Az államok kora: Muraközy László: Államok kora (Az európai modell) (könyvismertetés)

Gábor KarsaiVezetéstudomány 2012 · DOI

Introduction

In his book Az államok kora (The Age of States), László Muraközy challenges the prevailing technocratic view that economic history is merely a sequence of applied theories. Published in the journal Vezetéstudomány in 2012, this review by Gábor Karsai highlights Muraközy’s argument that the state's role in the economy is a complex byproduct of informal traditions, political psychology, and the prevailing "spirit of the age."

The Institutional Framework

Muraközy employs an institutional economics lens to analyze the European model from the post-WWII era to the 2008 financial crisis. He moves beyond "sterile" mathematical models to explore the gap between theoretical prescriptions and the messy reality of governance. His methodology involves a three-level analysis:

  • Factual Trends: Examining spending and debt levels.
  • Policy Consequences: How practice aligns with or deviates from declared goals.
  • Feedback Loops: The interaction between economic theory and political practice.

A central tenet of the work is that the effectiveness of a state is inextricably linked to its informal institutions—the culture, traditions, and values of its society.

The Evolution of the European State

The book categorizes the post-war era into three distinct phases:

  1. The "Blooming" Quarter-Century (1945–1973): A period of rapid growth and state expansion.
  2. The Crisis Decades (1973–early 1990s): Triggered by the oil shocks, leading to a reassessment of the Keynesian consensus.
  3. The Great Moderation (1992–2007): A period of relative stability and the rise of neoliberal frameworks.

Muraközy argues that major shifts, such as the New Deal, often preceded the formal theories that later justified them. In this view, "theory follows practice," driven by political necessity and the "spirit of the age."

Diversity of the European Model

Despite the pressures of globalization, Muraközy identifies four distinct European archetypes:

  • Nordic: High spending but high efficiency and institutional integrity.
  • Liberal: Smaller state footprint with a focus on market mechanisms.
  • Continental: A middle ground with strong social protections.
  • Southern: Often plagued by "fiscal alcoholism" and lower institutional quality.

The book posits that there is no universal "optimal" state size. A large state can thrive if supported by a high-quality bureaucracy and public trust (Nordic), whereas a small state can fail if it lacks institutional stability.

The Trap of Fiscal Alcoholism

A significant portion of the analysis is dedicated to the dangers of populist cycles. Muraközy describes "fiscal alcoholism" as a bad equilibrium where politicians offer short-term handouts to secure votes, reinforcing unsustainable public expectations and leading to long-term economic decline. This is exacerbated by the fact that bureaucrats and politicians are not neutral actors but are motivated by self-preservation and the expansion of their own influence.

The Hungarian Context

The reviewer notes Muraközy’s skepticism toward Hungary’s "non-conventional" economic policies following the 2010 shift. The book suggests that ignoring established economic correlations—such as the link between institutional stability and growth—contributed to the significant GDP contraction observed in early 2012.

Conclusion

Az államok kora serves as a warning against ignoring the institutional and historical constraints of economic policy. As European states face the dual challenges of aging populations and a shrinking share of the global economy, Muraközy’s work emphasizes that the path forward must be rooted in institutional integrity rather than just technocratic fixes.

Reviewer: Gábor Karsai
Source: Vezetéstudomány, Vol. XLIII, Issue 7-8, 2012.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{karsai2012az,
  author = {Gábor Karsai},
  title = {{Az államok kora: Muraközy László: Államok kora (Az európai modell) (könyvismertetés)}},
  booktitle = {Vezetéstudomány},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.14267/veztud.2012.07.11},
}
Figure