Abstract
We study axion effective field theories (EFTs), with a focus on axion couplings to massive chiral gauge fields. We investigate the EFT operators that couple an axion with two gauge bosons, and we show that, when massive chiral gauge fields are present, such interactions do not entirely originate from the usual anomalous EFT terms. The lack of relation between couplings and anomalies is caused by the presence of chiral fermions in the UV. For the case of an axion interacting with the Standard Model (SM) W and Z bosons, we show how anomaly-based sum rules in the IR one can detect whether the axion couplings are given or not by anomalies. Furthermore, the violation of those sum rules becomes a signal of heavy chiral matter. As an illustration, we study a UV-complete chiral extension of the SM, containing an axion arising from an extended Higgs sector and heavy fermionic matter that obtains most of its mass by coupling to the Higgs doublets. We assess the viability of such a SM extension through electroweak precision tests, bounds on Higgs rates and direct searches for heavy charged matter. We show that at energies below the mass of the new chiral fermions, the model matches onto an EFT where the electroweak gauge symmetry is non-linearly realised.
Introduction: The Role of Axions in BSM Physics
Axion-like particles (ALPs) are a cornerstone of modern beyond-the-Standard-Model (BSM) physics. Traditionally, the interaction between an axion and gauge fields is described using Effective Field Theory (EFT), where the coupling strength is assumed to be directly proportional to the "mixed anomaly"—a specific quantum effect related to the symmetry of the theory.
However, this "anomaly-only" description is strictly true only for massless gauge bosons, like photons or gluons. For massive gauge bosons, the physics is more complex. Because massive bosons have a longitudinal degree of freedom provided by the Higgs mechanism, additional gauge-invariant operators can exist in the EFT. This research investigates when these extra terms appear and how they might be detected experimentally.
Methodology: EFT Analysis and UV-Complete Modeling
The researchers employed a two-pronged approach to explore these interactions:
- EFT Analysis: They constructed a general axion EFT for massive gauge fields, identifying operators that are gauge-invariant but not related to the usual anomalies. They derived specific sum rules—mathematical relationships between different axion decay channels (e.g., $a \to \gamma\gamma$, $a \to ZZ$, and $a \to Z\gamma$)—that must hold if the couplings are purely anomalous.
- UV Modeling: To test their theory, they built a "minimal" UV-complete model. This model extends the Standard Model (SM) by adding an axion (from an extended Higgs sector) and new heavy chiral fermions. Unlike "vector-like" fermions, these chiral fermions obtain their mass through the Higgs mechanism, meaning they cannot have a "bare" mass term in the Lagrangian.
The model was evaluated against experimental data from Electroweak Precision Observables (EWPO), LHC Higgs rates, and direct searches for heavy charged particles to ensure consistency with current observations.
Key Insights: Chirality and the Non-Linear Realization
A central finding of the study is that the mismatch between axion couplings and anomalies occurs specifically when the heavy particles being "integrated out" of the theory are chiral. If the heavy matter had a bare mass (vector-like), the extra non-anomalous terms would decouple and disappear.
These extra couplings are rooted in the longitudinal components of the $W$ and $Z$ bosons, suggesting the axion "feels" the electroweak symmetry breaking sector more deeply than previously thought. Integrating out these chiral fermions naturally leads to an EFT where the electroweak symmetry is "non-linearly realised" (Higgs Effective Field Theory or HEFT), providing a bridge between axion physics and Higgs physics.
Key Results: Detecting Heavy Chiral Matter via Sum Rule Violations
The authors found that in their UV-complete model, the standard sum rules are explicitly violated. This violation is a direct consequence of the heavy chiral matter and serves as a "smoking gun" for new physics in the ultraviolet (UV) sector.
As seen in the figure above, the ratio of decay rates $\Gamma(a \to ZZ)/\Gamma(a \to \gamma\gamma)$ plotted against $\Gamma(a \to Z\gamma)/\Gamma(a \to \gamma\gamma)$ deviates significantly from the purple "SR-1" line representing standard anomalous predictions. This deviation is the "anomalous lens" through which the heavy UV sector can be observed. Quantitatively, the model remains viable with current experimental data if the new chiral fermions have masses $M \gtrsim 720$ GeV.
Discussion and Future Outlook
While the theoretical framework is robust, several hurdles remain for experimental verification. Standard Model loops involving $W$ bosons and top quarks can "fake" a violation of the sum rules, requiring precise calculation and subtraction to isolate a BSM signal. Furthermore, measuring axion decays into multiple massive gauge boson channels is extremely challenging, likely requiring a future high-luminosity collider or a dedicated "Axion Factory."
Despite these challenges, the study demonstrates that axion couplings to massive gauge bosons are not solely determined by quantum anomalies when heavy chiral fermions are present, offering a new pathway to probe the high-energy structure of the universe.
Summary updated