids also communicate via chemical and mechanosensory signals which may further influence these social dynamics.

Conclusion

This research offers a provocative parallel to "toxic leadership" in human organizations. It suggests that the behavioral processes that generate social dominance may simultaneously place the most ineffective leaders in positions of power. When leadership requires the clear transmission of information rather than simple coercion, the traits of the "alpha" may become a liability rather than an asset.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract In many species, cultures, and contexts, social dominance reflects the ability to exert influence over others, and the question of what makes an effective leader is pertinent to a range of disciplines and contexts. While dominant individuals are often assumed to be most influential, the behavioral traits that make them dominant may also make them socially aversive and thereby reduce their influence. Here we examine the influence of dominant and subordinate males on group behavior in different social contexts using the cichlid fish Astatotilapia burtoni . We find that phenotypically dominant males display behavioral traits that typify leadership across taxonomic systems – aggressive, social centrality, and movement leadership, while subordinate males are passive, socially peripheral, and have little influence over movement. However, in a more complex group-consensus task involving visual cue associations, subordinate males become the most effective agents of social change. We find that dominant males are spatially distant and have lower signal-to-noise ratios of informative behavior in the association task, potentially interfering with their ability to generate group-consensus. In contrast, subordinate males are physically close to other group members, have high signal-to-noise behaviors in the association task, and visual connectivity to other group members equal to that of dominant males. The attributes that define effective social influence are therefore highly context-specific, with socially and phenotypically dominant males being influential in routine but not complex social scenarios. These results demonstrate that behavioral traits that are typical of socially dominant individuals may actually reduce their social influence in other contexts. Significance Statement The attributes that allow individuals to attain positions of social power and dominance are common across many vertebrate social systems – aggression, intimidation, coercion. Yet these traits are socially aversive, and can make dominant individuals poor agents of social change. In a vertebrate system (social cichlid fish) we show that dominant males are aggressive, socially central, and lead group movement. Yet dominant males are poor effectors of consensus in an more sophisticated association task compared with passive, socially-peripheral subordinate males. The most effective agents of social influence possess behavioral traits opposite of those typically found in position of social dominance, suggesting the behavioral processes that generate social dominance may simultaneously place the most ineffective leaders in positions of power.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rodriguezsantiago2020behavioral,
  author = {Mariana Rodriguez-Santiago and Paul Nührenberg and James Derry and Oliver Deußen and Linda Karen Garrison and Sylvia Fernanda Garza and Fritz A. Francisco and Hans A. Hofmann and Alex Jordan},
  title = {{Behavioral traits that define social dominance are the same that reduce social influence in a consensus task}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.2000158117},
}
Figure