Average Consensus in Nearly Linear Time on Fixed Graphs and Implications for Decentralized Optimization and Multi-Agent Control

Alex OlshevskyarXiv 2014 · arXiv · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel distributed protocol for average consensus that achieves convergence in time linear to the number of agents ($n$), a significant improvement over previous quadratic bounds. This linear-time consensus protocol is then leveraged to develop similarly efficient distributed algorithms for crucial multi-agent tasks like formation maintenance, leader-following, and decentralized optimization of convex functions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the fundamental challenge of achieving "average consensus" in a distributed system of agents connected by a fixed, undirected graph. In average consensus, each agent has an initial value, and the goal is for all agents to collectively agree on the average of these initial values. This is a cornerstone problem for many multi-agent systems, from sensor networks to robotic swarms. Previous distributed protocols for this problem, while functional, often suffered from slow convergence, with their time complexity scaling quadratically or even exponentially with the number of agents ($n$). This slowness limits their practical applicability in large-scale or time-sensitive scenarios. The authors aim to break this bottleneck by developing a protocol with linear convergence time. Furthermore, they extend this to related problems like decentralized optimization, where agents collectively minimize a sum of functions they individually own, and formation control, where agents must maintain relative positions.

Methods

The core of the paper is a new distributed protocol for average consensus. This protocol involves each agent maintaining two states, $x_i(t)$ and $y_i(t)$. The update rule for $y_i(t)$ is a modified Metropolis-style consensus update, where agents weigh their neighbors' values inversely proportional to the larger of their degrees. The $x_i(t)$ state is then updated using an extrapolation step based on the difference between consecutive $y_i(t)$ values. This "momentum" term is key to accelerating convergence. A crucial assumption for achieving linear time is that all agents know an upper bound $U$ on the total number of agents, which is within a constant multiplicative factor of $n$.

The authors then demonstrate how this linear-time consensus protocol can be adapted for other problems:

  • Decentralized Optimization: They propose a protocol that uses the linear-time consensus mechanism to average subgradients of individual convex functions, leading to a convergence time of $O(n/e^2)$ for the objective function error.
  • Formation Maintenance: A protocol is presented where agents adjust their positions to achieve a desired formation, leveraging the consensus mechanism to ensure agreement on relative positions.
  • Leader-Following: This problem, where non-leader agents converge to a fixed value (the leader's value), is also addressed by adapting the consensus protocol.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical analysis and simulations on synthetic graph structures (line graphs, lollipop graphs, grids, geometric random graphs).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Linear Time Consensus is Achievable: The paper demonstrates that linear convergence time for average consensus on fixed graphs is not just a theoretical possibility but can be achieved with a practical, distributed protocol, provided agents have knowledge of an upper bound on the network size.
  • Momentum for Consensus: The introduction of an extrapolation step (momentum) in the consensus update is shown to be critical for accelerating convergence beyond the typical quadratic bounds.
  • Unified Framework: The paper elegantly shows how a single, efficient consensus protocol can serve as a building block for solving a range of related distributed multi-agent problems, including optimization and control.
  • The Role of Network Size Knowledge: The authors highlight that while distributed protocols are desirable, a small amount of global information (an upper bound on $n$) can significantly improve performance, enabling linear-time convergence where previously only quadratic was known.

Key Results

  • Average Consensus: A protocol is presented with a convergence time that scales linearly with the number of nodes ($n$), specifically $O(n \log (||y(1) - \bar{x}||_2 / \epsilon))$ for achieving an error of $\epsilon$. This is a significant improvement over the previous best of $O(n^2)$.
  • Decentralized Optimization: A distributed subgradient method is proposed with a convergence time of $O(n/e^2)$ for the objective function error, an improvement from $O(n^4/e^2)$.
  • Formation Maintenance and Leader-Following: Protocols are derived that also exhibit linear convergence times, directly benefiting from the core linear-time consensus result.
  • Specialized Graphs: For specific graph structures like 2D grids and geometric random graphs, the convergence time can be further improved to $O(\sqrt{n} \log n \log (||y(1) - \bar{x}||_2 / \epsilon))$.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Fixed Graphs: The primary limitation acknowledged is that the proposed linear-time consensus protocol is designed for fixed undirected graphs. The authors explicitly state that extending these results to time-varying graphs remains an open and challenging problem, as current best bounds for time-varying graphs are still quadratic.
  • Knowledge of U: The linear convergence time relies on the assumption that agents know an upper bound $U$ on the number of nodes, which is within a constant multiplicative factor of $n$. While this is a reasonable assumption in many scenarios, it's not universally applicable.
  • First-Order Model: The formation maintenance protocol uses a simplified first-order model for agent dynamics. More realistic models involving complex agent dynamics are a direction for future work.
  • Other Graph Classes: The paper suggests exploring convergence rates on other graph classes beyond grids and geometric random graphs.
  • Time-Varying Graphs: The most significant future direction mentioned is the extension of these linear-time results to time-varying communication graphs, which is crucial for many real-world applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

We describe a protocol for the average consensus problem on any fixed undirected graph whose convergence time scales linearly in the total number nodes $n$. The protocol is completely distributed, with the exception of requiring all nodes to know the same upper bound $U$ on the total number of nodes which is correct within a constant multiplicative factor. We next discuss applications of this protocol to problems in multi-agent control connected to the consensus problem. In particular, we describe protocols for formation maintenance and leader-following with convergence times which also scale linearly with the number of nodes. Finally, we develop a distributed protocol for minimizing an average of (possibly nondifferentiable) convex functions $ (1/n) \sum_{i=1}^n f_i(\theta)$, in the setting where only node $i$ in an undirected, connected graph knows the function $f_i(\theta)$. Under the same assumption about all nodes knowing $U$, and additionally assuming that the subgradients of each $f_i(\theta)$ have absolute values upper bounded by some constant $L$ known to the nodes, we show that after $T$ iterations our protocol has error which is $O(L \sqrt{n/T})$.
BibTeX
@misc{olshevsky2014average,
  author = {Alex Olshevsky},
  title = {{Average Consensus in Nearly Linear Time on Fixed Graphs and Implications for Decentralized Optimization and Multi-Agent Control}},
  year = {2014},
  eprint = {1411.4186},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1411.4186},
}

Loading related content...

Figure