Automated Critical PeakPricing Field Tests: 2006 Pilot ProgramDescription and Results

Mary Ann Piette, David Watson, Naoya Motegi, Sila Kiliccote

TL;DR

This paper details the 2006 pilot program for Automated Critical Peak Pricing (Auto-CPP) in commercial buildings. It demonstrates the technical feasibility and customer acceptance of automated demand response systems, showing significant peak demand reductions and providing valuable insights into the economics and operational aspects of such programs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the challenge of customer participation in Critical Peak Pricing (CPP) programs, which aim to reduce electricity demand during peak periods by offering variable pricing. A key barrier identified is the lack of customer knowledge and the manual nature of demand response (DR) activities. This manual process is labor-intensive and requires building operations staff to constantly monitor price signals and manually adjust systems. The paper explores how automation can overcome these hurdles, making DR participation more feasible, reliable, and cost-effective for commercial customers.

Methods

The study employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • Site Recruitment: 24 diverse commercial facilities (office buildings, retail stores, schools, etc.) were recruited in PG&E's territory.
  • Automation System Deployment: Participants worked with LBNL to select and implement control strategies for demand response, utilizing existing internet connectivity and building control systems (EMCS). Two automation equipment options were provided: web-service program source code or a Client and Logic with Integrated Relay (CLIR) Box.
  • Communication Testing: LBNL ensured the Demand Response Automation Server (DRAS) could correctly communicate CPP signals to each site's EMCS.
  • DR Strategy Evaluation: Various DR shed strategies were observed and evaluated for proper commissioning.
  • Demand Response Measurement: Two baseline models were used to estimate peak load savings:
  • CPP Baseline Model: Based on electricity consumption from noon to 6 p.m. for the three highest consumption days in the previous ten non-weekend days (not weather-normalized).
  • LBNL Adjusted OAT Regression Baseline Model: Weather-sensitive, using Outside Air Temperature (OAT) data and site electricity consumption from the previous ten days, adjusted with weather regressions.
  • Economic Analysis: The study assessed the CPP economics for each site by comparing credits earned on non-CPP days with charges on CPP days.
  • Surveys: Facility managers were surveyed about problems, comfort issues, and other relevant information.

Datasets

The study utilized the following data sources:

  • Site Electricity Consumption Data: Collected from InterAct™™ for 15-minute intervals.
  • Outside Air Temperature (OAT) Data: Gathered from NOAA, CIMIS, and on-site building weather stations.
  • HVAC, Controls, Communications, and Energy Time-Series Data: Collected from EMCS or other end-use meters.
  • Post-Event Surveys: Collected from facility operators regarding their perceptions and experiences.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Automation is Key: The study strongly reinforces that automation is crucial for increasing participation and reliability in demand response programs. It moves DR from a manual, labor-intensive task to a more institutionalized and repeatable process.
  • Technical Feasibility Proven: The Auto-CPP system demonstrated technical feasibility using existing technologies, with successful operation throughout the summer CPP period without significant technical issues.
  • Customer Acceptance is High: Participants generally found the automated system acceptable, with limited complaints regarding comfort, especially when communication and feedback were provided.
  • Weather-Normalized Baselines Matter: The LBNL adjusted OAT regression baseline model proved to be a significantly better predictor of load shape and demand savings compared to the non-weather-sensitive CPP baseline, particularly for weather-sensitive loads.
  • HVAC Strategies Dominate: Global temperature adjustment emerged as a common, effective, and least disruptive DR strategy, with other HVAC adjustments, lighting reductions, and some process modifications also employed.
  • Communication is Critical: Clear communication about the CPP tariff, expected charges, and credits is essential to address customer concerns, especially during periods with multiple CPP events.

Key Results

  • Participation: 24 facilities participated, with 14 being continuing sites from 2005.
  • Demand Reduction:
    • Average peak demand reduction was 14% of the whole-facility load during the three-hour high-price period.
  • Average peak demand reduction was 87 kW per facility, based on the OAT regression baseline.
  • An aggregated three-hour peak demand reduction of 1.2 MW was delivered on June 26, 2006.
  • Potential load reduction of 1.7 MW (six-hour) and 2.0 MW (three-hour) was estimated if all sites provided maximum reduction.
  • Occupant Comfort: During a severe heat wave in July 2006, all sites continued to participate, with some increase in occupant complaints and internal temperatures, but not to a disruptive level.
  • Economics: 11 out of 13 sites saved money under CPP, with an average cost reduction of $1,700 over the six-month period. The average payback period for automation setup was four years.
  • Automation Costs: Initial automation setup costs were estimated at $3,000 to $5,000 per site.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Small Commercial and Industrial Sites: The paper suggests exploring Auto-DR for smaller commercial and large industrial sites, as well as investigating how to connect DRAS with buildings lacking centralized EMCS.
  • Common Savings Evaluation Methods: A critical need is to develop standardized methods for estimating peak demand savings, moving beyond historical "bin" methods to dynamic models that incorporate weather data, peak load shapes, and HVAC system dynamics.
  • CPP Tariff Communication: Improved communication from utilities regarding the complexity of CPP tariffs, bill impacts, and predictive tools for charges and credits is recommended.
  • State Benefits of DR: More effort is needed to communicate the broader benefits of DR to the state electricity system to overcome marketing hurdles due to limited customer understanding.
  • Alternative Baseline Models: The study highlights the need for weather-adjusted baseline models for weather-sensitive loads, as the CPP baseline often underestimated demand.
  • New DR Tariffs and Economic Tools: Development of new tools to help customers understand their load shapes and DR strategies' impact on costs, along with exploring new tariff designs, is suggested to attract more participants.

Summary updated

Abstract

During 2006 Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (LBNL) and the Demand Response Research Center (DRRC) performed a technology evaluation for the Pacific Gas and Electric Company (PG&E) Emerging Technologies Programs. This report summarizes the design, deployment, and results from the 2006 Automated Critical Peak Pricing Program (Auto-CPP). The program was designed to evaluate the feasibility of deploying automation systems that allow customers to participate in critical peak pricing (CPP) with a fully-automated response. The 2006 program was in operation during the entire six-month CPP period from May through October. The methodology for this field study included site recruitment, control strategy development, automation system deployment, and evaluation of sites' participation in actual CPP events through the summer of 2006. LBNL recruited sites in PG&E's territory in northern California through contacts from PG&E account managers, conferences, and industry meetings. Each site contact signed a memorandum of understanding with LBNL that outlined the activities needed to participate in the Auto-CPP program. Each facility worked with LBNL to select and implement control strategies for demand response and developed automation system designs based on existing Internet connectivity and building control systems. Once the automation systems were installed, LBNL conducted communications tests to ensure that the Demand Response Automation Server (DRAS) correctly provided and logged the continuous communications of the CPP signals with the energy management and control system (EMCS) for each site. LBNL also observed and evaluated Demand Response (DR) shed strategies to ensure proper commissioning of controls. The communication system allowed sites to receive day-ahead as well as day-of signals for pre-cooling, a DR strategy used at a few sites. Measurement of demand response was conducted using two different baseline models for estimating peak load savings. One was the CPP baseline model, which is based on the site electricity consumption from noon to 6 p.m. for the three days with highest consumption of the previous ten non-weekend days; it is not normalized for weather. The second model, the LBNL adjusted outside air temperature (OAT) regression baseline model, is based on OAT data and site electricity consumption from the previous ten days, and it is adjusted using weather regressions from the fifteen-minute electric load data during each event day. These baseline models were used to evaluate the demand reduction during each DR event for each site. The aggregated response from all sites for each event was also estimated using both baseline models. The evaluation research also included surveying the facility managers regarding any problems or issues that arose during the DR events. Questions covered occupant comfort, controls issues, and other potential problems. This 2006 Auto-CPP study included an assessment of the CPP economics for each site. This consisted of summing all of the credits on non-CPP days and subtracting the charges on CPP days. Estimates of the CPP economics without the demand response control strategies were also developed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{piette2007automated,
  author = {Mary Ann Piette and David Watson and Naoya Motegi and Sila Kiliccote},
  title = {{Automated Critical PeakPricing Field Tests: 2006 Pilot ProgramDescription and Results}},
  booktitle = {Lawrence},
  year = {2007},
}

Loading related content...

Figure