Automata with Generalized Rabin Pairs for Probabilistic Model Checking and LTL Synthesis

Krishnendu Chatterjee, Andreas Gaiser, Jan Kretínský

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new type of automaton called Deterministic Automata with Generalized Rabin Pairs (DGRW) that allows for more compact representations of system properties expressed in Linear Temporal Logic (LTL). This new formalism leads to significant performance improvements in probabilistic model checking and LTL synthesis, outperforming existing methods by orders of magnitude in practical evaluations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Model checking, a crucial technique for verifying the correctness of systems, often relies on translating temporal logic formulas (like LTL) into automata. For probabilistic systems and synthesis problems, a key step is converting these LTL formulas into deterministic Rabin automata (DRW). However, the standard "Safra's determinization" procedure, while effective, can lead to a significant blow-up in the size of the resulting automaton, making subsequent analysis computationally expensive. This paper tackles the challenge of generating smaller, more manageable automata for LTL properties, specifically focusing on the (F,G) fragment of LTL, to improve the efficiency of probabilistic model checking and LTL synthesis.

Methods

The core contribution of this paper is the introduction of Deterministic Automata with Generalized Rabin Pairs (DGRW). Unlike traditional DRW, DGRW employ a more complex acceptance condition that is a disjunction of "generalized Rabin pairs." Each generalized Rabin pair is a conjunction of Büchi and co-Büchi conditions.

The authors present:

  • A Safraless Translation: They show that LTL(F,G) formulas can be directly translated into DGRW, resulting in automata with the same number of states as a direct translation to Muller automata but with a more amenable acceptance condition. This translation is shown to be significantly more compact than existing methods that produce DRW.
  • Efficient Algorithms for DGRW: Crucially, the paper develops direct algorithms for probabilistic model checking and game solving that operate on DGRW, avoiding the need to first convert them into DRW. This direct approach is key to achieving performance gains.
  • Theoretical Analysis: They provide theoretical bounds and analyze the speed-up achieved by their DGRW-based approach compared to traditional DRW-based methods, highlighting a multiplicative factor improvement based on the complexity of the generalized Rabin pairs.
  • Experimental Implementation: The proposed approach has been implemented and integrated into the PRISM model checker, demonstrating substantial practical improvements.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical contributions and experimental evaluation using a benchmark protocol.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • DGRW as a Sweet Spot: DGRW offer a compelling balance. They allow for compact automata representations (similar to Muller automata) while retaining an acceptance condition that is algorithmically efficient to handle, unlike general Muller conditions.
  • Avoiding the Blow-up: The paper demonstrates that the blow-up associated with converting to DRW is often unnecessary for probabilistic model checking and synthesis. DGRW provide a more direct and efficient path.
  • Significant Practical Gains: The experimental results show that the DGRW approach can lead to improvements of orders of magnitude in model checking time, especially for complex fairness constraints. This suggests that the theoretical advantages translate directly into practical benefits.
  • Generalization of Rabin Conditions: The concept of "generalized Rabin pairs" is a key innovation, allowing for more expressive and compact acceptance conditions than standard Rabin pairs.

Key Results

  • Compact Automata: For the LTL(F,G) fragment, DGRW can be significantly more compact than DRW. For example, a formula requiring a DRW with over a million states was translated to a DGRW with only 64 states.
  • Probabilistic Model Checking Speed-up: The DGRW-based approach offers theoretical speed-ups by a multiplicative factor of $jk$ and $jk^2+k$ compared to translating to DRW, where $j$ and $k$ relate to the complexity of the generalized Rabin pairs.
  • Experimental Improvements: In experiments with the Pnueli-Zuck randomized mutual exclusion protocol, the DGRW-based PRISM implementation showed improvements of "order of magnitude" over the existing DRW-based implementation. For games, the speed-up was even greater.
  • Synthesis Efficiency: The paper also shows how DGRW can speed up LTL synthesis by avoiding the degeneralization step to Rabin games, leading to a speed-up factor of $|B|^k$ where $|B|$ is the degeneralization index and $k$ is the number of pairs.

Limitations and Future Work

  • LTL Fragment: The current work focuses on the (F,G) fragment of LTL.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest extending their approach to LTL with the U (until) and X (next) operators. They also propose exploring symbolic computation and Long's acceleration of fixpoint computation for games, comparing it to their ranking function-based algorithm.

Summary updated

Abstract

The model-checking problem for probabilistic systems crucially relies on the translation of LTL to deterministic Rabin automata (DRW). Our recent Safraless translation [KE12, GKE12] for the LTL(F,G) fragment produces smaller automata as compared to the traditional approach. In this work, instead of DRW we consider deterministic automata with acceptance condition given as disjunction of generalized Rabin pairs (DGRW). The Safraless translation of LTL(F,G) formulas to DGRW results in smaller automata as compared to DRW. We present algorithms for probabilistic model-checking as well as game solving for DGRW conditions. Our new algorithms lead to improvement both in terms of theoretical bounds as well as practical evaluation. We compare PRISM with and without our new translation, and show that the new translation leads to significant improvements.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chatterjee2013automata,
  author = {Krishnendu Chatterjee and Andreas Gaiser and Jan Kretínský},
  title = {{Automata with Generalized Rabin Pairs for Probabilistic Model Checking and LTL Synthesis}},
  booktitle = {CAV},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-642-39799-8\_37},
}
Figure