Beaked Whales Respond to Simulated and Actual Navy Sonar

Peter L. Tyack, Walter Zimmer, David Moretti, Brandon L. Southall, Diane Claridge, John W. Durban, Christopher W. Clark, Angela D’Amico, Nancy DiMarzio, Susan Jarvis, Elena McCarthy, Ronald Morrissey, Jessica Ward, Ian L. BoydPLoS 2011 · DOI

Abstract

Beaked whales have long been associated with mass strandings during naval sonar exercises, yet the underlying behavioral mechanisms have remained poorly understood. This study investigates the responses of Blainville's beaked whales (Mesoplodon densirostris) to both actual mid-frequency active (MFA) sonar and controlled experimental playbacks. Using a combination of passive acoustic monitoring, satellite telemetry, and high-resolution acoustic tags (DTAGs), we demonstrate that these whales exhibit strong avoidance behavior, stopping foraging and fleeing the area at sound pressure levels significantly lower than current regulatory thresholds. The results suggest that beaked whales may perceive sonar as a predatory threat, triggering an evolved "stop and flee" instinct that disrupts their energy budget and potentially leads them into lethal situations.

Introduction: The Stranding Mystery

For decades, marine biologists have noted a grim correlation: beaked whale mass strandings often coincide with naval mid-frequency active (MFA) sonar exercises. However, the causal link remained elusive. Because beaked whales are deep-diving specialists that forage at extreme depths (>1,000m) and spend minimal time at the surface, observing their reactions in the wild is exceptionally difficult. The central challenge was determining whether the whales were suffering direct physical injury from the sound or if a behavioral "flight" response was driving them into dangerous, shallow-water environments. To solve this, researchers measured exactly what a whale hears and how it moves in response to both real-world naval exercises and controlled, simulated sonar.

Methodology

The research was conducted at the Navy’s Atlantic Undersea Test and Evaluation Center (AUTEC) in the Bahamas, utilizing a multi-modal approach to track population-level and individual behavior:

  1. Passive Acoustic Monitoring (PAM): An array of 82 bottom-mounted hydrophones tracked "Group Clicking Periods" (GCPs)—the echolocation sounds produced during foraging dives—to monitor population-level presence across the entire range before, during, and after sonar exercises.
  2. Satellite Telemetry: A 23-day track of a male Blainville’s beaked whale provided insights into long-range horizontal displacement.
  3. Digital Acoustic Recording Tags (DTAGs): Suction-cup sensors recorded received sound levels, depth, and 3D orientation during controlled exposure experiments (CEEs).

The CEEs utilized a "dose escalation" protocol, exposing tagged whales to simulated sonar, killer whale calls (a natural predator), and band-limited noise to identify specific behavioral thresholds.

Key Findings

The Avoidance Response

During actual multi-day naval exercises, beaked whales did not merely go silent; they physically abandoned the range. Detections shifted to the periphery, with whales found an average of 16 km away from the sonar source. Satellite tracking confirmed this, showing an individual moving tens of kilometers outside its normal habitat and not returning for nearly three days.

Disruption of Foraging and Recovery

In both experimental and opportunistic conditions, whales stopped echolocating during deep foraging dives when exposed to sonar. This cessation of foraging suggests a significant energetic cost. Notably, it took 48 to 72 hours for whales to return to the center of the range after an exercise concluded, indicating a prolonged "area abandonment" effect that disrupts their foraging cycle.

Low Sensitivity Thresholds

Perhaps the most critical finding was the low sound pressure level (SPL) required to trigger a response. Whales reacted to simulated sonar at received levels as low as 138 dB re 1 µPa. This is significantly lower than the 160 dB threshold often used by regulators to define behavioral disturbance (Level B harassment), suggesting that current safety standards may be inadequate.

Predator Mimicry

The whales' reaction to sonar—stopping foraging followed by an unusually long, slow, slanting ascent—closely mirrored their response to killer whale calls (which triggered reactions at even lower levels, ~98 dB). This suggests that beaked whales may perceive sonar as a predatory threat, triggering an evolved instinct to cease activity and move away from the sound source.

Conclusion and Policy Implications

This study provides the first direct evidence of how beaked whales respond to sonar in the wild. The findings indicate that current regulatory frameworks may significantly underestimate the sensitivity of these species. The observed avoidance behavior and altered dive profiles provide a plausible behavioral link to mass strandings, highlighting the need for more conservative sound exposure limits in sensitive marine habitats.

Limitations and Future Work

While the results are statistically significant, the sample size for controlled DTAG exposures was limited. Furthermore, while this study focused on Blainville’s beaked whales, other species like Cuvier’s beaked whales—which are more frequently involved in strandings—may exhibit different sensitivity levels. Future work is needed to definitively link these behavioral changes to the physiological mechanisms of mortality during strandings, such as potential decompression-like sickness resulting from altered ascent profiles.

Summary updated

Abstract

Beaked whales have mass stranded during some naval sonar exercises, but the cause is unknown. They are difficult to sight but can reliably be detected by listening for echolocation clicks produced during deep foraging dives. Listening for these clicks, we documented Blainville's beaked whales, Mesoplodon densirostris, in a naval underwater range where sonars are in regular use near Andros Island, Bahamas. An array of bottom-mounted hydrophones can detect beaked whales when they click anywhere within the range. We used two complementary methods to investigate behavioral responses of beaked whales to sonar: an opportunistic approach that monitored whale responses to multi-day naval exercises involving tactical mid-frequency sonars, and an experimental approach using playbacks of simulated sonar and control sounds to whales tagged with a device that records sound, movement, and orientation. Here we show that in both exposure conditions beaked whales stopped echolocating during deep foraging dives and moved away. During actual sonar exercises, beaked whales were primarily detected near the periphery of the range, on average 16 km away from the sonar transmissions. Once the exercise stopped, beaked whales gradually filled in the center of the range over 2-3 days. A satellite tagged whale moved outside the range during an exercise, returning over 2-3 days post-exercise. The experimental approach used tags to measure acoustic exposure and behavioral reactions of beaked whales to one controlled exposure each of simulated military sonar, killer whale calls, and band-limited noise. The beaked whales reacted to these three sound playbacks at sound pressure levels below 142 dB re 1 µPa by stopping echolocation followed by unusually long and slow ascents from their foraging dives. The combined results indicate similar disruption of foraging behavior and avoidance by beaked whales in the two different contexts, at exposures well below those used by regulators to define disturbance.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tyack2011beaked,
  author = {Peter L. Tyack and Walter Zimmer and David Moretti and Brandon L. Southall and Diane Claridge and John W. Durban and Christopher W. Clark and Angela D’Amico and Nancy DiMarzio and Susan Jarvis and Elena McCarthy and Ronald Morrissey and Jessica Ward and Ian L. Boyd},
  title = {{Beaked Whales Respond to Simulated and Actual Navy Sonar}},
  booktitle = {PLoS},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pone.0017009},
}

Loading related content...

Figure